|
Post by Cei-U! on Dec 15, 2023 5:01:59 GMT -5
The 1990s are often disparaged by fans as the nadir of the American comic book. I heartily disagree. Even ignoring the wealth of quality comics available outside the Big Two, there were some damn fine funnybooks produced during that decade. One of my favorites was (and is) Starman, James Robinson's saga of Jack Knight and his reluctant assumption of his father's role and responsibilities as wielder of the Cosmic Rod. Among the series' many assets was its portrayal of a super-villain who, to that point, had been about as one-dimensional as comic book characters get. Which leads us to today's selection: 10. The Shade
This 4-issue mini-series spotlights the mysterious master of darkness and his 150-year long feud with the murderous Ludlow family. There are a handful of guest stars both well-known (The original Flash, Scalphunter) and obscure (The Spider, Captain X of the RAF) but the story is firmly focused on its immortal protagonist. Narrated in a non-linear but easily followed manner by Shade himself, it gives us further insight into his complex and sometimes contradictory personality, acknowledging both his acts of ruthless villainy and his occasional bouts of nobility. Each issue is drawn by a different artist (Gene Ha, J. H. Williams, Bret Blevins, and Michael Zulli) and though the quality drops noticeably post-Williams, none of it is what I would characterize as bad. But the real star here is Robinson, whose dialogue has a poetry and rhythm that suits this story very well. I approached re-reading this series with a bit of trepidation, fearing it would've lost some of its luster since I last read it twenty-odd years ago. I needn't have worried. Cei-U! I summon the nyctophobia!
|
|
|
Post by MRPs_Missives on Dec 15, 2023 5:21:41 GMT -5
Third Day of Christmas: A femme fatale for the Saturday morning cartoon crowdJezebel Jade, originally appearing in comics in the pages of Jonny Quest, and spinning off into her own 3 issue mini-series. She was a femme fatale and the foil/romantic interest for Race Bannon. It’s hard to ignore the impact of a Dave Stevens cover, but she was a standout character in the JQ series, and getting her mini by Messner-Loebs with art and covers by a young Adam Kubert was a no-brainer. I was always a sucker for the strong femme fatale type, but this one had a heart of gold underneath it all, but never mention that (unless you happen to be Race Bannon). -M
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,871
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 15, 2023 5:27:29 GMT -5
10. MagikFirst Appeared in: Giant-Size X-Men #1 (1975) Spin-offs: Magik (1983), New Mutants (1984) Sure, it really felt like Chris Claremont was trying to rip off the only thing about New Teen Titans that wasn't swiped directly from the X-Men (go ahead, fight me), but the darkchylde was so much younger...and we'd known her for eight years as an innocent tag-along before she was mercilessly transformed. Claremont managed to take a character absolutely no one cared about and turn her into one of the most memorable X-characters of all time. Best of all, while Kurt made an excellent case for why the New Mutants does not count as a spin-off as originally published, Magik's addition to the team only a little over a year in gave it a more direct link to its predecessor. In my mind, New Mutants was pretty much reborn at this point, with new characters, far superior art that appealed to a more mature audience, and (especially) a more direct tie to the X-Men as a spin-off.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2023 5:27:58 GMT -5
10. Squadron Supreme (1985)First appearing in Avengers #85 (and based off of an earlier evil incarnation, the Squadron Sinister), the Squadron is of course a direct rip on the Justice League. In 1985, the team fully spun off into a 12 issue limited series masterfully written by Mark Gruenwald. The story explores a scenario where the superheroes decide they can run the world better than the regular humans and proceed to do just that. I personally love this one as much as a lot of other "groundbreaking" comic book work from this time.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Dec 15, 2023 6:07:33 GMT -5
10. Darkdevil(3-part mini-series, 2000) Darkdevil, created by Tom DeFalco and Pat Olliffe, was first introduced in the Spider-girl series that was launched in the late 1990s (for those who may not be familiar, this iteration of Spider-girl is the teenage ‘Mayday’ Parker, the daughter of Peter and Mary Jane, created by Tom DeFalco and Ron Frenz). In fact, he first appeared in Spider-girl #2 (1998) and then made a number of subsequent appearances in that series. He's something of anti-hero, and apparently as much of an antagonist for Spider-girl as an ally. His real name is Reilly Tyne, and among other things he’s the son of Ben Reilly (the Spider-clone), and, well, his origin is too convoluted to summarize. I’ll just say here that it involves him inheriting some of the spider-powers thanks to this parentage, but there’s also a supernatural element (which is where the connection to Daredevil comes from). In fact, this mini-series is basically his origin story, which is very effectively told in a series of flashbacks that punctuate the action surrounding the main plot-line, wherein the Kingpin (now in prison) has put out a hit on one of the candidates in the NY mayoral campaign. So even though there’s a lot of exposition, the story, by Tom DeFalco and Ron Frenz, is pretty dynamic and fast-paced. I also found the art, by Ron Frenz and Al Milgrom, quite nice. I should point out that besides Darkdevil, the only other material from this Spider-girl universe (also known as ‘MC2’) I’ve read is another mini-series featuring a character called the Buzz, which I would consider a spin-off but realized does not qualify under this year’s rules (his first and only appearance prior to his mini was a solo back-up story in the Spider-girl 1999 Annual). These two minis were collected in a digest that I have and both are really fun. I’ve now read them multiple times, and they make me want to read more MC2 stuff – which is why they, well Darkdevil anyway, made my list this year.
