|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 3, 2021 7:51:10 GMT -5
OFF THE RACKS!What did you read this week?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 3, 2021 8:46:07 GMT -5
Future State: Swamp Thing #2Written by Ram V Art by Mike Perkins Summary: After years of coming up short against Swamp Thing, the Floronic Man has finally found a way to exact his vengeance on the Green. Plot: In his finale Future State issue Ram V shows us that not only does he know how to infuse his plot with a truly epic (in the true literal sense) feeling but also the sense to keep it entertaining enough for a casual reader which is a rare feat these days. Ultimately though, two issues just wasn't enough pages to tell this story; I know all the Future State books are truncated versions of what was meant to be a year long event but this is the first book that truly shows the sad limitations of forcing that kind of a crunch on a story. It's plain enough to see the heights that Ram V wished to ascend to as there is a sense of longing that permeates every page as Swamp Thing embarks on not only a journey north to save humanity but also an introspective journey of self understanding of his own soul and the lack thereof in his own children. That journey alone is a lot to take in, and is a fertile ground for storytelling that could easily yield a ripe crop of stories for months to come(I couldn't help it folks) and yet it was sadly cut short. Instead of the planned year we get just this short month and a half and after just two issues, Ram V needs to wrap up too much to give you a truly satisfying read. There just isn't room in two issues time to allow the characters time to breathe, for motivations to become more clear to explore the fundamentals of how Swamp Thing created his own people and a classic supervillain plot to destroy humanity and in trying to do so despite the limitations Ram V has the unenviable position of trying to deliver what could have been top tier comic in an abortion of a comic event and sadly it just simply doesn’t mesh as well as you would hope. That said, this is the man who will deliver more Swamp Thing come March in a new ten issue series( although with out Alec Holland you can read more here) so although this book wasn't all it could be the sparks of creativity within it leave me very hopeful about the story that is to come. Art: In his final Future State foray Perkins does manage to deliver some great artwork, with a fantastic moody feel that is very fitting with a horror character like Swamp Thing. However, and for the same reasons the plot takes a hit, the visuals also fall victim to the massive undertaking of fitting so much story into too few pages. With so much needing to come together so quickly there's an inherent need for more dialogue and narration which steadily chips away at the room for artistic expression. Again, though imperfect, there's enough fantastic elements here to easily make one excited to see that Perkins too will be returning to Swamp Thing in just one short month from now. Grade:6.5/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 3, 2021 9:32:16 GMT -5
Man-Bat #1Written by Dave Wielgosz Art by Sumit Kumar Summary: What started out as medical research for the deaf has turned into a monstrous addiction for Kirk Langstrom, and it might be his death. Plot: I've been a huge Man-Bat fan ever since I first saw him on Batman: The Animated Series, which caused me to go on my first back issue quest as I just knew I needed more. And although I've loved just about every appearance in comics since his debut in Detective Comics #400 this entry is sadly an example of why buying books based only on their covers doesn't often lead to the best results as I went into this totally blind and paid the price. Reading that back, it makes this issue sound worse than it actually is...this isn't a bad book persay, it does a decent job of introducing you to Kirk Langstrom and Man-Bat and sets up a plot that sees him possibly dying from the effects of the serum and becoming a member of Amanda Waller's Suicide Squad. But for a long time reader there is a huge sense of, "Been there, done that." as even though we haven't seen Man-Bat himself as part of Suicide Squad we've seen other characters from Gotham join the team in the past like Killer Croc and Harley. It's even remarked upon by Waller in the story itself that she's had extensive experience in the past with cleaning up after Batman, which didn't make the feeling of deja-vu any better.
Art: While Kumar does have a great sharpness to his style and a really great eye towards capturing energy in static images he too falls prey to retreading the classics and when those classics feature the works of such artistic luminaries as Neal Adams and Kevin Nowlan then the comparisons to those past works are going to leave your standing feeling a little low.
Ultimately, this issue feels like more of a repackaging of the greatest hits of Man-Bat(it even brings back the Blackout Gang from his debut) than an actual new story which is really frustrating as the character has great potential and the cover looked really great so I was definitely expecting far greater things than what was actually delivered and I just can't see myself reading more. Grade:6/10
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Feb 3, 2021 12:45:53 GMT -5
The Comic Book History of Animation #3. (IDW) Fred Van Lente & Ryan Dunlavey This is the follow-up to the teams Comic Book History of Comics. So far the first three issues have shown the birth of animation, the rise of Disney and in this issue it looks at the rise of UPA and the evolution of the style at Warner Brothers along with the de-emphasis of animation at Disney as they moved in to live-action and "live" entertainment. Essentially it covers the forties and in to the early 50s. That cover alone is worth the price of admission. But this is an entertaining book that is a nice initial primer of the history of animation. While it doesn't focus super heavily on non-American animation, it doesn't ignore it. And this issue certainly foreshadows the career of Osamu Tezuka. Well recommended if you want a quick fun look at animation history. Though it may well read better when it's collected. But...oh that cover.
