|
Post by DubipR on Aug 13, 2024 7:27:44 GMT -5
Nothing finer than curling up with a good comic book. What's on your pull list this week?
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Aug 13, 2024 9:37:51 GMT -5
- Houses of the Unholy HC - Rifters #3 - Sensational She-Hulk #10 - Jonny Quest #1
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 14, 2024 15:08:50 GMT -5
Robin Lives! continues to be a slow burn but I'm really enjoying the tension behind Jason's rehabilitation and Bruce's own personal quest following almost losing Jason.
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Aug 14, 2024 17:51:10 GMT -5
I got kind of busy and ended up not going to the comic shop last week. Which wasn’t any big deal because I only had one comic on my list, and that was Birds of Prey.
This week was pretty slim as well, with only She-Hulk.
However, while I was browsing, I looked at Gotham City Sirens and I really liked the deluxe cover for the second issue. I’ve been cutting down a little bit on comic books, plus there’s no Catwoman and Harley Quinn this month, so I decided to grab both issues of Gotham City Sirens. It’s a four-issue mini series that will be concluded in two weeks, so why not?
Birds of Prey #12 Gotham City Sirens #1 Sensational She-Hulk #10 Gotham City Sirens #2
I’ve been very hot and cold on Birds of Prey. I really like the line-ups, but the stories are so obviously written for the trade, and they tend to drag on more than a little bit. However, I liked #12 quite a bit. Very amusing, and they seem to have moved the story forward enough that they can wrap it up next issue. Hoosier X likes that!
It’s the last issue of this volume of She-Hulk. What a mixed bag it’s been! There was stuff I liked and stuff that I didn’t like. The romance with Jack of Hearts never worked at all!
I’m so glad I picked up Gotham City Sirens! What a breath of fresh air! I didn’t like it that they were trapped so easily at the end of the second issue. When I open up the third issue, I’m going to pretend that the last few pages of the previous issue weren’t very lazily written.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 15, 2024 8:04:11 GMT -5
The one two punch of Gail Simone and Rainbow Rowell on Action Comics continues to be really solid. With Superman facing off against a sadistic alien Olympics with the Earth at stake Gail delivers a really classic story with a lot of fun energy to it while Rowell's Lois and Clark back up really hits hard as the duo grapple with how their relationship works now that Lois is editor in chief of the Daily Planet.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 15, 2024 8:25:00 GMT -5
Unlike my disappointment with Flash Gordon, Joe Kelly really did Johnny Quest right. It really does feel like an authentic continuation of the old show and I can't wait to see where it goes next.
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Aug 15, 2024 10:08:43 GMT -5
Unlike my disappointment with Flash Gordon, Joe Kelly really did Johnny Quest right. It really does feel like an authentic continuation of the old show and I can't wait to see where it goes next. Yeah. It was surprisingly good. The art was a bit off here and there but a solid story set-up. I need to find the FCB story in which this comes off of to get the bigger picture. Flash Gordon was unreadable.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Aug 16, 2024 7:34:59 GMT -5
I thought Flash was pretty good... I like they are doing something different. It could definitely go south, and there were some really silly things in it (just the fact that Flash was able to get up after being tied down for some long period of time and be an action hero, never might that he STOPPED TO SHAVE BEFORE ESCAPING)
I can see that being off-putting, but I'm curios where they will go and the art was good.
Kinda reminds me of the Nottingham series as far as being content you don't expect with a long running property.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 16, 2024 12:16:52 GMT -5
I thought Flash was pretty good... I like they are doing something different. It could definitely go south, and there were some really silly things in it (just the fact that Flash was able to get up after being tied down for some long period of time and be an action hero, never might that he STOPPED TO SHAVE BEFORE ESCAPING) I can see that being off-putting, but I'm curios where they will go and the art was good. Kinda reminds me of the Nottingham series as far as being content you don't expect with a long running property. I thought the action and art were both pretty solid and if it was just a new sci-fi adventure book I'd probably be interested in it more...but for a Flash Gordon book it just felt too generic to me.