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Dec 15, 2023 6:12:17 GMT -5
#10
HawkeyeFirst appearance: Tales of Suspense #57 1964 Creators: Stan Lee / Don Heck Series covered : Solo Avengers # 1-10 1987 Series Team: Tom Defalco/ Mark Bright/Joseph Rubinstein/ Jose Marzan
I consider Hawkeye one of my favorite characters in all my comics reading life. I first became aware of him in the 70’s while reading reprints of silver age Avengers stories in Marvel Triple Action. The kooky quartet stories of the Avengers that lasted from Avengers # 16-26 cemented his wiseguy rebellious personality that was kind of original for the comics genre. He challenged Captain America's authority from the beginning but you knew that he had a heart of gold underneath. In the 80’s the Avengers expanded to a franchise of titles , adding West Coast Avengers and Solo Avengers. The latter starred two stories , one being a Hawkeye lead feature and the second, a story with any one of the rest of the team. There have been 2 other mini series with Hawkeye before this but these tales went deeper into his past. For example, You find out it was someone else that taught him archery (Trick shot) and he had to settle a debt with that person. For the most part, I feel he works best in the pages of the Avengers as a supporting cast member, but this 40 issue run was solid stuff.
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Dec 15, 2023 6:22:07 GMT -5
10. Squadron Supreme (1985)First appearing in Avengers #85 (and based off of an earlier evil incarnation, the Squadron Sinister), the Squadron is of course a direct rip on the Justice League. In 1985, the team fully spun off into a 12 issue limited series masterfully written by Mark Gruenwald. The story explores a scenario where the superheroes decide they can run the world better than the regular humans and proceed to do just that. I personally love this one as much as a lot of other "groundbreaking" comic book work from this time. I never knew there was a distinction between the Squadron Sinister and the Squadron Supreme.
|
|
|
Post by MWGallaher on Dec 15, 2023 6:25:37 GMT -5
10. Black Panther in JUNGLE ACTION #6-18, Marvel Comics, September 1972-November 1975 Spun off from FANTASTIC FOUR #52, July 1966 By Don McGregor with Rich Buckler, Gil Kane, Billy Graham, Klaus Janson et al. Those of you who read my Jungle Gems or Jungle Junk thread know that I gave my first sampling of this highly-regarded run a highly negative review. I’d gone into it eager to trash writer Don McGregor’s tin ear and penchant for overblown writing, looking for flaws and deficiencies. As I’d hoped, other forum members came to its defense, and did so heartily and convincingly, so I committed myself to attempting to read the entire saga from the beginning, with an open mind. And thus did I become a convert. OK, gang, I get it. Marvel’s first graphic novel, coming unexpectedly out of nowhere, “Panther’s Rage” was a groundbreaking, ambitious, richly plotted work that walked a fine line between respecting the norms of both the superhero comic (throwing a parade of newly-created, memorable super-villains at our hero) and the jungle comic (challenging our hero with a menagerie of menacing jungle beasts) while upsetting others: it featured an almost entirely all-Black cast, told an extended story with genuine consequence from beginning to satisfying end, didn’t waste too much valuable panel space on hand-holding rehash. It provided a map of Wakanda early on, and demonstrated a well-planned out structure by using the locations shown as the story played out. It generated a convincing sense of concern for the hero’s survival, most remarkably in a single issue over the course of which T’Challa, already at a disadvantage with his mystic panther powers limited thanks to an interrupted ritual, is progressively wounded, his costume in tatters, crawling home barely alive. The supporting cast are not just a collection of character types, but well-developed characters with distinct personalities and drives. McGregor’s weaknesses are still there, but they are compensated for; once sucked into the story, his florid prose feels not so much like pretentiousness but more like an integral part of the experience. You can bet I'll be reading McGregor's two follow-ups to this epic. Thanks a million to the members whose well-reasoned and polite counterarguments convinced me to give it a try. I wouldn't have suspected that a classic comic I read for the first time just days before the annual CCC event would rise to the ranks of my top 12, but this morning, while writing up what I had originally slotted for this position, I realized that it had!
