Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 16, 2015 6:14:57 GMT -5
No, it's pretty much as you suspect, it was never used again and no explanation was given for that. Obviously the Tagge ship which contained the Omega Frost technology was destroyed and the project's mastermind Silas Tagge was "apparently" killed. But, as you say, there must've been blueprints etc and, of course, Domina Tagge, Ulric Tagge and Casio Tagge were still at large, so why didn't they re-build or re-use the technology? As you say, the real reason that this never happened was because this is comic books and in comic books once the villain has been vanquished, the scary superweapon he's created is normally never seen again...unless you're from the Smythe family and we're talking Spider-Slayers. Another reason it was quietly forgotten might be because -- just like I said in my last review -- that Archie Goodwin designed the device to deliver maximum storytelling effect on the twin sun-baked planes of Tatooine. It's simply nowhere as near as interesting or visually impressive a weapon once it's taken out of a hot environment. The Trask family and their Sentinels would like to say "hi". Ha! Yes, good point. I'm sure there are loads of supervillains that have reused their technological terrors (see what I did there?), but the Smythes were the first ones that came into my head. Of course, there are still countless other times when a superweapon has simply vanished because the hero beat the villain and destroyed said weapon the first time it was used. That's kind of a comic book trope, isn't it?
|
|
|
Post by The Captain on Jun 16, 2015 7:34:30 GMT -5
The Trask family and their Sentinels would like to say "hi". Ha! Yes, good point. I'm sure there are loads of supervillains that have reused their technological terrors (see what I did there?), but the Smythes were the first ones that came into my head. Of course, there are still countless other times when a superweapon has simply vanished because the hero beat the villain and destroyed said weapon the first time it was used. That's kind of a comic book trope, isn't it? Absolutely. The writers don't want to get stuck in the trap of bringing back the "Super-Mega-Death-Ray" every time Dr. Killalot shows up and being accused of being lazy or eliciting the dreaded "oh, that again" response from readers. After Captain Hero destroys that weapon, the writer has to show his creativity (through his villain) of coming up with something new and different, because he can't bring back something that was beaten previously; if it wasn't a threat before, why would it be a threat then?
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jun 16, 2015 12:15:08 GMT -5
Ha! Yes, good point. I'm sure there are loads of supervillains that have reused their technological terrors (see what I did there?), but the Smythes were the first ones that came into my head. Of course, there are still countless other times when a superweapon has simply vanished because the hero beat the villain and destroyed said weapon the first time it was used. That's kind of a comic book trope, isn't it? Absolutely. The writers don't want to get stuck in the trap of bringing back the "Super-Mega-Death-Ray" every time Dr. Killalot shows up and being accused of being lazy or eliciting the dreaded "oh, that again" response from readers. After Captain Hero destroys that weapon, the writer has to show his creativity (through his villain) of coming up with something new and different, because he can't bring back something that was beaten previously; if it wasn't a threat before, why would it be a threat then? I liked the time Dr. Doom was replaced by his ward Kristoff, whose own mind had been supplanted by an earlier version of Doom's. When reviewing his past actions, the "new"Doom realized that one of his earliest plots against the FF (shooting the Baxter Building into space) had failed because of the involvement of his then-ally, the Sub-Mariner; reusing the same plan without the Sub-Mariner should yield much better results. And it did! The Empire in Marvel's Star Wars knew it was on to something with its Death Star... First the original one, then the Tarkin, then the second one! If you don't succeed at first...
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 16, 2015 12:31:19 GMT -5
The Empire in Marvel's Star Wars knew it was on to something with its Death Star... First the original one, then the Tarkin, then the second one! If you don't succeed at first... The Tarkin was sort of a Death Star-lite though, although I loved that story. Actually, the plot that David Michelinie originally submitted did feature the Empire building a second Death Star. What with the secrecy surrounding the making of Return of the Jedi, no had bothered to tell anyone at Marvel that there would be an all-new Death Star appearing in the forthcoming film. George Lucas obviously didn't want Marvel duplicating or pre-empting anything he had planned for Return of the Jedi and that's why the Death Star in Michelinie's original story became the less powerful and decidedly non-moon-shaped Tarkin.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Jun 16, 2015 12:36:01 GMT -5
The Empire in Marvel's Star Wars knew it was on to something with its Death Star... First the original one, then the Tarkin, then the second one! If you don't succeed at first... The Tarkin was sort of a Death Star-lite though, although I loved that story. Yeah... Budgets, budgets...
