|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 23, 2021 17:19:43 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKS!The Web's place for real, honest, user generated reviews! What did YOU read this week? (Yes, You, right there!)
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 24, 2021 8:53:30 GMT -5
Batman/Superman #16Written by Gene Luen Yang Art by Ivan Reis Summary: Witness the first meeting of the World's Finest...but with a mystery spanning two worlds perhaps that should be Multiverse's Finest? Plot: Of all of the titles and creative teams announced as part of DC’s new Infinite Frontier era Yang was one of the writers I was most excited to see as I absolutely loved Superman Smashes the Klan and unlike my reaction to Ram V's Swampthing(another anticipated book) I'm glad to say my expectations were definitely met. I can't say it for certain shaxper but it looks like Yang was as big a fan of Superman: Man of Steel #5 as I was, as he fully co-opts the movie serial format used there to tell this story of the first meeting of Batman(and Robin!) and Superman of two different worlds. However, unlike in Simonson's tale, Yang uses the film technique to a much greater impact on the story as they are not only used through out the whole story, the tones used actually feel like the old Batman and Superman movie serials, and they are also used as physical representations of the two separate worlds that Superman and Batman live in. And those two worlds were just so fun to explore here, I mentioned already they feel like the old movie serials with Clark slinking away with a knowing wink and Batman and Robin having a wholesome partnership and on top of that they exist in worlds that don't have each other in them...though there are interesting twists that represent them as Alfred lives under Wayne Manor and operates as a Bane like criminal mastermind in Superman's world and in Batman's we see that Superman's rocket ship didn't make it intact to Earth but there is a mysterious fortress at the North Pole suggesting someone from Krypton did make it. And in the end something from outside these world's burns a whole in the films allowing the two stories to cross over which was a real fun effect. I don't know where this meeting of the Multiverse's Finest will Ultimately go but the energy is amazing so I'm locked in for sure. Art: What more can really be about the amazing work of Ivan Reis? If you're looking for someone who just seems to "get" what a classic superhero comic should look like he really is your guy. His look is just so bright and clean that it just instantly invokes that feeling of nostalgia that I find I really crave when it comes to a good superhero book. In this book in particular I really loved his use of the filmstrip structure with the dual narratives; and while it didn't leave a ton of room for complex layouts, it did give a great showcase for Reis' storytelling abilities and how subtle changes in style really affect tone in these two tales. Grade:10/10
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,867
|
Post by shaxper on Mar 24, 2021 9:30:41 GMT -5
Yang uses the film technique to a much greater impact on the story as they are not only used through out the whole story, the tones used actually feel like the old Batman and Superman movie serials, and they are also used as physical representations of the two separate worlds that Superman and Batman live in. And those two worlds were just so fun to explore here, I mentioned already they feel like the old movie serials with Clark slinking away with a knowing wink and Batman and Robin having a wholesome partnership and on top of that they exist in worlds that don't have each other in them...though there are interesting twists that represent them as Alfred lives under Wayne Manor and operates as a Bane like criminal mastermind in Superman's world and in Batman's we see that Superman's rocket ship didn't make it intact to Earth but there is a mysterious fortress at the North Pole suggesting someone from Krypton did make it. Stop making me interested in new comics, dammit!
