|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jun 29, 2021 16:17:53 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKSReal reviews by real readers
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Jun 30, 2021 10:37:26 GMT -5
Green Arrow: 80th Anniversary 100-Page Super Spectacular.
The first story is by Mariko Tamaki & Javier Rodriguez. It is told in the style of a 1940's Green Arrow & Speedy story from More Fun Comics. I really liked this one but I also like Green Arrow stories from the 40's & 50's.
The next story is by Tom Taylor & Nicola Scott. It co-stars Wildcat & Black Canary and is from the early 60's era of GA.
Stephanie Phillips & Chris Mooneyham tell a JLA story that highlights GA's relationships with the JLA in the 70's. Especially his arguments with Hawkman. This one was not one of my favorites since I really felt the old Green Arrow/Hawkman rivalry felt forced.
Mike Grell tells a story from his era when GA was living in Seattle with Black Canary. This one felt like it could have been a reprint from that time. Pretty good at capturing the tone of those stories.
Then Ram V & Chris Mitten tell a story from the post Grell era.
Then a Connor Hawke story by Brandon Thomas & Jorge Corona. I like Connor so I enjoyed this one.
Then Devin Grayson & Max Fiumara tell a Roy Harper/Arsenal centric story. I always like a decent Roy Harper tale.
Then a nice Arrow Family tale by Phil Hester from the Kevin Smith/Judd Winnick era. Like the Grell story this captured the mood & tone of that run.
Vita Ayala & Laura Braga have a GA/BC story that highlights the time they shared a comic.
Next Ben Percy & Otto Schmidt tell a story from their era. Another classic run IMO.
Jeff Lemire & Andrea Sorrentino are next with a story that showcases why their GA run is a classic. Sorrentino was awesome as an artist.
And finally Larry O'Neil & Jorge Forns do a wordless story paying tribute to Larry's Dad Denny O'Neil who died last year. Nice thoughtful story that touched me. Denny revitalized Ollie back in the early 70's moving him away from 30 years of a Batman clone to the version we have had the last 50 years. Denny elevated GA from a minor DC character to one of the major ones that headlined a whole TV universe on the CW TV.
Green Arrow has been blessed with some really great artists over the years.
DC has done another fantastic job with another 100 page 80th Anniversary special that celebrates their top characters. This type of issue gives you a glimpse into each era of these characters over the last 80 years.
Highly recommended.
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Jun 30, 2021 10:53:05 GMT -5
The Mighty Crusaders: The Shield. by Rob Liefeld and David Gallaher.
The story gives us a brief recap of the 4 different Shield's: William Higgins. Joe Higgins. Lancelot Strong. Victoria Adams. It also provides a glimpse of the Mighty Crusaders. Flygirl. Capt Commando. Jaguar. Black Hood. The Comet. The Fox. Lancelot Strong. And Victoria Adams/Shield.
It then shows Joe Higgins as the Shield fighting the Burning Hand and ends with Victoria & Dusty Simmons (Higgins sidekick during the 40's) asking the Crusaders to vote on how to save their different realities...
I felt this had potential to lead into a decent mini series but I guess this will be all we get. Liefeld's art has shown improvement although he still avoids any background details.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 1, 2021 7:11:23 GMT -5
Green Arrow: 80th Anniversary 100-Page Super Spectacular.
The first story is by Mariko Tamaki & Javier Rodriguez. It is told in the style of a 1940's Green Arrow & Speedy story from More Fun Comics. I really liked this one but I also like Green Arrow stories from the 40's & 50's.
The next story is by Tom Taylor & Nicola Scott. It co-stars Wildcat & Black Canary and is from the early 60's era of GA.
Stephanie Phillips & Chris Mooneyham tell a JLA story that highlights GA's relationships with the JLA in the 70's. Especially his arguments with Hawkman. This one was not one of my favorites since I really felt the old Green Arrow/Hawkman rivalry felt forced.
Mike Grell tells a story from his era when GA was living in Seattle with Black Canary. This one felt like it could have been a reprint from that time. Pretty good at capturing the tone of those stories.
Then Ram V & Chris Mitten tell a story from the post Grell era.
Then a Connor Hawke story by Brandon Thomas & Jorge Corona. I like Connor so I enjoyed this one.
