|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 4, 2022 9:51:55 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKS!What did you read this week?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 5, 2022 7:57:07 GMT -5
Gotham City: Year One #1Written by Tom King Art by Phil Hester Summary: In 1961, a baby is stolen from the Wayne family and PI Slam Bradley gets stuck right in the middle of the mystery. Plot: Now, before I go any further, I'll say that Tom King is a good writer and more than capable of spinning an entertaining yarn; for instance I loved his take on Dick Grayson as a master spy in Grayson, and his Batman/Elmer Fudd one shot was seriously one of the best Batman stories I've ever read...but like that rhyme about the little girl with a curl down the middle of her head, while Tom King can be good, when he's bad he's rotten(I'm looking at you Supergirl and Human Target).But this was a book with Slam Bradley as the lead and I love Slam so I took the chance. Now, this issue isn't rotten by any stretch of the word but it does play heavily into what dragged down some of his previous missteps in that much of the plot is blatantly stolen from elsewhere(and with out attribution) with only the thinnest of veneers plastered over it to make it look original. In this case, rather than stealing the plot from a well known movie he copies the events of the notorious Lindbergh abduction down to a tee, including every specific element from who discovered the missing child and the cobbled together ladder straight down to the exact text of the ransom letter...only changing the odd circular symbol to a crudely drawn bat-symbol. On top of that, King throws in Slam getting bagged for the death of his partner which is taken right from the Maltese Falcon right down to the body being found at the bottom of a muddy hill. It's a fun setting, and he really does have a good handle on the techniques of telling a proper crime noir story...but it kills me just how much is "borrowed" from other sources. Other than inserting Slam Bradley, setting in Gotham and involving the Wayne family everything else of note is wholly unoriginal. It's slam though, so unlike Human Target where I dropped it when I saw how bad it ripped D.O.A. I'm going to try and stick it out a little bit longer. Art: Phil Hester is one of my all time favorite artists and I have never understood why he doesn't get more work. In this issue in particular, Hester's art does an utterly amazing job of making the story feel like a real deal pulp detective story. The bold lines and dark shadows are perfect for capturing that city lights through a pair of blinds look that is typical of a proper noir film...and unlike King, although Hester captures that aesthetic none of his images are actually traced directly from a film scene which makes it all the better. Grade:6.5/10
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Oct 5, 2022 8:32:27 GMT -5
Gotham City: Year One #1Written by Tom King Art by Phil Hester Summary: In 1961, a baby is stolen from the Wayne family and PI Slam Bradley gets stuck right in the middle of the mystery. Plot: Now, before I go any further, I'll say that Tom King is a good writer and more than capable of spinning an entertaining yarn; for instance I loved his take on Dick Grayson as a master spy in Grayson, and his Batman/Elmer Fudd one shot was seriously one of the best Batman stories I've ever read...but like that rhyme about the little girl with a curl down the middle of her head, while Tom King can be good, when he's bad he's rotten(I'm looking at you Supergirl and Human Target).But this was a book with Slam Bradley as the lead and I love Slam so I took the chance. Now, this issue isn't rotten by any stretch of the word but it does play heavily into what dragged down some of his previous missteps in that much of the plot is blatantly stolen from elsewhere(and with out attribution) with only the thinnest of veneers plastered over it to make it look original. In this case, rather than stealing the plot from a well known movie he copies the events of the notorious Lindbergh abduction down to a tee, including every specific element from who discovered the missing child and the cobbled together ladder straight down to the exact text of the ransom letter...only changing the odd circular symbol to a crudely drawn bat-symbol. On top of that, King throws in Slam getting bagged for the death of his partner which is taken right from the Maltese Falcon right down to the body being found at the bottom of a muddy hill. It's a fun setting, and he really does have a good handle on the techniques of telling a proper crime noir story...but it kills me just how much is "borrowed" from other sources. Other than inserting Slam Bradley, setting in Gotham and involving the Wayne family everything else of note is wholly unoriginal. It's slam though, so unlike Human Target where I dropped it when I saw how bad it ripped D.O.A. I'm going to try and stick it out a little bit longer. Art: Phil Hester is one of my all time favorite artists and I have never understood why he doesn't get more work. In this issue in particular, Hester's art does an utterly amazing job of making the story feel like a real deal pulp detective story. The bold lines and dark shadows are perfect for capturing that city lights through a pair of blinds look that is typical of a proper noir film...and unlike King, although Hester captures that aesthetic none of his images are actually traced directly from a film scene which makes it all the better. Grade:6.5/10 I agree with your review 100%. This is just typical King aping more classic noir films and trying to make it cool. The dialogue was clunky as hell and like you mentioned, just pastiches of real events and films. I was expecting Eddie Mueller to barge in and correct King for his nonsensical writing. Hester is always amazing but right now, I feel his pencils and inks are wasted on this drek.
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Oct 5, 2022 8:47:46 GMT -5
A decent downloads to read...