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Mar 24, 2021 9:39:16 GMT -5
I might check out Batman/Superman based on above review. I won't be able to get my books this week due to work schedule.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 24, 2021 16:13:26 GMT -5
Yang uses the film technique to a much greater impact on the story as they are not only used through out the whole story, the tones used actually feel like the old Batman and Superman movie serials, and they are also used as physical representations of the two separate worlds that Superman and Batman live in. And those two worlds were just so fun to explore here, I mentioned already they feel like the old movie serials with Clark slinking away with a knowing wink and Batman and Robin having a wholesome partnership and on top of that they exist in worlds that don't have each other in them...though there are interesting twists that represent them as Alfred lives under Wayne Manor and operates as a Bane like criminal mastermind in Superman's world and in Batman's we see that Superman's rocket ship didn't make it intact to Earth but there is a mysterious fortress at the North Pole suggesting someone from Krypton did make it. Stop making me interested in new comics, dammit! I might check out Batman/Superman based on above review. I won't be able to get my books this week due to work schedule. It was a seriously fun book, and totally worth checking out. To quote the youngins, sorry, not sorry Shax
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 24, 2021 17:43:11 GMT -5
Alien #1Written by Phillip Kennedy Johnson Art by Salvador Larroca Summary:Gabriel Cruz is ready for a well earned retirement from the Weyland-Yutani Corporation but his estranged son might bring him back. Plot: I've long ban a fan of the world of Aliens, from the films to the books and comics I've tried just about all of them over the years so when Disney bought Fox I knew it was only a matter of time before Aliens comics left Dark Horse and came to Marvel and now that its here I'm a little underwhelmed. I had high hopes as I love Phillip Kennedy Johnson's work with Last Gods and his Dark Crystal book but this was a huge miss for me...so much that I can't see myself picking up issue two. There's no attempt at building tension, no real sense of mystery or discovery and as such there's no real horror either which is a huge failure for an Alien book. Art: Compounding the issue this book had with its empty feeling narrative is the artwork by Larroca, which is so straight forward that there's never a sense that something could jump out at you at any moment which is probably the most important element of any Aliens story. It's perhaps a predictable issue with Larroca, he has a style that often relies on photo-referencing and although it can often deliver some iconic images it can also come off as very flat and lifeless and that's what we got here. This is a perfect one-two punch of awfulness; a horror story with a tension-less plot and art with out energy or emotion. Grade:0/10 I don't think I've ever delivered a rating this low.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,867
|
Post by shaxper on Mar 24, 2021 23:03:25 GMT -5
Alien #1Written by Phillip Kennedy Johnson Art by Salvador Larroca Summary:Gabriel Cruz is ready for a well earned retirement from the Weyland-Yutani Corporation but his estranged son might bring him back. Plot: I've long ban a fan of the world of Aliens, from the films to the books and comics I've tried just about all of them over the years so when Disney bought Fox I knew it was only a matter of time before Aliens comics left Dark Horse and came to Marvel and now that its here I'm a little underwhelmed. I had high hopes as I love Phillip Kennedy Johnson's work with Last Gods and his Dark Crystal book but this was a huge miss for me...so much that I can't see myself picking up issue two. There's no attempt at building tension, no real sense of mystery or discovery and as such there's no real horror either which is a huge failure for an Alien book. Art: Compounding the issue this book had with its empty feeling narrative is the artwork by Larroca, which is so straight forward that there's never a sense that something could jump out at you at any moment which is probably the most important element of any Aliens story. It's perhaps a predictable issue with Larroca, he has a style that often relies on photo-referencing and although it can often deliver some iconic images it can also come off as very flat and lifeless and that's what we got here. This is a perfect one-two punch of awfulness; a horror story with a tension-less plot and art with out energy or emotion. Grade:0/10 I don't think I've ever delivered a rating this low. Wow. Is there any chance they are delivering such a straight forward start in order to catch you off guard in issue 2?