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 16, 2015 13:13:04 GMT -5
Star Wars Weekly #110Cover dated: April 2nd, 1980 Issue title: The Word for World is Death! ( World of Fire!, Part 4) Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Tones: Howard Bender Letters: Jean Simek Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 7½ out of 10 Plot summary: Buried beneath tons of solidified lava on the planet Alashan in a wrecked Imperial starship, Princess Leia instructs Luke Skywalker on how to perform emergency surgery with a lightsaber on the critically injured body of Mici Shabandar. Once Mici's condition has been stabilised, the entombed Rebels begin to think about their escape. With the air supply on board their craft running dangerously low, Luke decides to use his lightsaber to dig his way through the hardened lava, up from the ship's hatch and towards the planet's surface. After hours of tunnelling, Luke finally breaks through into daylight, but he is promptly captured by an Imperial squad, led by Major Grau. Comments: The "World of Fire!" arc continues, with the second of its three acts beginning in this issue. This second act is entitled "The Word for World is Death!", which is presumably a sly nod to Ursula K. Le Guin's 1976 sci-fi novel The Word for World is Forest. The first thing to note about this issue is that the dialogue Chris Claremont is writing for Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia is much more in character than earlier instalments of this story and closer to the high standards he set for himself in "The Long Hunt/A Duel of Eagles!" in Star Wars Annual #1. Unfortunately, for all of the nice, in character writing that Claremont delivers here, he also gives us a slightly uncomfortable, incestuous moment between Luke and Leia, with the former senator kissing her brother passionately on the lips. To make matters worse, Luke clearly enjoys the smooch, noting that with a send off like that, his mission couldn't possibly fail. Still, like I always say whenever things get slightly awkward between Luke and Leia in the original Marvel run, nobody knew back in early 1980 that they were brother and sister – maybe not even George Lucas! There's also an interesting example of Luke's ever increasing abilities with the Force here, as he meditates to become ultra-attuned to the mystical energy field in order to "operate" on Mici Shabandar, using his lightsaber to cauterise her internal wounds. One thing's for sure, he'd have to have one hell of a steady hand to do that and, even with the Force as his guide, I question whether a lightsaber is precise enough an instrument to accomplish the job without causing more damage than it fixes. Actually, while we're on the subject of Luke and his lightsaber, what the hell happens to all the igneous rock that he displaces as he tunnels through the solidified lava with his weapon? I guess we're not really supposed to ask questions like that. Maybe it was vapourised by the lightsaber's intense heat or something? Interestingly, during this tunnelling sequence, Claremont seems to hint that Luke's saber draws some of its energy from Luke himself – almost as if there is some kind of symbiotic relationship between the Jedi and their lightsabers. It's an interesting concept, but not one that fits in with established Star Wars canon at all unfortunately. I get a real kick out of the scene in which Luke comes up with the fake name Lars Dunestrider, what with it clearly being derived from his adopted family's surname, coupled with a decidedly more earthbound take on Skywalker. Also, I should just mention that for some reason artist Carmine Infantino has suddenly started drawing Luke with longer, almost Conan the Barbarian-esque hair again, just as he did in issues #11 through to #26 of the U.S. Star Wars comic. Overall, I'd say that this is the best instalment of this story arc so far. Infantino does a great job of conveying the tense atmosphere of Claremont's script, with Luke spending a lot of the issue looking strung out and perspiring profusely under the strain of mental and physical exertion. In particular, Infantino's heavy shadow work combined with Howard Bender's liberal use of Zip-a-Tone shading gives the darkened interior of the Staraker a feverish, nightmarish quality that works to great effect in the claustrophobic setting Claremont has created. Continuity issues: - It is inferred in this issue that Luke Skywalker's lightsaber somehow draws its power from Luke himself, but this is not something that has ever been established in Star Wars canon.
Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "So … much for our … perfect mission … eh, Princess?" – An exhausted Luke Skywalker glumly reflects on the seemingly hopeless situation that he and Leia have found themselves in.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 18, 2015 7:47:31 GMT -5
Star Wars Weekly #111Cover dated: April 9th, 1980 Issue title: Unholy Alliance! ( World of Fire!, Part 5) Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Tones: Howard Bender Letters: Jean Simek Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 6½ out of 10 Plot summary: After being captured by Imperial Major Grau and his men, Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia learn that the Imperials are stranded on the planet Alashan too. Grau suggests that the enemies search the planet together under a banner of truce, since they stand a better chance as a team against whoever or whatever it is that attacked them both. The Rebels procure medicine from the Imperials for their wounded comrade Mici Shabandar, before leaving the injured woman in the care of the droids R2-D2 and C-3PO, as they venture off into the wilds of Alashan to investigate. After almost a full day's walk, the team finally locates the destroyed Rebel archaeological camp that Luke and Leia were originally sent to investigate. Just as they arrive, the team come under fire from the same powerful superlaser that destroyed their respective starships. Luke pulls Major Grau out of the way of the blast at the last moment, saving his life and gaining the Imperial's trust. Once the allies extricate themselves from the rubble of a rock slide caused by the blast, Luke quickly becomes concerned that the laser came from the direction of their wrecked ship, where Mici and the droids are. Comments: The first thing I want to note about Star Wars Weekly #111 is that, after the opening truce-making scene between Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia and the Imperials, writer Chris Claremont steers us into a scene with some pretty dark subject matter. We see Luke explaining to the critically injured Mici Shabandar that he and Leia are going off to search for whatever it is that's attacking them, prompting a frightened Mici to plead with him to stay with her. She explains that she knows how badly injured she is and that she's afraid she might die there, alone in the dark. The scene is very powerful, especially given the hints that Claremont gave us in issue #108 about possible romantic feelings that the pair have for each other. Carmine Infantino's art in this scene (with Gene Day on inks and Howard Bender applying the Zip-a-Tone) is really nice, with his compositional choices and brooding shadow work communicating the seriousness and emotional vulnerability of the scene excellently. This is some pretty heavy stuff for an action, sci-fi comic like this and warrants me including the entire page in my review... As for the Imperials, we learn that Major Grau is clearly a somewhat honourable man and a pragmatist too, given that it was he who proposed the truce with the Rebels and handed Luke his lightsaber back after the young Rebel saved his life. However, it's also clear that not all of Grau's men share the desire to co-operate with the enemy: the cowardly Ensign Kyril Lopaki definitely dislikes the two parties working together and that plot point that will come to the fore in future issues. Something else that I want to note about this issue is that, following the rock slide scene, one of Leia's distinctive "cinnamon buns" on the side of her head comes undone, much like they both did in issue #109. It's a weird look and it's also odd that this has happened twice in short succession. Leia's hair looking messy and dishevelled is becoming a reoccurring element of this story. Maybe she needs to start using stronger space-hairspray or something! All in all, Star Wars Weekly #111 is another solid instalment of this story arc. It serves to move the story forward quite a bit, but despite the emotionally powerful scene featuring Luke and Mici, this issue lacks the gripping tenseness of last week's episode. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Humans have so many emotions, Artoo. And most seem to cause them pain. I do not understand, but I'm glad I have none. And yet -- I can't help wondering sometimes... what it would be like." – C-3PO ponders the human condition with R2-D2.