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Dec 15, 2023 6:57:03 GMT -5
#10 – Hit-Girl #1–5 (2012–13) Spinning out of Mark Millar's Kick-Ass, the Hit-Girl mini-series sees the titular foul-mouthed, pre-teen killing machine starring in her own comic for the first time. Here, Mindy McCready (a.k.a. Hit-Girl) attempts to settle down to life as a regular High School kid, navigating romantic interest from boys and cruel bullying from girls, while trying not to spill anybody's blood. Oh, and she's still intent on cleansing the streets of New York City of its organised crime contingent. I know it's not everybody's cup of tea, but I loved the black humour and cartoonish ultra-violence of Kick-Ass and that very much continues into this Hit-Girl mini-series. Undoubtedly, part of her appeal is the contradictory juxtaposition of a sweet-looking 12-year-old girl who is also a skilled enough fighter to kill adult gangsters and hoodlums in the most bloodthirsty and gory ways. She's like Betty Kane's Batgirl, if Batgirl behaved like Frank Castle in the Punisher MAX series! The twist here though is that while Mindy can easily murder a dozen gun-toting mobsters, making it through High School, with all its social complexities and toxic bullying culture, is another matter. Not that Hit-Girl is a particularly clever book; Millar is certainly not embarrassed to be writing a shallow, self-aware comic, with blood and guts a-plenty. So, while this mini-series does deal with school bullying to a degree, the totally over-the-top and massively tongue-in-cheek slaughter is never very far away. John Romita Jr's art is very much in his later, blocky stye, which you'll either love or hate. Personally, I'm a fan, so that's OK. You can also tell that Romita is really enjoying himself having to draw so much over-the-top violence and gore (it's not something he really got to do in his regular Marvel assignments). To sum up, Hit-Girl is, in all honesty, a pretty shallow comic, with lots of sickening violence, ridiculously unrealistic action sequences and plenty of dark humour. Simply put, it's a really fun read! There have been subsequent Hit-Girl solo series, but this initial one is the only one that was published before the Jan 2014 cut off for this year's Classic Comics Christmas event.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Dec 15, 2023 7:04:12 GMT -5
I never knew there was a distinction between the Squadron Sinister and the Squadron Supreme. They are two different groups; the Squadron Sinister first appeared in Avengers #69 and they were villains from the main Marvel universe (616, as we're supposed to call it) assembled by the Grand Master. The Nighthawk from that Squadron later became a Defender (after he helped foil a plot by the Squadron Sinister in that series), while that version of the Whizzer became the Spider-man villain Speed Demon. The Squadron Supreme are heroes in an alternate universe - kind of like the Earth 2 universe to the 616 Earth 1. In fact, the evil Hyperion from Squadron Sinister appears in the Squadron Supreme series mentioned in supercat's post above.
|
|
|
Post by commond on Dec 15, 2023 7:14:08 GMT -5
#10 Jezebel Jade #1-3 (1988)Spun off from Comico's Johnny Quest series. My pick for day 10 is also Jezebel Jade. Comico's Johnny Quest is one of the best adventure series I've read. Just a pure joy. When I was coming up with a list for this year's topic, I kept racking my brain for spinoffs of comics I love as much as Johnny Quest and I couldn't think of many good ones. It seems the reason for that is because most spinoffs are created by an entirely different creative team, and in the case of 80s independent publishers like Comico often quite inexperienced creators. This book is an exception, however. It's got regular Johnny Quest scribe, William Messner-Loebs, scripting it, and a young Adam Kubert penciling, inking, coloring and lettering it. This book just pops. If you're only used to Marvel Kubert, like I was, this is a different beast. The wrap-around cover for issue one alone may be the best wrap-around cover ever.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Dec 15, 2023 8:04:03 GMT -5
Day Three (#10) Howard the Duck For a while there, some of the best social and comic book satire you could ever read. Even non-comics fans cottoned to Howard’s Whitmanesque “Waauuugh!” hurled at a ridiculous world full of hairless stalking apes. And naturally, it was a world he never made. I didn’t stay with Howard, who had popped up out of nowhere in Man-Thing story that I hadn’t read, but for about 15 issues or so, he made me laugh and provided a haven of relatively adult humor and commentary on everything from politics to martial arts movies. To comic books themselves. Steve Gerber’s Howard was a self-appointed spokesman for Everyman (in other words, every human being out there) who is appalled by having to deal with insanity gussied up as sanity, absurdity presented as normality and idiocy masquerading as reason. That he was a cigar-smoking duck just made everything he said that much funnier. There was a smidgeon of Kafka in those early issues. But, like so much satire, Howard (and perhaps Gerber) ran out of juice because his kind of attitude never changes and lacks nuance as much as that of any institution he’s criticizing. It’s an anthropomorphic version of keep your wiffleball off my lawn stuff, which itself becomes parody instantaneously. And Gerber’s satire was quite specific, to its time and place, which meant that it was funny and perceptive... but ephemeral. And a non-stop screed, which was Howard’s style is too one-dimensional to retain much power for very long. However, in 1976, when the first issue hit the stands, mainstream comics were in another of their typical ruts and Howard provided the proverbial much needed lift. I guess it was as close as Marvel was going to come to publishing an underground comic, the artwork (for the couple of years when I read it at least) was usually quite good, and until things got repetitive, Howard was entertaining. Not an insignificant accomplishment for a guy, um, duck who had popped up in a horror comic a few years earlier.