Then Devin Grayson & Max Fiumara tell a Roy Harper/Arsenal centric story. I always like a decent Roy Harper tale.
Then a nice Arrow Family tale by Phil Hester from the Kevin Smith/Judd Winnick era. Like the Grell story this captured the mood & tone of that run.
Vita Ayala & Laura Braga have a GA/BC story that highlights the time they shared a comic.
Next Ben Percy & Otto Schmidt tell a story from their era. Another classic run IMO.
Jeff Lemire & Andrea Sorrentino are next with a story that showcases why their GA run is a classic. Sorrentino was awesome as an artist.
And finally Larry O'Neil & Jorge Forns do a wordless story paying tribute to Larry's Dad Denny O'Neil who died last year. Nice thoughtful story that touched me. Denny revitalized Ollie back in the early 70's moving him away from 30 years of a Batman clone to the version we have had the last 50 years. Denny elevated GA from a minor DC character to one of the major ones that headlined a whole TV universe on the CW TV.
Green Arrow has been blessed with some really great artists over the years.
DC has done another fantastic job with another 100 page 80th Anniversary special that celebrates their top characters. This type of issue gives you a glimpse into each era of these characters over the last 80 years.
Highly recommended.
I thought about picking this up, the writers and artists attached to it are great...but I've just never been a Green Arrow fan.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 1, 2021 7:34:02 GMT -5
Star Wars Adventures: Weapon of a Jedi #2Based on the novel by Jason Fry Scripted by Alec Worley Art by Ruari Coleman Summary: In the ruins of the ancient Jedi temple Luke continues to hone the skills passed on to him by his departed master, Obi-Wan Kenobi. Plot: Collecting parts three and four of the strip originally exclusively published in the German language Star Wars fan magazine this issue was every bit as amazing as the first. When telling stories set between the scenes, so to speak, it can be easy to go overboard and present things that feel out of touch with where we know the story already goes and that's especially true when you're talking about Star Wars. It would have been far too easy to show Luke learning amazing talents from this adventure to a Jedi temple but they wouldn't have lined up with what we saw of his talents at the start of Empire Strikes back, fortunately Worley has a deft hand with this universe and the characters that inhabit it and side stepped that continuity drama entirely. Instead of granting him new Jedi powers Worely has Luke practice the skills already imparted to him by Obi-Wan and he does it in a way that still feels new and exciting. The whizz of the target droids is familiar but the renewed focus feels strong and Luke's drive to learn with out the guidance of a master is incredibly compelling and not only fits in to his quest to find Yoda in Empire but gives you a little back ground information into just why Luke was so eager to jump after that chance when it seemed his friends needed him the most.
The story isn't without its flaws however, we never see just how Luke escapes the Empire and makes his way back to the Alliance at the end, and although the fight with the Scavanger was fantastically done he was still really lacking in characterization. With the way he referred to the Jedi as sorcerers it recalled the way the Mandalorian referred to the Jedi but he wasn't wearing mando armor and as he died at the end it isn't likely we'll ever learn more about him which is slightly dissatisfying. Still and all this was a fantastic comic and I'm still jealous that the German fan magazine gets amazing stories like this while Marvel continues to churn out mostly drivel these days.
Art: I think my favorite part of the art here is the way Coleman draws Luke's lightsaber. Instead of a more film accurate cylinder like beam Coleman went with the style seen in that original Star Wars poster with the arcing flare at the hilt and the beam coming to a point at the end. It's a great stylistic nod and totally my preferred look for lightsabers as it just feels way more dynamic than they usually appear whether it be on film or comics. Grade:9/10
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Jul 1, 2021 10:02:43 GMT -5
That Texas Blood #7 by Chris Condon & Jacob Phillips That Texas Blood returns after a six month hiatus. Sheriff Joe Bob Coates is back in Ambrose County and feeling moody about an old case. And that's really what we get this issue. A little look at Coates, his bailiwick and a look back at the tip of the iceberg of a case he handled in the 80s when he was still a deputy. In lesser hands that could be boring, but Condon & Phillips are up to the task. My one bit of trepidation is that the case seems to be another 80s, Satanic ritual/cult case. And frankly, I'm tired of that trope...even more tired of it now than I was when I lived through that B.S. at the time. But I'm hopeful after the last arc (and with Phillips' history working with Brubaker and his Dad) that they can avoid the worst of the tropes. Well worth a read...but I'm concerned about where this story is going to go.