|
|
|
Post by dupersuper on Jun 18, 2015 22:42:49 GMT -5
Fa vourite quote: "Humans have so many emotions, Artoo. And most seem to cause them pain. I do not understand, but I'm glad I have none. And yet -- I can't help wondering sometimes... what it would be like." – C-3PO ponders the human condition with R2-D2. Says 1 of the most emotional characters in Star Wars
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 22, 2015 9:56:17 GMT -5
Star Wars Weekly #112Cover dated: April 16th, 1980 Issue title: A Creature in the Stars! ( World of Fire!, Part 6) Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Tones: Howard Bender Letters: Jean Simek Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 7 out of 10 Plot summary: On board the wrecked star-cruiser Staraker, the critically wounded Mici Shabandar and the droids R2-D2 and C-3PO are shaken by a series of laser blasts that excavate the ship from the solidified lava in which it is buried. With the ship now accessible, a large creature approaches the airlock, prompting R2 to shock Mici into bio-stasis in order to trick the alien predator into thinking that she is dead. The creatures enters the craft, but sensing no organic life it soon departs, preventing Mici from being slain. Meanwhile, Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia, along with Imperial Major Grau and his men, locate an underground tunnel amid the carnage of the Rebel archaeological site that they are investigating. They also discover records that allude to the archaeologists having discovered a huge underground city, with tunnels leading to it. However, an artificial barrier prevented them from entering the subterranean metropolis. The archaeologists decided to go ahead and break through the barrier, leading Leia to ponder whether they unwittingly released the beings that killed them. As the Rebels and Imperials enter the tunnels to investigate, they are unaware that they are being stalked by a ferocious alien creature. Comments: With this instalment of the "World of Fire!", Chris Claremont takes the already suspenseful plot and ratchets up the tension another notch, with the introduction of a genuinely threatening, bloodthirsty alien creature. Artist Carmine Infantino wisely shows us very little of the alien at this stage, other than a glimpse of scaly hand or clawed foot. When the creature attacks an Imperial stormtrooper towards the end of this issue, the savage ease with which it slices through the soldier's armour is quite gruesome and really made an impression on me as a kid (see my favourite panel below). I think my only complaint about this issue, plot-wise, is that R2-D2's sudden ability to shock Mici Shabandar into some kind of death-like bio-stasis seems awfully contrived and also fairly improbable. While we're on the subject of Mici, this seems like the perfect time for me to address something about this character that I've alluded to in recent reviews. When I read this storyline as a kid, I assumed that Mici was black-skinned and of African-American appearance, since Infantino seems to be drawing her that way in the comic, with regards to her facial features and hair. It's also how the unknown colourist of the front cover of this very issue depicts her. However, when "World of Fire!" was reprinted in the U.S. in Marvel Illustrated Books: Star Wars #2 – World of Fire, the front cover (which is painted by Earl Norem) depicted Mici as being Caucasian in appearance (that's her standing between Luke and R2)...
And here's that gorgeous painting of Noreem's again, without the trade dress to spoil it... In addition, the back cover artwork of this U.S. paperback reprint, which was coloured by Ken Feduniewicz, also depicts Mici as being Caucasian... Now, Claremont had already introduced one black-skinned female into the Marvel Star Wars universe, with the appearance of Katya M'Buele in his story from Star Wars Annual #1, so it's tempting to assume that Mici was meant to be dark-skinned as well. However, it could be that the unknown colourist who worked on the cover of Star Wars Weekly #112 got it wrong and perhaps Mici was always intended to be Caucasian. On the other hand, given that the story was reprinted in the U.S. some two and a half years after its initial publication in the UK, perhaps it's more likely that it's simply a colouring mistake on Noreem and Feduniewicz's part. Or maybe it's something altogether more interesting and controversial: could it be that perhaps Marvel thought a Caucasian Mici on the cover of Marvel Illustrated Books: Star Wars #2 – World of Fire would appeal more to American Star Wars fans than an African-American character? That's probably unlikely, given the fact that by October 1982 (when this paperback was published) Lando Calrissian was already firmly established as a much loved African-American hero from the Star Wars franchise. Myself, I feel sure that Mici was meant to be of African-American appearance, but I'd love to know for sure and get to the bottom of this. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Dead is dead, Luke. Once it happens, 'how' it happens doesn't really matter anymore -- to the dead." – Major Grau grimly comments on the carnage at the Rebel archaeological site.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 29, 2015 10:09:10 GMT -5
