I have the entire original 75 issue run and enjoyed it immensely. Later versions not so much love for. Wonderful Bagley art which showed the team as a true young/teen group of people. Was thankful for the return of (Kid) Nova and his dating Namorita. The Marvel Boy and Firestar connection to the greater Marvel universe felt natural and not forced and Speedball was fun in his comedic relief and the growth of his powers/control. Night Thrasher was ok and nothing special for me.

The stories were fun and delved deeply into the existing Marvel characters to be found as well as creating new ones making a grand mix of old and new for the team to confront. It was nice seeing the smaller forces of villainy being explored and the series to me had that original Avengers feeling and mixture of cosmic (Terrax, the Sphinx, time travel stories, Dire Wraiths, etc) versus more mundane (Puppet Master, Punisher, Marvel Boy's trial, etc) which helped make the team something special. 

I enjoyed the New Warriors, although I can't remember much about it save the romance between Firestar and Marvel Boy (and his trial). Seems like I remember Kid Nova and Namorita having a romance. Was there a member named Silhouette? I remember Nighthrasher and there was another team member that went on to be an Avenger (Firestar and Marvel Boy did as well--didn't he change his name to Justice?)

By the time the comic came out I wasn't much invested in mainstream superheroes, although I did buy the first issue out of curiosity. I thought Nightthrasher was an unfortunately predictable 'token angry young black man,' although I was pleasntly impressed that they managed to cobble together a team of pretty much all the unaffiliated non-mutant teen heroes of the time and they seemed to fit together pretty well.

I bought the book for about the first 50 issues and enjoyed it, but mostly because I was a Nova fan. Never much cared about most of the others, except Vance and Angelica.

I have most of the first 50 issues and I re-read it a few years back and it didn't hold up. I found that I kind of hated Bagley's art.

I've collected all the Bagley issues back in the 90's. Since then I've been finding the rest in $1 bins here at a local chain of stores and have been buying them when I see them. Overall I liked the early issues, but the latter issues seem to be lacking. One of the latest ones I read that I purchased months ago was a disappointment. Of the 12 or so issues, I have after #27 or 28 (Bagley's last issue) I think they made Nightthrasher even more of the token "angry black guy", as mikelmidnight mentioned, and by the few #50 issues and the Nighttrasher mini, they really made him a caricature. Almost as bad as reading Simonson's Steel, even though I usually like her writing. But these two are good examples of someone writing a character they are unfamiliar with badly. Which is weird since Fabian did well in the early part of the series. And both Bagley and Robertson were good artists. But after that the writing and art gone bad. (Except that one issue where they all fight a Namor that didn't take them seriously. I mean the art was still bad, but it was a hilariously funny issue.)

I never got into New Warriors, despite buying a ton of Marvel content at the time it was being published. Outside of Nova, I really didn't take to any of the characters.

I think I own four issues of the original series. I know I have the 1st issue, which I bought for $1 somewhere, #10 because it had White Queen on the cover, and the first two annuals because they were parts of bigger stories. Other than those, I have never had any interest in picking up more of this series.