- Gotham City: Year One 1 (Disappointed) - Batman 128 (Not a good Zdarsky starting arc. I'm hoping he goes somewhere with it) - Ant Man 4 - Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty 6 - Spider-Man 1 - That Texas Blood 18
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Oct 5, 2022 16:24:27 GMT -5
I read Batman #128. I'm not crazy about this arc by Zdarsky but the art is beautiful. I had a lot of hope that he would write a great Batman because his Daredevil has been excellent. It's just ok. Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #5. Still enjoying this arc. I felt this was much better than Sam's book this month. Hope the ending next issue is great.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 6, 2022 8:38:02 GMT -5
I read Batman #128. I'm not crazy about this arc by Zdarsky but the art is beautiful. I had a lot of hope that he would write a great Batman because his Daredevil has been excellent. It's just ok. Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #5. Still enjoying this arc. I felt this was much better than Sam's book this month. Hope the ending next issue is great. Batman's actually growing on me, I'm still not crazy about the idea of another story about Batman's contingency plans biting him in the ass as we've seen that already but there's enough here that despite not being super original its still entertaining. I really liked the characterization of Bruce and the use of the Justice League was great. I think my big hope is that after he's done with this big action set piece story Zdarsky goes small and focuses more on the characters.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 6, 2022 8:41:08 GMT -5
Gotham City: Year One #1Written by Tom King Art by Phil Hester Summary: In 1961, a baby is stolen from the Wayne family and PI Slam Bradley gets stuck right in the middle of the mystery. Plot: Now, before I go any further, I'll say that Tom King is a good writer and more than capable of spinning an entertaining yarn; for instance I loved his take on Dick Grayson as a master spy in Grayson, and his Batman/Elmer Fudd one shot was seriously one of the best Batman stories I've ever read...but like that rhyme about the little girl with a curl down the middle of her head, while Tom King can be good, when he's bad he's rotten(I'm looking at you Supergirl and Human Target).But this was a book with Slam Bradley as the lead and I love Slam so I took the chance. Now, this issue isn't rotten by any stretch of the word but it does play heavily into what dragged down some of his previous missteps in that much of the plot is blatantly stolen from elsewhere(and with out attribution) with only the thinnest of veneers plastered over it to make it look original. In this case, rather than stealing the plot from a well known movie he copies the events of the notorious Lindbergh abduction down to a tee, including every specific element from who discovered the missing child and the cobbled together ladder straight down to the exact text of the ransom letter...only changing the odd circular symbol to a crudely drawn bat-symbol. On top of that, King throws in Slam getting bagged for the death of his partner which is taken right from the Maltese Falcon right down to the body being found at the bottom of a muddy hill. It's a fun setting, and he really does have a good handle on the techniques of telling a proper crime noir story...but it kills me just how much is "borrowed" from other sources. Other than inserting Slam Bradley, setting in Gotham and involving the Wayne family everything else of note is wholly unoriginal. It's slam though, so unlike Human Target where I dropped it when I saw how bad it ripped D.O.A. I'm going to try and stick it out a little bit longer. Art: Phil Hester is one of my all time favorite artists and I have never understood why he doesn't get more work. In this issue in particular, Hester's art does an utterly amazing job of making the story feel like a real deal pulp detective story. The bold lines and dark shadows are perfect for capturing that city lights through a pair of blinds look that is typical of a proper noir film...and unlike King, although Hester captures that aesthetic none of his images are actually traced directly from a film scene which makes it all the better. Grade:6.5/10 I agree with your review 100%. This is just typical King aping more classic noir films and trying to make it cool. The dialogue was clunky as hell and like you mentioned, just pastiches of real events and films. I was expecting Eddie Mueller to barge in and correct King for his nonsensical writing. Hester is always amazing but right now, I feel his pencils and inks are wasted on this drek. I love Noir Alley! And yeah, it was definitely overbearing at times. You can tell King loves crime noir...but he just can't seem to put enough of his own voice in it. He can write well...this just isn't it, but I love Slam so I'm holding out hope it gets better.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 6, 2022 18:24:23 GMT -5
I picked up Gun Honey Blood for Blood #2 but the covers are too risque to post here.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 7, 2022 7:54:55 GMT -5
Sword of Azrael #3Written by Dan Watters Art by Nikola Cizmesija Summary: In order to rescue Brielle and stop her from being turned into an "angel" like himself JPV must confront the origins of his order. Plot:Dan Watters continues to make Azrael a must read book, as not only is a great superhero yarn but the deep characterization and world building are top notch. In the latest issue Watters makes this an ever better read for me as he takes the book in a serious turn towards horror as he explores the origins of the order of St. Dumas. Like a great horror story, it starts slow and moody, throws in a dash of mystery and melancholy before it bursts into action right at the end. A sleepy old Italian villa in the shadow of an ancient volcano, missing children going back decades and a myth of a dark beast...these are classic elements of a horror story and tying them into Azrael's back story not only makes for a great read but it deepens the character as well, giving him a unique niche in DC's world. On top of that I loved the way it tied into the greater cosmology of the DC universe with the way it showed us that the battle between the angel and demon who fell to Earth, the very genesis of te Azrael program was actually a battle between Orion and Kalibak making the technology that created Azrael from the New Gods...or possibly from Apocolypse, which is a really interesting question. And the monster at the end being the first angel of St.Dumas? He was a fantastic Frankenstein Monster like creature that totally stole the scene and that he was meant to be the embodiment of Satan was a great addition that will really make JPV question himself even more. I can't wait to read more and although this is part three of six I'm hoping it continues much further than that. Art: In terms of cohesion between the art and the story I really think this is the best issue yet. In this chapter Cizmesija really dialed in his style to better fit the tone of the story and the book is so much better for it. In this issue we see a greater emphasis on deep shadows and he's also scaled back his manga inspired stylization which gives the book a more realistic and darker tone which helps highlight that classic horror feel. I can't wait to see what he does next month when the battle with the first Angel really kicks into full gear! Grade:9/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Oct 8, 2022 12:44:50 GMT -5
I read Batman #128. I'm not crazy about this arc by Zdarsky but the art is beautiful. I had a lot of hope that he would write a great Batman because his Daredevil has been excellent. It's just ok. Captain America: Sentinel of Liberty #5. Still enjoying this arc. I felt this was much better than Sam's book this month. Hope the ending next issue is great. Captain America was really good, I was genuinely shocked when Bucky shot Revolution(and maybe Steve?) in the conclusion and it'll be interesting to see what happens next.
|
|