|
Post by Cei-U! on Dec 17, 2018 9:34:39 GMT -5
When I was in junior high, my vocal music teacher dragged those of us who performed in the school’s glee club to several performances at the Seattle Opera. We saw Carmen, Madame Butterfly and a third production that has long since faded from my memory. Despite this early exposure, I never warmed up to opera. (In fact, I can’t stand it. Buncha danged caterwaulin’, if’n you axe me.) So if you’d told pubescent Cei-U! that someday I’d list a comic based on an opera as one of my favorites, I’d have suggested you share some of whatever you were smoking. But here it is all the same: There’s been a lot of justified praise for P. Craig Russell’s interpretation of Wagner’s Ring cycle but, good as it is, I think it’s far less powerful than the version produced by Roy Thomas, Gil Kane, and Jim Woodring for DC in 1989. The four-issue limited series features some of Thomas’ most lyrical wordsmithing and, more significantly, some of the most dynamic artwork Kane ever created. It was the story he was born to tell, and he told it so magnificently that it didn’t even bother me that he inked his own pencils, something I normally can’t abide. I’d sold off the original run years ago, but stumbled across the trade collection at a must-have-it price years ago, an edition that now bears the signatures of both Roy and Woodring. I’m never gonna like listening to opera but as long as this book is in my collection, I’ll always love reading it. Cei-U! I summon the Ride of the Valkyries!
|
|
|
Post by Phil Maurice on Dec 17, 2018 9:51:52 GMT -5
8. Gang Busters / Gangbusters (National, 1947-58) Cover: Curt Swan/Stan Kaye A dramatic mainstay from radio's golden age, Gang Busters' cacophonous opening, full of screeching tires, blaring sirens, keening police whistles, and staccato gunfire birthed the common expression "came on like Gang Busters." Touting its adherence to authentic police case histories, it was in some ways the Law and Order of its day and it enjoyed a successful run from 1936-1957. National's (DC's) adaptation of the show was also successful, running for 67 issues between 1947 and 1958. It fit neatly into the crime comics genre that was at the peak of its popularity in the late 40s and early 50s. The series largely eschews the more lurid elements that characterized crime comics of the era. The tone of the stories reflects a more establishment view of criminals as unglamorous villains and law enforcement as heroic crusaders who always get their man. It's clear that National was aware of Dr. Wertham's anti-comics crusade and chose not to invite scrutiny. They needn't have bothered. Wertham saved his ugliest comments for the publisher's comparatively innocuous Batman comics. Where Gang Busters distinguishes itself as a comic is in the mind-staggering array of artists who contributed to the series, among them: Bernard Baily, George Roussos, Ruben Moreira, Jack Kirby, Mort Drucker and Frank Frazetta, as well as early National work by Nick Cardy and Curt Swan. Cover: Nick Cardy Like many other Atom Age crime comics, Gang Busters was an anthology series with few recurring characters. Every issue is a jumping-on point and boasts at least a few pages by a giant of the industry.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 17, 2018 10:24:41 GMT -5
On Day Five I give you... Frost and Fire DC Science Graphic Novel #3, 1985
The entire DC Graphic Novel series was a fantastic experiment, adapting a slew of great short stories but my favorite edition was this issue which adapted Ray Bradbury's The Creatures Time Forgot. Not only is the art and coloring by Janson fantastic, but more than that I loved that it introduced me to a brand new story I had never even heard of by one of my favorite authors. I think that's one of the best elements of an adaptation, it's ability to bring awareness of a story to an entirely new audience.
|
|
|
Post by brutalis on Dec 17, 2018 10:29:49 GMT -5
8. Tomb of Dracule. Marvel. Marv Wolfman/Gene Colan/Tom Palmer (primarily) 1972-1979.70 issues of with the Lord of the Undead as antagonist and protagonist of supernatural horror's within the greater MU. Has there ever been a better ongoing continued horror series than this? not only is Vlad the main vein man but there is a great set of recurring characters as well as newly created just for the comic cast. Old Quincy Harker, young Rachel Van Helsing, Frank Drake, Taj, Blade the Vampire Hunter, Hannibal King reluctant vampire, Lilith the daughter of Drac', Vampire Deacon Frost, Harold H. Harold the hacUsea pinch of Universal classic horror, mixing in some Hammer horror styling's and then add the start of Marv Wolfman as writer, this series steadily built a cult following with eerie atmospheric artwork from Colan and Palmer.
The longest running continuous horror comic book and for good reason. The stories are skillful, intricate and intriguing providing wonderful reads and re-readings. The art from Colan oozes through the mists with Gothic blood tingling sophistication. The characters all have their own voice and life adding to the story of the dead life of Dracula as he walks the Earth in search of manifesting his power. This series is a "SAGA" in every way that entices you to enter it's world where you will most likely end up staying until a wooden stake is driven through your own heart...
|
|
|
Post by hondobrode on Dec 17, 2018 10:44:23 GMT -5
8. Superman War of the Worlds (DC 1998) This probably wouldn’t be up so high except A. It’s the Golden Age Superman who I love and B. Michael Lark. Oh yeah, Roy Thomas is the guy that dreamed this up. Classic Roy Thomas. What else is there to be said ? I don’t see how anyone who likes either Golden Age Superman or War of the Worlds could be dissatisfied with this little Elseworlds gem.
|
|
Crimebuster
CCF Podcast Guru
Making comics!