|
|
|
Post by DubipR on Mar 25, 2021 6:46:24 GMT -5
My only comic purchase of the week was from a Kickstarter back in the summer of 2020. Noir Is the New Black
A collection of noir and noir-esque short stories by some of the best African American comic creators. People like David F. Walker (Power Man & Iron Fist, Bitter Root, Brandon Easton (Transformers, various animated shows), Gary Phillips (crime novelist and comic writer of AngelTown), Shawn Martinbourgh, and many more. Tales of murder, mystery and mayhem. What's not to love? You can order a copy at Fair Square Comics' website.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 25, 2021 7:45:12 GMT -5
Alien #1Written by Phillip Kennedy Johnson Art by Salvador Larroca Summary:Gabriel Cruz is ready for a well earned retirement from the Weyland-Yutani Corporation but his estranged son might bring him back. Plot: I've long ban a fan of the world of Aliens, from the films to the books and comics I've tried just about all of them over the years so when Disney bought Fox I knew it was only a matter of time before Aliens comics left Dark Horse and came to Marvel and now that its here I'm a little underwhelmed. I had high hopes as I love Phillip Kennedy Johnson's work with Last Gods and his Dark Crystal book but this was a huge miss for me...so much that I can't see myself picking up issue two. There's no attempt at building tension, no real sense of mystery or discovery and as such there's no real horror either which is a huge failure for an Alien book. Art: Compounding the issue this book had with its empty feeling narrative is the artwork by Larroca, which is so straight forward that there's never a sense that something could jump out at you at any moment which is probably the most important element of any Aliens story. It's perhaps a predictable issue with Larroca, he has a style that often relies on photo-referencing and although it can often deliver some iconic images it can also come off as very flat and lifeless and that's what we got here. This is a perfect one-two punch of awfulness; a horror story with a tension-less plot and art with out energy or emotion. Grade:0/10 I don't think I've ever delivered a rating this low. Wow. Is there any chance they are delivering such a straight forward start in order to catch you off guard in issue 2? I doubt it, there's literally nothing there that holds my interest. The father was an ex-Weyland/Yutani security officer who apparently encountered the aliens sometime shortly after the events of Aliens had zero personality, and his son was a terrorist who stormed into the space station and immediately killed the first two guards he saw(who happened to be the only two characters who received any real characterization in the book) so it's not like it's a slow build to get you to care about the human interest before launching into the horror...it's just a huge misfire, which is really surprising for such a high profile launch. There was an attempt in the opening to explore the father's emotional scars from his encounter with the aliens that almost seemed interesting...but it was so superficial that it couldn't keep me interested and when he visited the counselor (who was a Bishop android seemingly just to have a connection with the films) again it was just boring as he simply repeated the same things about darkness. Aside from the versus books(and even those got stale pretty quick) Predator had a much weaker line up of stories in the past so my hopes aren't high that the new Marvel stories with him will be better after this book...and I really hope they don't touch Planet of the Apes now.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 25, 2021 8:10:10 GMT -5
Usagi Yojimbo #17Art and Story by Stan Sakai Summary:Usagi and his former sensei, Sojobu, have their backs against the wall when an unforeseen ally comes to their aid. Art/Story: The latest adventure featuring your favorite ronin rabbit continues the Tengu War storyline that began in the last issue and it really delivers when it comes to action. However, while there are fights aplenty delivered in beautiful, fluid panels that you swear are moving and wonderfully odd looking yokai...it lacks a little heart, which is usually the centerpiece of any good Usagi story. There's a short bit about a samurai's duty and honor and a tiny exploration of Japanese myths but not a whole lot to really latch onto emotionally. Don't get me wrong, it's not a terrible book by any stretch of the imagination, it's just that it's very action orientated and very straight forward so it's not the deepest read in the world. Part of me feels like this should have been a deep dive into Japanese culture, like Kite Story or Kaiso, where the plot almost feels like a superficial excuse to deliver an educational text but you don't mind because the information is so interesting that you can forgive the simplistic plot. It would have been interesting to learn why, if for any reason, Sojobu's wife appears to be wearing a yokai mask for instance. Is that how female yokai are often depicted? No idea, but if so a look into that would have been really fun and added a sense of depth to what is otherwise a fairly run of the mill story that basically boils down Usagi helps an old friend defend their home from a band of miscreants. Sure, in this case the old friend is a mountain spirit and the miscreants are weird furry monsters, but at the end of the day it's a tad simplistic. Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Mar 26, 2021 12:06:32 GMT -5
I had enough time today to get my books. I was able to get the last copy of Batman/Superman at my comic store. And I agree with the review above. It was one of the best issues l have read in awhile. Thank you thwhtguardian for the recommendation.
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Mar 26, 2021 14:44:05 GMT -5
Detective Comics #1034.
Batman story by Mariko Tamaki & Dan Mora.