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Jul 1, 2021 10:39:06 GMT -5
I thought about picking this up, the writers and artists attached to it are great...but I've just never been a Green Arrow fan. I agree these are for fans of the character not casual readers. Although these do make a nice starting point for new readers to showcase the history of the character. I have not bought any anniversary issues from DC or Marvel of characters that I never was a fan of. I do prefer DC's approach to this over Marvel's.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 1, 2021 18:25:43 GMT -5
I thought about picking this up, the writers and artists attached to it are great...but I've just never been a Green Arrow fan. I agree these are for fans of the character not casual readers. Although these do make a nice starting point for new readers to showcase the history of the character. I have not bought any anniversary issues from DC or Marvel of characters that I never was a fan of. I do prefer DC's approach to this over Marvel's. Yeah, DC's anniversary issues have really been top notch in terms of quality.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 1, 2021 19:17:30 GMT -5
Usagi Yojimbo: The Dragon Below Conspiracy #1Pencils and story by Stan Sakai Colored by Ronda Pattison Cover by David Peterson Summary: Suspecting a plot against the Shogun the ever loyal Lord Noriyuki sends Tomoe to investigate Lord Tamakuro's new fortress. Plot: A lot of people (and I believe shaxper is one of them) would probably list Grasscutter as their favorite Usagi "epic" but for my money T he Dragon Below Conspiracy is by far my favorite long form Usagi story so I was really excited to see it get a new colorized version so I could revisit it once again and it didn't disappoint. I think the main reason I love this story so much is because that it has a lot of what I consider to be Stan's greatest strengths as a storyteller all rolled into one comic: great action, lots of intrigue, amazing characterization, an ability to weave in interesting historical tid-bits, humor and a great supporting cast. That last element is incredibly strong in this first issue in particular as we get three parallel stories featuring Gen hunting a bounty, Tomoe investigating one of Lord Hikiji's vassals, Usagi aimlessly wandering the roads...and one of my all time favorite supporting characters: Zato Ino the Blind Swordspig! Each little plot gives the character in question their own character moment that not only establishes them as characters but also gives them good cause for their individual threads to combine into one story in a completely organic way. Art: While there is no new art here the addition of color by Ronda Pattison does make for a fun new way to experience an old favorite. When these new colorized versions first started coming out I initially was disappointed that they were going to be digitally colored rather than done in the traditional way Parrison has shown a deft hand at applying the colors to the art in an appropriate way. That said there are a couple of panels where the typical errors associated with digital coloring do rear their ugly heads, with the most egregious being the flashback of Tomoe talking to Lord Noriyuki where I feel the digital shading is a bit much, making him look more black and gray than his natural black and white but that aside it is still really well done. On top of that I really love the new cover by David Peterson of Mouseguard fame, I really love his slightly shaggy looking Usagi as it really gives him an appropriately road weary look and I'm really excited to see what else he gives us as the story continues. Grade:9/10
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,867
Member is Online
|
Post by shaxper on Jul 1, 2021 21:18:26 GMT -5
A lot of people (and I believe shaxper is one of them) would probably list Grasscutter as their favorite Usagi "epic" Nope, but I definitely agree Dragon Bellows is underrated. Nice to see it receiving new life in print!
|
|
|
Post by Hoosier X on Jul 1, 2021 23:36:17 GMT -5
Green Arrow! Has it really been 80 years? It seems like 800.
(Sorry. It’s just second nature to bag on poor Ollie. He’s such an easy target! I’m not proud of it. I blame Scipio at The Absorbascon.)