|
|
|
Post by profholt82 on Feb 3, 2021 21:10:01 GMT -5
Coincidentally, I just happened to grab Man-Bat and Future State Swamp Thing 1 and 2 while I was at the shop today. They weren't in my pull, just grabbed them off the wall on a whim. Well, the shop owner recommended Man-Bat, and made it sound interesting, but I've always liked him as a character. He's had a few good appearances in some Batman books over the years, and I loved him in one of my favorite episodes of Batman the Animated Series back in the 90s. Looking forward to reading them. Hopefully, I like them a bit more than you did, but I'm glad you didn't give them a 2 or 3. Hahaha
|
|
|
Post by berkley on Feb 3, 2021 22:20:15 GMT -5
The Comic Book History of Animation looks cool, but it also looks like the kind of thing I might prefer to read in collected form - though I could say that about almost any comic, these days.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 4, 2021 14:44:11 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #43Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett Summary: As the U-Foes practice working as a team, Joe Fix-It tries to lay low but the Hulk blows his cover. Plot: Normally, this would be one of those lull issues that I've bemoaned in the past, and don't get me wrong it is a whole lot of treading water...but I just really love how Ewing writes Joe Fix-It so a whole issue focused on him working a grift was a fun read. The kind of sleazy, 70's crime exploitation feel that Ewing brought to the page definitely kept me entertained but by the end I have to say that the book needs to really step on the gas and I wonder if seven issues is enough to give this story of Hulk on the run and trying to reinvent himself. It's been a solid and interesting run to date, even with its various valleys in quality...but if it can't stick the landing on the end I think it could miss out on being a truly legendary run. Only time will tell I guess. Art: Bennett didn't get to do a whole lot of interesting things but he did do a good job of making Joe look suitably lecherous. Grade:7/10
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Feb 4, 2021 14:53:16 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #43Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett Summary: As the U-Foes practice working as a team, Joe Fix-It tries to lay low but the Hulk blows his cover. Plot: Normally, this would be one of those lull issues that I've bemoaned in the past, and don't get me wrong it is a whole lot of treading water...but I just really love how Ewing writes Joe Fix-It so a whole issue focused on him working a grift was a fun read. The kind of sleazy, 70's crime exploitation feel that Ewing brought to the page definitely kept me entertained but by the end I have to say that the book needs to really step on the gas and I wonder if seven issues is enough to give this story of Hulk on the run and trying to reinvent himself. It's been a solid and interesting run to date, even with its various valleys in quality...but if it can't stick the landing on the end I think it could miss out on being a truly legendary run. Only time will tell I guess. Art: Bennett didn't get to do a whole lot of interesting things but he did do a good job of making Joe look suitably lecherous. Grade:7/10 Well he did do this. Which is at least controversial.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 4, 2021 15:50:39 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #43Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett Summary: As the U-Foes practice working as a team, Joe Fix-It tries to lay low but the Hulk blows his cover. Plot: Normally, this would be one of those lull issues that I've bemoaned in the past, and don't get me wrong it is a whole lot of treading water...but I just really love how Ewing writes Joe Fix-It so a whole issue focused on him working a grift was a fun read. The kind of sleazy, 70's crime exploitation feel that Ewing brought to the page definitely kept me entertained but by the end I have to say that the book needs to really step on the gas and I wonder if seven issues is enough to give this story of Hulk on the run and trying to reinvent himself. It's been a solid and interesting run to date, even with its various valleys in quality...but if it can't stick the landing on the end I think it could miss out on being a truly legendary run. Only time will tell I guess. Art: Bennett didn't get to do a whole lot of interesting things but he did do a good job of making Joe look suitably lecherous. Grade:7/10 Well he did do this. Which is at least controversial. Yeesh, I didn't even notice it until you blew it up...and worse yet it seems he's made some pretty inflammatory posts in the past that I hadn't heard about. I might need to reevaluate how I see him and his work.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 4, 2021 16:12:56 GMT -5