Posts: 3,958
|
Post by Crimebuster on Dec 17, 2018 10:50:09 GMT -5
8. Glenn Scarpelli in Hollywood
8. Master of Kung Fu(Marvel, 1974-1983) I'll be honest, I haven't actually read all that much Master of Kung Fu yet, which is probably why it's only #8 on my list instead of higher. That will change soon, as I recently completed the run, so I'm just about ready to dig in. Still, even a small sampling is enough to convince anyone that Master of Kung Fu is a series worth checking out, if just for the amazing art alone from the likes of Paul Gulacy, Mike Zeck, and Gene Day. Add to that some rip roaring martial arts adventures with more than a hint of James Bond-esque globe hopping intrigue and you have a pure winner. The title's literary entanglements are well documented, as the decision to ground the series in the literary world of Sax Rohmer's Fu Manchu noel has been an ongoing rights headache for decades now. With a Shang Chi film reportedly in development, though, hopefully Marvel has figured out a way to smooth things over, or just erase Fu Manchu from the story going forward. Whatever it takes to get some more Master of Kung Fu!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 17, 2018 10:53:18 GMT -5
8. Superman War of the Worlds (DC 1998)
With two entries in its favor, I really need to check this one out.
|
|
|
Post by MDG on Dec 17, 2018 11:11:05 GMT -5
8. EC Ray Bradbury StoriesEC, 1952-1954 A lot of Feldstein’s often verbose EC scripts showed an influence of Bradbury, so, after essentially ripping the writer off, it was obvious that Gaines and Bradbury would enter a formal arrangement. The partnership worked out well (though I read recently that, when comics were really coming under fire, Bradbury's manager had him ask EC not to list him on the covers. Need to check that). Bradbury had suitable science fiction, horror, and crime stories that worked well in 6-8 pages, and EC’s artists usually brought their A game to the work, especially Wally Wood. And Bradbury’s rep meant that they could print “The Flying Machine” in a SF comic even though it’s not a science fiction story. {More Art!} Bradbury's name also helped market Ballantine paperback EC reprints in the 60s (before reprinting ECs became an industry unto itself.)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 17, 2018 11:20:03 GMT -5
8. The Real GhostbustersFirst there was 1984's Ghostbusters. Five years later, there was Ghostbusters II. In between that, there was the animated The Real Ghostbusters. A guy sure needed his Ghostbusters fix, right? And that's where Marvel UK's The Real Ghostbusters came in. It ran for - wait for it - 141 issues between 1988 and 1992. Some of, it not all, of my choices so far have been about entertaining me when a favourite franchise was off the air/not making films. The cartoon series ran for seven seasons between 1986 and 1991. That aside, two films in five years was not enough for me - and we had to wait 27 years for a third movie. So I never failed to appreciate the ancillary stuff. Each issue had a lively letters page, with letters answered by "Peter Venkman", plus around 4 strips. There were often text stories, too. And articles/fact files on Ghostbusters technology. And Spengler's Spirit Guide. And...so much else. Busting ghosts may seem like a limited premise. It could have been. There was enough variety, though. Familiar favourites such as the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man appeared. Slimer appeared a lot - and he got his own spin-off comic. It was true to the spirit of the animated series. And there was continuity with the films. When a "descendant" of Gozer appeared in one strip, the Ghostbusters said to Ray, "Don't you dare think of the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man!" when Gozer's "descendant" asked them to choose the form of their destructor. With superlative art, funny stories and so much else, this, like my other examples, is representative of a licensee actually putting a lot of thought into a title rather than taking the ever-so-easy option of churning something uninspiring out.