Star Wars Weekly #113Cover dated: April 23rd, 1980 Issue title: The Guardian of Forever! ( World of Fire!, Part 7) Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Tones: Howard Bender Letters: Irving Watanabe Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 6 out of 10 Plot summary: Deep below the surface of the planet Alashan, Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, Imperial Major Grau and his men enter the mysterious underground city they have discovered. No sooner have they begun to explore the subterranean metropolis, than the group realise that they have been followed by a ferocious alien creature. Opening fire on the monster, the beast glows momentarily and then vanishes, just as a stray blaster shot causes a rock slide, trapping the group. With no obvious means of escape, the team reluctantly press on into the city, unaware that the creature is still alive and stalking them. Comments: The third and final act of the "World of Fire!" story arc begins with an instalment titled "The Guardian of Forever!". The first thing that occurs to me is, wasn't that the title of an old Star Trek episode? Well, almost...Google tells me that the episode in question was actually called "The City on the Edge of Forever", but the portal that allowed movement through space and time in that episode was called the Guardian of Forever, so I was close. Anyway, the slightly unoriginal title aside, Chris Claremont gives us another fairly gripping episode of this adventure, with a decent amount of action and suspense. There's also an emphasis on the treacherous Ensign Lopaki's plotting, which will come to a head next issue. Claremont does good job of conveying the eeriness of the deserted subterranean city, although artist Carmine Infantino's pencils don't really give the same ambiance, leaving the reader to be told what the mood of the opening scene is, rather than being shown. On the plus side, Infantino finally gives us a full look at the murderous alien creature that has been stalking our heroes. Unfortunately and perhaps predictably, the creature isn't quite as scary looking as we might have hoped it would be. Nevertheless, having seen what it can do in previous issues, it continues to be a credible threat. Some of the inking in this instalment looks noticeably different to earlier episodes of the story. The credits say it's still Gene Day on inks, as it has been throughout, but I half suspect that someone else has helped out on certain pages in this issue. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "End of the line, people. For better or worse, we've arrived!" – Imperial Major Grau surveys the huge underground city that lies below the planet Alashan.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 30, 2015 7:28:18 GMT -5
Star Wars Weekly #114Cover dated: April 30th, 1980 Issue title: Betrayal! ( World of Fire!, Part 8) Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Tones: Howard Bender Letters: Irving Watanabe Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 6½ out of 10 Plot summary: As Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, Imperial Major Grau and his men explore a mysterious underground city, an alien creature stalks them from the shadows. Leia is attacked by the creature, as she walks along an elevated causeway, but Luke comes to her rescue by grabbing the princess and jumping off of the walkway with her in his arms. As the pair plunge towards their deaths, Luke snags a nearby tower with his grappling hook and rope, swinging to safety and saving them both. Elsewhere, Grau and Sergeant Anarine are chased through the city by the alien, after setting off an ineffective trap for the creature. The beast corners the pair, but seconds before it attacks, it teleports away. Meanwhile, Leia manages to find a clue to the creature's weakness in some ancient hieroglyphs, prompting her to rush to the city's control centre with Luke. Once there, the two Rebels are confronted by the treacherous Imperial Ensign Lopaki, who is intent on killing them both to further his reputation and advance his military career. Comments: Star Wars Weekly #114 is a really action-packed comic, full of daring escapes, blaster shoot-outs and the constant threat of the marauding alien creature. Carmine Infantino's artwork does a great job here of conveying the fast pace and swashbuckling heroics of Chris Claremont's script, while Gene Day's inking seems to be back on point, after looking decidedly weird at times in the last issue. The sequence in which Luke Skywalker throws himself and Princess Leia off of a high causeway and swings to safety, with the princess in his arms, is somewhat reminiscent of the pair's daring swing across the Death Star chasm in the original Star Wars movie. Of course, the free fall and grappling hook escape sequence in this issue