Star Wars: The High Republic #3Written by Cavan Scott Art by Ario Anindito Summary: Jedi Knight Keeve and her master Sskeer respond to a distress call but are too late to render aid but continue to look for the Nihl. Plot: I almost dropped this after the terrible disappointment that was the novel Light of the Jedi (thoughts on that here) which this comic spins directly out of but stuck it out for another look...and although Scott provides some solid characterization I'm not sure there's enough else to keep me interested and a lot of that has to do with one of the issues I had with the novel: the Nihl just aren't an interesting threat. They're a bunch of pirates that brutally maim and kill to get what they want and don't have any real philosophy to them to make their motivations any deeper which is really bland. On top of that they aren't force users so they get mowed down pretty easily by jedi, as seen here, so no threat and no interesting characteristics makes them pretty uninteresting which really kills my motivation to discover more. It's a real shame Scott is hamstrung by the constraints of the High Republic event because he's a capable writer who's delivered some great Star Wars books in the past. Art: What's really disappointing is that Anindito's art is really fun to pour over. He has a really slick, cinematic look that not only really draws you into the big scenes but gives a real spark to the smaller more intimate scenes as well. It's just too bad that both he and Scott don't have a book worth their time. Grade:5/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 4, 2021 16:35:49 GMT -5
Strange Academy #8Written by Scottie Young Art by Humberto Ramos Summary: A class field trip with Rocket and Groot spills over into the on going rehabilitation of Emily Bright and Doyle Dormammu. Plot: Boy, there are a lot of things going on here! An action packed, and suitably humorous, class trip guest starring Rocket and Groot, Doyle dealing with the emotional impact of his death and return to life and Emily confronting her mistrust of Doctor Strange all play out over the course of twenty odd pages...so the pacing is quick to say the least! And while I applaud Young for both the quick pacing and for avoiding the edict of stretching plots out to fit the trade I do wish we could take things just a little bit slower and let us get to know these characters more. That feeling isn't new either, I've felt that we haven't really gotten to spend enough time with these kids yet, leaving many of them feeling rather empty and superfluous right along...but the ideas that Young continues to throw out at us along the way and the energy he brings to the page continues to make this well worth reading despite its flaws. Art: Ramos continues to be able to balance the comedic elements with the dramatic moments making every scene feel like they fit together despite their differences in tone. Grade:7/10
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 4, 2021 19:23:30 GMT -5
Star Wars Adventures: The High Republic #1Written by Daniel Jose Older Art by Harvey Tolibao Summary: As a remnant of the Hyperspace Disaster appears over Trymant IV, Yoda and his cadre of Padawans find there's more at stake. Plot: Like Alec Worley's Smuggler's Run, Older's story here really proves that having the "Adventures" masthead on the top of your book and gearing your story towards a younger audience doesn't mean you can't tell a great story. Though it's plot of young Jedi getting involved in a pirate raid isn't terribly complex that doesn't mean it isn't a great read as what it lacks in complexity it more than makes up for with some really excellent characterization and unlike previous High Republic entries it doesn't get too caught up with world building. Usually, I hate to directly compare two comics when I review them as a story normally deserves to be considered on its own merits first, without being put into the context of the other contemporaneous books. However, as the High Republic is a massive cross over event across different mediums and Older's Adventures is coming out at the exact same time as another High Republic book, the eponymous comic written by Cavan Scott and the same month as the novel, Light of the Jedi by Charles Soule comparisons really just can't be escaped.
As you've seen from the review above, and the linked review of the novel my first impressions of the High Republic event weren't very great so I approached this book with a certain amount of trepidation however Older’s High Republic Adventures ends up looking significantly better in the comparison, and it's not just because the bar is so low. Where as Scott’s High Republic basically throws you straight into the deep-end. assuming that you’ve read the kickoff book to the High Republic era, Charles Soule’s Light of the Jedi, and then just goes from there which results in a plot lacking the necessary context to draw you in, and while Soule himself spends nearly a third of his novel describing in excruciating detail an event which in the end of this doesn't actually have terribly much to with the threat faced by the Jedi, Older focuses on delivering a solid, self contained story which makes for a much better read.
Without being repetitive or loading the reader down with pages and pages of exposition, Older concisely quickly explains what is going on in the galaxy by playing out a similar event as the one that started Soule's novel which immediately grounds the characters in that greater context of the event while not forgetting to give us time to understand our protagonists and their emotional states. By focusing on the characters involved and not making a big deal out of the debris or the pirates beyond their immediate threats Older successfully sidesteps the flaws that have plagued the other entries of the event and delivered the readers a fun Star Wars adventure in a unexplored era, which is everything the event promised.It’s honestly impressive, and I almost wish that Older had the main book, and Cavan Scott and Soule were given the side stories as he really seems to get how to use the plot elements much better than either of the other two writers.
