That we all had input on it... 

I thought Aerosmith was a part of the title; but looking at your initial post -- I misunderstood and you were referring to the famous band, whoops on my part.

No, no, no...the rules for this year's Classic Comics Christmas were set out in a very clear way right from the get go. If you had any queries about them, Kurt graciously offered to answer your questions via PM ahead of time. In addition, we all had a week in which we could make suggestions concerning the rules before they were finalised.

This is Kurt's thing and it always has been. It is not for you (or anyone else) to say "nothing should be disqualified" or anything goes! Mistakes can happen, of course, but there's a world of difference between someone making an honest mistake over interpretation of the rules and someone arbitrarily announcing that any choice they make should be allowed. If you can't or won't play by the rules then might I suggest that you don't play.

I've never seen this one before but it certainly sounds good. How many issues did it run for?

It ran for 17 issues.. but really the 1st 12 are what you want... 13-15 is a time travel story to have an excuse to have the TOS cast on, and 16-17 was a 3 parter that never got finished.

My list is sitting on my desk (I found it).  I don't feel like going to the office.  So I'll likely just do days 3-5 tomorrow.  Unless I just rearrange it for stuff I remember.   Until then...random thoughts. 

MGM's Marvelous Wizard of Oz
- I've never actually seen a copy of this.  But then I saw very few tabloids for sale at the time.  I certainly saw the house ads.  

Captain Video - This is a series I've only seen pictures of. 

Blade Runner - I bought a few movie adaptations over the years (very few).  This was not one of them.  But with Goodwin and Williamson I should check it out. 

The Three Musketeers - I haven't read this one.  I did pick up a few issues of the Marvel Classics from garage sales back in the day.  I'm intrigued.  Nino was an interesting artist.  I may have to try to track this down. 

Batman: Gotham by Gaslight - This never crossed my mind.  In retrospect it probably should have...and though it's a close call (as to it fitting) it might well have made my list.  

Rainbow - Cool.  This is something I have never heard of.  But cool.  

Unexpected #217 - "Dear Senator" - I very seldom read DC's mystery books.  I think I recall seeing this cover somewhere though.  I may have to see if I can track down the story.

The Infinite Horizon - This sounds like something I'd like.  I'll look for it.  I think it maybe fits better than Kurt does.  But it's his baby.  

Superman Adventures - I make no secret of the fact that I generally hate Superman.  The exceptions are the earliest Siegel & Shuster tales...and some of his animated appearances.  I love the Fleisher (sp) cartoons and I generally liked Superman Animated.  I didn't read the funny book though.  

The Phantom, Charlton Comics, 1969-1970 - This was the predecessor to my Day One.  I've only read a few of Aparo's Phantom books. But his art is always gold.  

Marvel Team-Up # 74 - I bought Marvel Team-Up semi-regularly back around this time.  This is not one of the books I bought.  

Marvel Super Special # 1, 5 Kiss (Marvel 1977 - 1978) - I've not read these books.  But then I really don't get the love for Kiss.  So that may have a lot to do with it. 

Creepshow GN - It's been eons since I've read this. It likely would not make my list if I'd thought of it...but it's a cool choice.  I do like the meta of it being an adaptation of a movie that riffed on comics.  

Batman: The Golden Streets of Gotham - I have to agree that this likely doesn't fit.  But it's an interesting choice.  I've read it...but not since it first came out.  And I likely will again soon.  I'm seriously considering an Elseworlds review thread. 

Star Wars #38 - I've probably only read the first dozen or so issues of Star Wars.  I liked the movies fine.  But they just never jazzed me enough to read the comics, strips, books, graffiti, mugs, etc.  Though I have contemplated looking for the Al Williamson strips...because...Al Williamson. 

Thor #295-299 - I think I started buying Thor again with #300 (anniversary issue).  So I'm pretty sure I've not read this.  I'd like to say I will.  but there are so many funny books.  And so little time.  

Tarzan Dark Horse, 1996 series - I don't think Tarzan is going to make my list.  Kubert's Tarzan didn't quite make the cut.  I did read a fair piece of this run though and it's largely pretty good.  

Shadowman # 19 Aerosmith - Huh!  Well what do you know.  I had no idea this was a thing.  I don't think I've ever read a Valiant comic.  And I really don't like Aerosmith.  I suspect I'll remain unaware that this is more than a thing.  

"The Doomsday Book", Detective Comics #572 - I haven't read this forever. Like...maybe since 1987.  I was happy to co-star in it though.  I should probably re-read it.  

Oz series, from Eric Shanower - I've read two or three of these.  And they're pretty spiffy.  I likely should have given them more consideration.  Shanower and Skottie Young's adaptations would have been on my list if they weren't too new.  If you haven't read them..you absolutely should.  

The Cursed Earth
2000AD 61-85 - I've read very little Judge Dredd.  One of those things I hope to rectify.  But so many funnybooks, etc. 

Star Trek: Early Voyages - Star Trek for me is a bit like Star Wars.  I watched re-runs of Star Trek as a kid after school.  And I liked them.  I watched the first four movies.  Largely because I worked at a video store in college.  I tried to watch The Next Generation when it started but it seemed very derivative in the storylines (I understand it got better).  And that was pretty much it.  I think I just prefer my SF to be prose.  

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 8 - I've never Buffy'd.  Neither TV nor funnybooks.