stretches credibility a little, but it's exactly the sort of Errol Flynn style daring-do that informed the original Star Wars trilogy and besides, c'mon, this is comic books! It's nice to see Claremont's sub-plot about Ensign Lopaki's treachery come to a head in this issue, although, as we shall see next week, this sub-plot is somewhat squandered in the end. Still, having Lopaki threatening Luke and Leia at gunpoint serves as an effective cliffhanger. Something that bugs me in this issue is that it's never adequately explained why the alien creature teleported away, just before killing Major Grau and Sergeant Anarine. I suppose that the monster must've realised that Luke and Leia were in the city's central control room and were therefore a threat that needed dealing with immediately. However, the speed and ease with which this monster has dispatched all those that it has attacked before means that it would've surely only taken seconds to finish off these two Imperials. The fact that it left them alive seems unlikely and somewhat of a contrivance on Claremont's part, simply because he wanted the pair to survive the encounter. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Luke Skywalker and Leia Organa -- I arrest you in the name of the Emperor, for the crime of high treason!" – Ensign Lopaki attempts to apprehend Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia at blaster point.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Jul 20, 2015 11:55:37 GMT -5
The Marvel Comics Illustrated Version of The Empire Strikes BackPublished: May 1980 (possibly on sale in late April 1980) Issue title: The Empire Strikes BackScript: Archie Goodwin Artwork: Al Williamson (pencils & inks)/Carlos Garzon (pencils & inks)/Rick Vietch (inks - uncredited) Colours: Carl Gafford Letters: Rick Vietch/Jim Novak Cover art: Bob Larkin Overall rating: 10 out of 10 Plot summary: See my forthcoming reviews for Star Wars #39–44 for the plot summary. Comments: This is something of a supplementary review, since I will be covering the comic adaptation of The Empire Strikes Back in my reviews of Star Wars #39–44. However, there are some distinct differences present in the artwork and dialogue of this first published paperback-sized edition of the adaptation, when compared to the version that appeared in those later issues, and it's these differences that I want to focus on here. The publication date listed on the title page of first editions of this paperback is May 1980. In fact, the book was on sale before The Empire Strikes Back opened in American cinemas on the 21st May and, according to some sources, was possibly on book store shelves as early as April 1980. It was followed a few weeks later by the treasury-sized Marvel Special Edition Featuring Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back #2 (which is dated spring 1980, but was on shelves by mid-May 1980) and by Marvel Super Special #16: "The Empire Strikes Back" (which is also dated spring 1980, but was released on May 20th 1980). These publication dates are important, given their close proximity to each other, because only the paperback-sized edition features the differences in art and dialogue that I spoke of earlier. The differences in the artwork include many of the panels having been cropped, so that the dialogue balloons would be legible in the smaller paperback format (which makes sense), the colouring in the paperback being by Carl Gafford and not Glynis Wein (as it is in the other versions) and most strikingly, artist Al Wiliamson giving us a very weird looking, white-haired and purple-skinned Yoda instead of the familiar green Jedi Master that we all know and love... The story behind this alternate version of Yoda is that Williamson had to begin drawing the comic adaptation so far in advance – in order for it to be ready when the movie hit theatres – that he initially only had Ralph McQuarrie's concept artwork of Yoda to go on, rather than the finished Frank Oz puppet (see examples below). The other magazine and treasury-sized versions of the adaptation, as well as the version that appeared in Star Wars #39–44, had a re-drawn and corrected Yoda in them. The reason that only the paperback edition had the wrong Yoda in it is because it had already gone to press (probably due to a greater lead time being required by the printers of the paperback) by the time that Lucasfilm's comics liaison officer Diana Attias was able to get photographs of the finished Yoda puppet to Marvel. Thus, Williamson had time to correct his artwork and draw Yoda more like the Frank Oz puppet for the other editions... If you look at Luke's speech balloon in the above image, you can see an example of the subtle changes in the dialogue that Goodwin made between completion of the paperback-sized edition and the other versions. As for why Marvel would get Carl Gafford to colour the paperback-sized version of the adaptation, but use Glynis Wein to colour the other versions, I have no idea. Maybe it was something to do with the paper stock used for the paperback? Or maybe Gafford was