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Aug 16, 2024 20:02:53 GMT -5
That's fair... perhaps more Flash-ness is coming
|
|
|
Post by MRPs_Missives on Aug 16, 2024 21:14:36 GMT -5
That's fair... perhaps more Flash-ness is coming When the book was first announced and the FCBD issue solicited, I reached out to Jeremy Adams and asked if this was going to be a reboot or reinvention of Flash (since so many of those over the years in different mediums had been so lackluster and I didn't want to get my hopes up), and he responded no, what he wanted to do was to pick up Flash's story with the idea "What happens after Flash saves Earth and defeats Ming?" He didn't want to retell what Alex Raymond did, he didn't want to re-envision Flash to be more contemporary, didn't want to reinvent the wheel to tell a Flash Gordon story, he just wanted to explore what came after. And from what I can tell from the FCBD and 1st issue, he's doing exactly that. Which means that a lot of the familiar trappings we think of for Flash Gordon stories in terms of the traditional conflict of Flash vs. Ming and the exploring/making alliances with the various other rulers of Mongo kingdoms are off the table because that story has already been resolved, so it might take some time to establish the new status quo moving forward from that. I thought the first issue was ok, not great, but not terrible. It felt like it was trying to start a bit "in medias res" after a bit of a small time jump after the defeat of Ming, and I hope it takes some time in coming issues to fill in the gaps of what happened. It might not have been the best way to launch a new series, but as was mentioned, the art and action worked well. I think the "it didn't feel like Flash Gordon" thing though could be a result of the approach of that moving forward from the defeat of Ming decision. It's Flash, but without the tropes of "the Earth is in jeopardy" "it's everybody scheming for or against Ming" "let's present all these weird kingdoms and their petty rulers and see where they are in for/against Ming dynamic and which ones will betray Flash or betray Ming after their initial alliance is declared" that we are all familiar with and expect in a Flash Gordon story, because that story has been told and this is the next story with the character-something that hasn't been attempted much outside of some of the later comic strips, and those always seemed to devolve into Ming returns and takes over and just rehashes the same conflict in different terms (much the same trap I saw books like Micronuats fall into with Baron Karza). It's like we had one great story to tell but no one knew what to do next so we keep falling back on retelling different versions of the same story. And part of that is fans keep expecting that same story and seem unwilling to let that one conflict go, so it defines expectations of what a Flash Gordon (or Micronauts of Batman or fill in many other long running characters) is or has to be. I'm not sure if Adams will succeed with this, but I am glad to see him try, and I will reserve judgment for now. -M
|
|
|
Post by Dizzy D on Aug 17, 2024 17:04:39 GMT -5
X-Factor #1 by Mark Russell and Bob Quinn
What Happened Before: The mutant island state of Krakoa is gone, mutants are back to living among humans (mostly). X-Factor is a team, partly owned by Angel that works for the government while also being mutant celebrities.
Plot: Rodger Broderick is a TV producer who has convinced the U.S. Government that mutants are both becoming popular and are powerful assets to be used in their wars. He has recreated the team of X-Factor, co-owned by Angel who functions as its leader, with members Feral (formerly of X-Force), Rusty Collins (ward of X-Factor and former New Mutant) and new characters (as far as I know) Xyber (a mutant with electric powers and Cameo (a shapeshifter). The team is not quite as popular as Rodger hopes, lacking the more reknown mutants and are seen as sell-outs by other mutants. On the first mission, most of the team is killed leaving only Angel and Xyber alive. Angel is wounded and needs to recover, Xyber is immediately assigned to the replacement team lead by Havok with members Frenzy, Pyro, Cecilia Reyes and new character Granny Smite.
Does this sound familiar? A team of superheroes that are heavily marketed and merchandised running into a lethal mission and being immediately replaced leaving their surviving members depressed and disillusioned? It's almost point by point the plot of X-force #116, the first issue of the Pete Milligan and Mike Allred run which later was renamed to X-statix. Except this lacks the humor of Milligan and Allred's art and designs. This felt like somebody went, what's the most popular X-Factor run? Peter David's government team. What's the most popular X-Force run? (Arguably) Milligan's celebrity superheroes. Let's mix those two together even though that makes very little sense.
Art: Bob Quinn is a capable artist, but nothing in this book stands out. The designs of the new characters are rather boring. Oh and the cover is by Greg Land, so that's a turn-off as well.