A new chapter. Bruce Wayne has lost a huge amount of his money & Wayne Manor. He is adjusting to being Batman without unlimited funds. He is reinventing himself. Plus the new mayor has stoked anti-Batman sentiment. And now a new crime wave and a murder mystery.
I like this creative team. I also feel they brought back some of the detective element to this book.
Robin back up by Joshua Williamson & Gleb Melnikov.
continued from Batman #106. Set ups the new Robin series. Nice cliffhanger on the last page! Makes me want to check out the new Robin title.
|
|
|
Post by majestic on Mar 26, 2021 14:59:12 GMT -5
THUMBS DOWN
Action Comics #1029. The main Superman story was under whelming. It felt like filler. It should have been bigger to start off this new direction with a bang. Hester's art was really amazing. The Midnighter back up was disappointing. It just fell flat for me. Plus I would have rather had a Superman related character or someone like Green Arrow or Aquaman who no longer have a solo series.
Batman Black & White #4. I really only liked the story by Karl Kerschl. The rest I either did not like the art or the story was too "weird" for my tastes.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 26, 2021 17:29:42 GMT -5
THUMBS DOWN
Action Comics #1029. The main Superman story was under whelming. It felt like filler. It should have been bigger to start off this new direction with a bang. Hester's art was really amazing. The Midnighter back up was disappointing. It just fell flat for me. Plus I would have rather had a Superman related character or someone like Green Arrow or Aquaman who no longer have a solo series.
Batman Black & White #4. I really only liked the story by Karl Kerschl. The rest I either did not like the art or the story was too "weird" for my tastes. I think the Superman story would have been better if so much of it didn't feel like it was a rehash of what we saw in the last issue. I literally stopped reading this issue originally to go check my box and make sure I just hadn't picked up a second copy of the last issue by mistake. The story of a son finding out their father isn't Superman even when their dad actually IS the Man of Steel is poignant and fun...but I don't think it needed to be told in two parts. And the Midnighter story was definitely a miss for me as well, the art was great but other than that it just holds zero interest for me. 6/10 for me. As much as it pains me to do so given my love of anthologies I think I'm going to drop Batman Black and White. Like you, I loved the story by Kerschl with Maps from Gotham Academy(I miss that book!) as Robin the supernatural story that felt like it would have been right at home in the pages of Hellboy made it all the sweeter...but also like you, aside from the Story by Becky Cloonan and Terry Dodson( I'd love them on a regular bat book!) that was about the only feature I enjoyed and that's been fairly consistent each issue with one or two stories appealing to me while the others missed the mark and with the cost of these issues due to jump to 6 bucks that's just not a success rate that makes it a good value for me. I still love the concept and I'll totally buy the trade when it comes out but I just can't see spending that much every month. 6/10 as well
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Mar 26, 2021 17:52:29 GMT -5
Detective Comics #1034.
Batman story by Mariko Tamaki & Dan Mora.
A new chapter. Bruce Wayne has lost a huge amount of his money & Wayne Manor. He is adjusting to being Batman without unlimited funds. He is reinventing himself. Plus the new mayor has stoked anti-Batman sentiment. And now a new crime wave and a murder mystery.
I like this creative team. I also feel they brought back some of the detective element to this book.
Robin back up by Joshua Williamson & Gleb Melnikov.
continued from Batman #106. Set ups the new Robin series. Nice cliffhanger on the last page! Makes me want to check out the new Robin title.
I thought Batman/Superman was good(and it was!) but yeah, this is what I've been craving from a Batman book for years. Tamaki, not only weaves a yarn with a lot of tension and mystery but with the party Bruce attends actually having names and back stories to the wealth there with him it actually feels human which is something that's been missing for a while. With out the man there can be no Batman, I mean the super heroics are fun and are definitely the main draw but with out the human element it's just guys in funny clothes punching each other which only gets you so much enjoyment. And the Robin back up? Yup that was a win for me too, sure it was just a tease for the upcoming Damian Wayne solo Robin book, and yeah the Enter the Dragon premise it sets up isn't super original but the energy was fun so I'll certainly be checking it out even if it's a little light weight in comparison to Detective. 10/10 for me
|
|