just Marvel's go-to guy, since he had coloured a number of issues of the regular Marvel Star Wars series, including parts of the first movie adaptation (though his work was erroneously credited to Steve Leialoha), and perhaps he wasn't available to colour the redrawn artwork? I think both of the colouring jobs work brilliantly to compliment Williamson's stunning art, although they are very different to each other: Gafford's is much more fantasy-styled, with lots of bold, primary colours and with a greater emphasis on making the artwork 'pop', much like his colouring of the Star Wars adaptation. Wein's, on the other hand, is earthier, more subtle, and with a greater amount of detail. Which version you prefer is very much a matter of personal taste and, myself, I can never quite decide between the two. Here are some colouring comparisons, with Gafford's work on the left and Wein's on the right... As an aside, although the paperback is the only place that the purple-skinned Yoda, Carl Gafford's colouring and the cropped panels appeared in the U.S., here in the UK, this version was used in the magazine-sized hardcover UK Annual. What's weird is that this UK annual wasn't published until autumn 1980, just in time for the Christmas market, so you would think that there would've been plenty of time for the correct version to have been sent to the UK publishers. The version of the adaptation that was serialised in Marvel UK's newly retitled The Empire Strikes Back Weekly comic was the uncropped version, with the redrawn Yoda. For what it's worth, as a kid reading the UK hardcover annual (which was my first encounter with this adaptation), the fact that Yoda looked a bit different to how he did in the film didn't bother me one jot. It was obvious who the character was and I just put it down to Williamson doing his own stylised take on the character. Another thing that is notable about this paperback is that it represents the first appearance of Bob Larkin's gorgeous cover painting. This cover picture would be re-used on the treasury edition and Marvel Super Special #16. It was also used all over the world, including on the aforementioned UK Empire Strikes Back annual. Interestingly, Larkin's painting features Rebel Snowspeeders that look like the concept art of those vehicles, rather than the actual film prop. As for the contents of this paperback, as I say, I won't be going into much detail here, but suffice it to say that this is the first time in my reviews of Marvel's original Star Wars run that I've awarded a comic 10 out of 10. Simply put, not only is the adaptation of The Empire Strikes Back about as good as Star Wars comics get, but I also consider it to be the best comic adaptation of any film, ever. Also, woo-hoo!...my 1,000th post!
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,202
|
Post by Confessor on Aug 4, 2015 6:32:25 GMT -5
Star Wars #35Cover dated: May 1980 Issue title: Dark Lord's GambitScript: Archie Goodwin Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Gene Day (inks) Colours: Nelson Yomtov Letters: John Costanza Cover art: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 7 out of 10 Plot summary: Among the ruins of a Rebel refuelling station, Darth Vader finally learns that the name of the boy who destroyed the Death Star is Luke Skywalker. Scheming to get his revenge, Vader enlists the help of Ulric Tagge and his younger sister, Domina, who is a member of the religious group The Order of the Sacred Circle. The group wield great influence throughout the Galaxy, but have so far remained neutral in the Galactic Civil War. However, with the Imperials making overtures to the Order, Domina calls on the Alliance to dispatch a representative to persuade the group to side with the Rebellion. Luke is chosen for the mission and sent with R2-D2 to the Order's home planet of Monastery, while Han Solo, Princess Leia, C-3PO and Chewbacca secretly wait in orbit above the planet in the Millennium Falcon, in case Luke should run into trouble. Once on Monastery, Luke comes face to face with Darth Vader, who is there to represent the Empire. Luke wonders if he's out of his depth, undertaking such a diplomatic mission, but Domina reassures him that he is the Rebellion's best hope for persuading the Order to side with them. However, unbeknown to Luke, Domina is in league with Vader and is intent on extracting revenge on the boy for his involvement in the apparent death of her brothers, Baron Orman Tagge and Silas Tagge. Comments: Archie Goodwin sets up a really interesting story in this issue, which is the first part of the Red Queen story arc and the first appearance of the mysterious Sister Domina Tagge. Darth Vader's scheming manipulations, in which he keeps the near-dead bodies of Baron Orman Tagge and Silas Tagge (who readers assumed had died last issue) in suspended animation, in order to ensure the support of Ulric Tagge, who is in line to become the next Baron, are a lot of fun to read. I must say, it's great having Vader back in the comic series and he's certainly a big presence