Overall: This was really disappointing. Everything else I read by Mark Russell was very good, but I can't recommend this in any way. A big deal is that this seems just like a lesser version of X-Force/X-Statix. There are some continuity quibbles: - Havok and Polaris are back together (after being apart for 10 years and Havok being with Madelyne Pryor last we saw), just to break up again in this issue. - Angel is disappointed by the quality of his team, but scoffs at Frenzy as one of the potential recruits, though Frenzy has been on the main X-Men team for several times now and has proven to be both powerful and reliable. - Cecilia Reyes volunteers for this team, but she has always only been interested in being a medical doctor, not a superhero. - Rusty Collins (using his rarely used codename Firefist) is insulted when a reporter asks him if being a member of the team is a lifelong dream, and retorts that he was a member of the original X-Factor team (he wasn't, he was being trained by them but I'd say that's a big difference). Oh and another nitpick: Most of the team and their opponents are killed when a stray bullet hits the plastic explosives X-Factor placed to blow up their target's base. Plastic explosives don't explode when being hit by bullets (and no, they didn't hit the detonator, they hit the plastic mass itself) Now all of these are minor complaints, but they add up and generally if somebody has a more interesting take than continuity established, than go with it, but I'm noticing all these small things, because there is nothing here to make up for it.
There is also a weird scene where Darkstar asks Havok to join her team, where they are both in a house that is carried by a helicopter to their secret base with no explanation given.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 18, 2024 18:24:02 GMT -5
That's fair... perhaps more Flash-ness is coming When the book was first announced and the FCBD issue solicited, I reached out to Jeremy Adams and asked if this was going to be a reboot or reinvention of Flash (since so many of those over the years in different mediums had been so lackluster and I didn't want to get my hopes up), and he responded no, what he wanted to do was to pick up Flash's story with the idea "What happens after Flash saves Earth and defeats Ming?" He didn't want to retell what Alex Raymond did, he didn't want to re-envision Flash to be more contemporary, didn't want to reinvent the wheel to tell a Flash Gordon story, he just wanted to explore what came after. And from what I can tell from the FCBD and 1st issue, he's doing exactly that. Which means that a lot of the familiar trappings we think of for Flash Gordon stories in terms of the traditional conflict of Flash vs. Ming and the exploring/making alliances with the various other rulers of Mongo kingdoms are off the table because that story has already been resolved, so it might take some time to establish the new status quo moving forward from that. I thought the first issue was ok, not great, but not terrible. It felt like it was trying to start a bit "in medias res" after a bit of a small time jump after the defeat of Ming, and I hope it takes some time in coming issues to fill in the gaps of what happened. It might not have been the best way to launch a new series, but as was mentioned, the art and action worked well. I think the "it didn't feel like Flash Gordon" thing though could be a result of the approach of that moving forward from the defeat of Ming decision. It's Flash, but without the tropes of "the Earth is in jeopardy" "it's everybody scheming for or against Ming" "let's present all these weird kingdoms and their petty rulers and see where they are in for/against Ming dynamic and which ones will betray Flash or betray Ming after their initial alliance is declared" that we are all familiar with and expect in a Flash Gordon story, because that story has been told and this is the next story with the character-something that hasn't been attempted much outside of some of the later comic strips, and those always seemed to devolve into Ming returns and takes over and just rehashes the same conflict in different terms (much the same trap I saw books like Micronuats fall into with Baron Karza). It's like we had one great story to tell but no one knew what to do next so we keep falling back on retelling different versions of the same story. And part of that is fans keep expecting that same story and seem unwilling to let that one conflict go, so it defines expectations of what a Flash Gordon (or Micronauts of Batman or fill in many other long running characters) is or has to be. I'm not sure if Adams will succeed with this, but I am glad to see him try, and I will reserve judgment for now. -M I think you nailed exactly what I was feeling. I think so much of what I love about Flash Gordon is the exploration of Mongo and seeing Flash meet all the other strange races of the world so not getting any of that threw me a little bit. Hopefully it finds it's footing as it goes and I'm willing to wait and see but for my money I think Johnny Quest and Dick Tracey did a much better job of capturing the feeling of the original.
|
|