|
|
|
Post by EdoBosnar on Dec 17, 2018 11:25:14 GMT -5
Demon With a Glass Hand (DC Science Fiction Graphic Novel #5)Written by Harlan Ellison, art by Marshall Rogers I agree thwhtguardian's assessment of DC's graphic SF novels of the 1980s, but this one is my personal favorite. It's Ellison's own adaptation of his script for the now legendary episode of The Outer Limits from 1964. Most people here are probably familiar with the story - i.e., the protagonist only has a memory spanning a few days, but knows he's somehow from the future, and he has a hand-shaped computer encased in transparent material instead of a normal left hand. He's trapped inside a building by humanoid aliens who are trying to kill him, and he convinces a lone woman working there to help him as the aliens play cat and mouse with him throughout the building. This is, of course, one of the truly iconic SF stories, and this graphic novelization was fantastically drawn by the late, great Marshall Rogers.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 17, 2018 11:28:52 GMT -5
On the Fifth day of Christmas, Santa said, In Space, no one can hear you scream... Alien: An Illustrated Story by Archie Goodwin and Walt Simonson, published by Heavy Metal in 1979; adapted from the Ridley Scott film I have the 2012 rerelease by Titan Publishing rather than the original (it has a different cover, but otherwise is the same). Alien was another movie my folks wouldn’t let me see as a kid, and my first exposure to the franchise was the 1986 sequel Aliens when I was in high school (seen in a double feature with Jeff Goldblum's the Fly with a friend who was really into horror movies), but once I saw the the first movie, it became one of my favorite sci-fi/horror films. And as much as I like the movie, I like the adaptation by Goodwin and Simonson better. Goodwin’s choices as to how to present this on the page as exceptional, and Simonson provides a visual tour de force that captures the tension, suspense, and atmosphere of the movie, but retaining the classic powerful feel of Simonson art. I was already a big fan of Simonson's work when I discovered this adaptation, but if I hadn't been, this would have made me one. And the Goodwin/Simonson team is one of the best collaborative combos out there. -M
|
|
|
Post by Slam_Bradley on Dec 17, 2018 11:29:20 GMT -5
Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe: The Little Sister by Michael Lark (Fireside Books 1997) I'm a huge fan of Raymond Chandler...and harboiled detectives in general. I came across this book at a remainder bookstore that used to be in the outlet mall in Boise. I used to stop there a couple times a year and they would periodically have some graphic novels and some other comics related stuff (I got the first two volumes of Flash Archives there). I was immediately drawn in by the Steranko cover. But I was blown away by Michael Lark's artwork. This is a pretty faithful adaptation of Chandler's novel. And there almost certainly isn't a better artist for it than Lark. His work just oozes the late 40s, early 50s noir feel. It doesn't hurt that his is one of Chandler's best Marlowe novels even given the fact that the plot is Byzantine and Chandler was completely pissed off at the world when he wrote it. This is one of those happy lucky comic book buys that turns out to be a great thing.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Dec 17, 2018 11:36:17 GMT -5
Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe: The Little Sister by Michael Lark (Fireside Books 1997) I'm a huge fan of Raymond Chandler...and harboiled detectives in general. I came across this book at a remainder bookstore that used to be in the outlet mall in Boise. I used to stop there a couple times a year and they would periodically have some graphic novels and some other comics related stuff (I got the first two volumes of Flash Archives there). I was immediately drawn in by the Steranko cover. But I was blown away by Michael Lark's artwork. This is a pretty faithful adaptation of Chandler's novel. And there almost certainly isn't a better artist for it than Lark. His work just oozes the late 40s, early 50s noir feel. It doesn't hurt that his is one of Chandler's best Marlowe novels even given the fact that the plot is Byzantine and Chandler was completely pissed off at the world when he wrote it. This is one of those happy lucky comic book buys that turns out to be a great thing. Damn, I need this in my life this instant.
|
|
shaxper
CCF Site Custodian
Posts: 22,865
Member is Online
|
Post by shaxper on Dec 17, 2018 11:56:09 GMT -5
In some sense, I just want to vote for the entire Roy Thomas era I have now read in the lovely Dark Horse trades and enjoyed so thoroughly. (Raises hand) #8. Conan at Marvel...all of it.I had a whole write-up for this which is currently sitting on my home computer while I type this on the fly from work. Like Coke & Comics, I wasn't initially interested in Conan. I didn't think I was interested in swords and sorcery, and I was sure I had no interest in some muscle-bound brute who solves all his problems with strength alone. So I avoided the property for a long time until it became inescapably clear that a ton of people around here with tastes I truly respect felt strongly about this series. And so I checked it out. I bought the first Dark Horse volume and pushed through it. At first, I couldn't see the appeal. I didn't particularly like the character, and BWS was still figuring out his style. But, beginning with Tower of the Elephant, I got it: Sure, later Conan could be incredibly wise and sane in comparison to the "civilized" world around him, but the truest magic of the series was its ability to glimpse into the unknown. Howard had a Lovecraft-inspired imagination, set in an action-oriented fantasy world, and that utterly fascinated me. It was less about Conan and more about the great unknown we'd experience this time around, and as some of the finest artists of the era took turns trying their hand at the property (note: I include the Savage Sword stories in this selection) it was brought to life even more beautifully and vividly than Howard's words had conveyed it before. As an added bonus, I positively love the lens through which Roy Thomas views Conan. He has read EVERYTHING Sprague-Camp, has read EVERYTHING writen by and about Howard, and his order, continuity, and editorial comments all string together Conan's universe in a tight, coherent manner. It's just such a rewarding experience.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Dec 17, 2018 13:15:49 GMT -5
In some sense, I just want to vote for the entire Roy Thomas era I have now read in the lovely Dark Horse trades and enjoyed so thoroughly. (Raises hand) #8. Conan at Marvel...all of it.(...) As an added bonus, I positively love the lens through which Roy Thomas views Conan. He has read EVERYTHING Sprague-Camp, has read EVERYTHING writen by and about Howard, and his order, continuity, and editorial comments all string together Conan's universe in a tight, coherent manner. YES!!!And to all the Conan fans and scholars who turn their nose up at Thomas's contribution because he told the Conan story as a continuing saga, or because he doesn't despise L. Sprague de Camp's work enough, or because he's just a comic-book writer... ...you will have the right to judge when you have done a quarter of what he did for the character.
|
|