Art: Okay, so the book must be a perfect ten right? Unfortunately not, and the problem is the art. Tolibao’s art is heavily lined, which isn't always a terrible thing as I'd say the same thing about Frank Quietly's work as well, but here it's taken to an extreme making even the young jedi look wrinkled and strange...while Yoda seems surprisingly less lined than normal. On top of that the back grounds are suspiciously un-detailed, making it look like the action is taking place in big empty areas...when it's supposed to be the most heavily populated city on the planet. In the end it's a shame this wasn't given to someone else, as while the art isn't so terrible so as to make the book unreadable it stops the book from being a true instant classic.
Grade:8/10
|
|
|
Post by wildfire2099 on Feb 5, 2021 17:40:13 GMT -5
My stuff for this week:
Strange Academy #8 : I agree... lots of stuff going on! I like how it keeps pulling random bits of the MU in... an actual GOOD use of the shared universe concept! Doyle has me massively intrigued. Pretty sure I know what's going on with Emily, which should also be pretty interesting. The rest of the cast? Well, two students does not a school make. It will be interesting to see if they're able to flesh out more of the characters or not.
Frost Giant's Daughter #3 : Definitely felt padded.... TWO two pages splashes back to back, and not much story. Very pretty, though. I could have done without the heart beating all over the art... not my favorite technique.
Star Wars: High Repbublic #2 : I think I'm liking this more than thwhtguardian... I feel like the real enemy is within, and that's a good story for Jedi of any era. The twins are really cool... I hope they don't go and kill them off. Pretty awesome spread with the dead hutt, too.
Redemption #1 : This was my impulse buy for the week, because I'm always a sucker weird genres, and the cover screams 'steampunk western'. At first glance, seemed like it was going to be just another post-apocalyptic story, but it's actually really good, with a unique main character. Based on the author notes in the back, it could end up going to far down the rabbit hole of politics, but this first issue was well worth putting the rest of the series on my pull list.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 5, 2021 19:39:13 GMT -5
Immortal Hulk #43Written by Al Ewing Art by Joe Bennett Summary: As the U-Foes practice working as a team, Joe Fix-It tries to lay low but the Hulk blows his cover. Plot: Normally, this would be one of those lull issues that I've bemoaned in the past, and don't get me wrong it is a whole lot of treading water...but I just really love how Ewing writes Joe Fix-It so a whole issue focused on him working a grift was a fun read. The kind of sleazy, 70's crime exploitation feel that Ewing brought to the page definitely kept me entertained but by the end I have to say that the book needs to really step on the gas and I wonder if seven issues is enough to give this story of Hulk on the run and trying to reinvent himself. It's been a solid and interesting run to date, even with its various valleys in quality...but if it can't stick the landing on the end I think it could miss out on being a truly legendary run. Only time will tell I guess. Art: Bennett didn't get to do a whole lot of interesting things but he did do a good job of making Joe look suitably lecherous. Grade:7/10 This was the only book I bought this week. I agree with your review.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Feb 6, 2021 17:13:15 GMT -5
My stuff for this week: Strange Academy #8 : I agree... lots of stuff going on! I like how it keeps pulling random bits of the MU in... an actual GOOD use of the shared universe concept! Doyle has me massively intrigued. Pretty sure I know what's going on with Emily, which should also be pretty interesting. The rest of the cast? Well, two students does not a school make. It will be interesting to see if they're able to flesh out more of the characters or not. Frost Giant's Daughter #3 : Definitely felt padded.... TWO two pages splashes back to back, and not much story. Very pretty, though. I could have done without the heart beating all over the art... not my favorite technique. Star Wars: High Repbublic #2 : I think I'm liking this more than thwhtguardian... I feel like the real enemy is within, and that's a good story for Jedi of any era. The twins are really cool... I hope they don't go and kill them off. Pretty awesome spread with the dead hutt, too. Redemption #1 : This was my impulse buy for the week, because I'm always a sucker weird genres, and the cover screams 'steampunk western'. At first glance, seemed like it was going to be just another post-apocalyptic story, but it's actually really good, with a unique main character. Based on the author notes in the back, it could end up going to far down the rabbit hole of politics, but this first issue was well worth putting the rest of the series on my pull list. The cast of Strange Academy is large, and they have a lot of characters that are really unique. I sometimes feel like this book would work really well as an OGN line like the DC YA books. As for the High Republic...I wish it was deeper like you suggested, but the Nihl are very much supposed to be the big bad and they just aren't interesting in the least. The Star Wars Adventures book was so much better than the main Marvel book, it's not even funny. Better characterization, a more interesting hook into the story and a better handle on the plot elements the event is centered around.
|
|