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 2, 2021 7:27:19 GMT -5
A lot of people (and I believe shaxper is one of them) would probably list Grasscutter as their favorite Usagi "epic" Nope, but I definitely agree Dragon Bellows is underrated. Nice to see it receiving new life in print! These colorized classics are definitely fun and I hope they're proving to be a good entry point for new readers.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Jul 3, 2021 9:24:10 GMT -5
Chibi-Usagi: Attack of the Heebie ChibisBy Julie and Stan Sakai Summary: Chibi-Usagi and his pals Chibi-Tomoe and Chibi-Gen rescue a Dogu village from the evil King Fire Salamander! Plot: With a double shot of Usagi this just feels like its your kind of week shaxper ! Now, personally I'm not the biggest fan of chibi books as I tend to like more detailed art but if paired with a story with some substance instead of just cutesy gags these kinds of books can be fun and the JUST Sakai team( as they Julie and Stan label themselves here) delivers just that. While on the cute side and with stakes much lower than your average Usagi book it still retains the kind of energy, sense of exploration and the same cultural insights that make for a good Usagi book so it really lives up to the all ages banner by having layers of story that can be enjoyed by readers both young and old. Though not super threatening I really liked the idea of the villain being a fire salamander...who actually breathed fire! While a fire breathing character wouldn't fly in the regular Usagi book it was a fun visual here, giving the villain a slight Godzilla feel to him and that's never a bad thing! Also included here in this awesome book was the 2020 Free Comic Book day issue of Usagi which was titled "Attack of the Teenie Titans" which while I remembered being announced I completely missed due to covid last year. Unlike the main story, which was in the chibi style from start to finish, this second feature had the "normal" Usagi visit the chibi world after a battle with a tengu which was really fun. The contrast between the two art styles was a great look and the way the "real" Usagi scared away the Chibi-Jei really made me smile. So all and all this was a fantastic book that any Usagi fan should pick up post haste! On a slightly different topic I really love just the title itself! I may be reading it wrong, but the way the subtitle plays off of the phrase "Heebie Jeebies" which makes me think that I may have been pronouncing the word chibi incorrectly my entire life. I've always pronounced chibi with the "i" sound being similar to bib, but the play on heebie jeebies makes me think chibi should sound like that same double "e" sound. Does anyone know which is the correct way to say it? Art: Julie and Stan give themselves equal billing here and don't mention who did what so it's hard to single either out for praise so I suppose all one can say is that JUST really did a fantastic job putting this together. On the color front, as much as I like and respect the work Rhonda has been putting in on the Color Classic line I feel like the more pastel choices Emi Fuji choose for this book really fit Usagi's world better. It has an almost water colored look that I really enjoy and I'd love to see more of that in the traditional Usagi books. Grade:10/10
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Jul 3, 2021 14:57:46 GMT -5
MY stuff for this week:
Redemption #5 : Entirely predictable, but perfect ending to the mini. Very good story that will read great as a trade if you like CLassic Westerns, with Mike Dedato doing steampunk-ish art.
Star Wars: High Republic #6 : Apparently we're not done wit the Drengir yet... I really hope Sskeer lives for the next storyline. It is fun to see the Hutts as (Sort of) good guys. For the rest, I'd like to see more exploration of the historical period and less action, but it's not terrible.
Black WIdow #8 : Pretty slow moving, but some good character bits, actually exploring the after effects on a hero after a traumatic event could be good if they go down that road far enough. Seems a bit deep for a main MU book, though, so I don't expect they will. STill, the I'm liking this version of Natasha.. definitely worth sticking with.
Beta Ray Bill #4 : Bill and Scuttlebutt free themselves from a giant squid... Surtur next issue (and the merciful end of the mini)
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Jul 3, 2021 16:11:40 GMT -5
DubipR's picks of the week:
- That Texas Blood #7: Slam's wrap up is dead on. I'm happy it's back. First issue of the new arc, I'm interested to see how this plays. I love Condon's research and dedication to the comic and prose back pieces that add to the story. They're so rich and flesh out the world he's building. Phillips' artwork is superb.
- Crossover #7: Donny Cates has created an insane but amazing series with Crossover. I love what he's doing in bridging comics and the real world together. It's fun and crazy and makes for great reading. This time guest writer Chip Zdarsky fills in with Ande Parks doing the art chores. The ending is a doozy and I look forward to more of Cates. He's one of my favorite writers at the moment.
- Kane and Able: I'm a big fan of Shaky Kane's books. He writes and draws such weird world stuff. If you're a fan of Bulletproof Coffin, this one is for you as it's a continuation of sorts. I've seen bits and pieces of Krent Able's work before but this is first time for a full comic. Dark and twisted. Gory and funny. The two of them combine to create a quirky comic
|
|