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Dec 15, 2023 9:22:16 GMT -5
Flying fast in for the Third Day... #10- Mr. Majestic (1999-2000/2005-2006)When Image was created in the 90s, the early days of the books were meh. The crew was still learning the ropes on how to write and promote their books. Jim Lee's WildCATS was a mediocre team book. Great concept but was just flat. A race of Aliens fights another race of aliens, the Kherubim versus the Daemonites. The Cats were pretty neat but it wasn't until issue 11, Lord Majestros was introduced. A mighty warrior in the house of Khera, he was a powerhouse. Basically Lee's Superman but with that '90s edge'. Lee created a Superman pastiche that pushed his abilities of being not afraid of using all their power. Mr. Majestic, to the Earth, became a feature player and sometimes star of the monthly. It was until 1999 that he got his chance to have is own monthly. Image writers Jason Hoguin and Joe Casey, along with mega-star artist Ed McGuiness gave Majestic the much need boost to the character. Remember the days when superheroes save cats from trees and move planets in the same series? Taking a page from the Silver Age Superman comics and applying modern sensibilities and action, Mr. Majestic was the answer to that. Taking on galaxy threats to save the solar system, to time paradoxes and going on dates with cyborgs, it's fun and action packed. When Wildstorm was bought by DC, Majestic makes a huge splash in Superman, when he disappears and Majestic takes over the duties of handling Metropolis. When Superman comes back, Majestic makes his way back to his universe and a relaunch of another short-lived series. Writers Danny Abnett & Andy Lanning made an incredible cosmic feel to Wildstorm's big man.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Dec 15, 2023 9:29:59 GMT -5
#10. Moon Knight
Him again! A graduate from the Werewolf by Night academy, Moon Knight was already the star of his own comic when I discovered him. He was, basically put, what I thought Batman should be. The few issues I read had no costumed super-villains and dealt with things like drug trafficking and jilted lovers. It felt new, despite treading old ground; it felt a bit more authentic than other similar titles. Part of its appeal was how straightforward it was: you had the hero with simple motivations, stock market money that explained how he could afford his toys, you had the girlfriend who was neither a perpetual hostage nor a ninja/sorceress/heir to a crime empire; you had the trusted sidekick/mechanic. Just enough toys in the toybox, and no crippling and convoluted backstory. Plus, there was the idiosyncratic Bill Sienkiewicz art, which was at the same time familiar and innovative (Bill had moved beyond his Neal Adams phase at that point). Reading the Moon Knight Essentials a few years ago, I realize that I was lucky with the issues I had read way back when; in the Essential, there were quite a few issues inked by people whose style didn't mesh with Sienkiewicz's. The most beautiful ones were the ones he inked himself, and they were often very impressive. "My" Moon Knight is a street-level do-gooder, who turned to vigilantism to atone for his past life as a mercenary (and because he's addicted to action). The Egyptian theme of his costumed identity might have been a hallucination and was not referenced too often. He was not suffering from multiple personality disorder, he was not the avatar of a god, he did not deserve the insane continuity nightmare that his comic-book career would turn into. He's also a good example of how a one-time villain in a C-list book can outgrow his origins!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2023 10:19:44 GMT -5
Day 3 Chili
First appearance: Golden-Age Millie the Model
Chili is a 1969-73 26-issue humour spinoff from the long-running Millie the Model series (Atlas/Marvel) starring Millie's friend/bitter rival Chili Storm. She was featured throughout the Millie series and provided one of the main sources of slapstick comedy.
Chili, who tends to be egotistical, vain and self-centered, is frequently on the receiving end as payback for her negative traits. The series is largely an Anthology Comic with multiple short Chili stories in each issue.
Incidentally, Millie the Model’s long running series (207 issues) and Chili’s much shorter run (26 issues and an annual) ended in the same year, 1973!
Naturally, any Archie-esque humour genre is a must have for yours truly. Not to mention every girl clique has its resident Chili Storm.
|
|