here, having learned that it was Luke Skywalker who destroyed the Death Star. Unfortunately, Goodwin's narration tells us that Vader finds Luke's name almost anticlimactic when he first hears it and there's no mention at all of the Dark Lord recognising the name "Skywalker" or of him realising that Luke is his son. Goodwin also reminds the reader that Vader was the killer of Luke's farther, which as far as Luke and the audience is concerned is true at this point. Of course, when this comic was being written, the fact that Vader was Luke's father would've been a closely guarded secret and, even if the guys at Marvel had known about it, they certainly wouldn't have been allowed to allude to it in this pre- Empire Strikes Back comic. Still, it's cool that this story represents the first time in the Marvel comics chronology that Luke and Vader have come face to face, meaning that their duel on Bespin Cloud City in The Empire Strikes Back was not their first encounter. While we're on the subject of things that don't quite align with what we later learn in the movies, we get another one of those uncomfortable incestuous moments that pop up all too frequently in this era of the Marvel series, when Princess Leia overhears Luke on the laserwave link pondering where he stands with the princess, in terms of her romantic feelings for him. As if that isn't bad enough, we also get Leia throwing Domina Tagge some jealous looks, when it becomes apparent that Luke is quite taken with the mysterious redhead. But, just as I always say whenever these slightly awkward moments arise, no-one reading or writing this comic would've had any idea at the time that Luke and Leia would turn out to be brother and sister. As for Domina, she's a very interesting character of Goodwin's. In fact, I'd have to say that she's probably the most interesting member of the entire Tagge family. She's a complex creation, being something of a manipulative seductress, with killer good looks, as well as a priestess in the Order of the Sacred Circle, and a femme fatale, secretly intent on seeing both of her brother Orman's arch enemies, Luke and Vader, dead. We'll learn later that Domina also has some limited ability with the Force, having received training from Darth Vader himself, but more of that in my review of next issue. Something else worth noting in this comic is that we see Luke leading a squadron of X-wing fighters as the commander of Blue Squadron. I believe that this is the first time we've seen Luke leading an X-wing squadron like this in the comics. Of course, in the original Star Wars movie Luke was in Red Squadron (although it was referred to as Blue Squadron in the novelization and comic adaptation), so I'm not sure if this is a continuity gaff and it should be Red Squadron or whether it's reasonable to assume that Luke is in an altogether different squadron now. After all, he's not in Red Squadron when we see him in The Empire Strikes Back, but is instead the commander of Rogue Squadron (although Rogue Squadron was essentially formed from the remains of Red Squadron, shortly after the Battle of Yavin). Regardless of all that, it's certainly pretty cool to see Luke leading a flight of X-wings against the Empire. Something else that I think is cool in this comic is the way in which Goodwin has Leia mention a previous mission in which she hurt her leg. It's a seemingly throwaway line, but I like it because it simultaneously shows us that some time has passed since the Omega Frost saga and also that we're not going to see every single significant event in the central cast's lives in the comic. As such, it gives the impression of these characters having a larger life than what we see on the comic page. Incidentally, Leia hurts her leg in Alan Moore's later story "Tilotny Throws a Shape", which is set around this same time in Star Wars continuity and will be published in Marvel UK's The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #154 in February 1982. I'm not sure if this was a case of Moore deliberately attempting to fill the gaps and explain how Leia hurt her leg or whether it's just a coincidence. But regardless, "Tilotny Throws a Shape" serves as a very neat explanation for Leia's leg injury. All in all, Star Wars #35 is a pretty gripping issue that sets up all the characters for the coming story arc very well and you really get a sense of things accelerating towards the events of The Empire Strikes Back. Carmine Infantino's artwork is pretty nice, for the most part, with some excellently composed or staged panels. However, his shaky grasp of Star Wars technology and spaceship design, as well as his overbearingly angular artistic tendencies are as annoying as ever to me. In addition, Infantino seems to have taken to drawing Darth Vader's face mask much wider than it should be, leaving the Dark Lord looking as if he's been filmed in a 4:3 aspect ratio, but watched back in widescreen. Continuity issues: - On the cover, Luke Skywalker's lightsaber is coloured red, when it should be blue/white.
- When Darth Vader learns that the boy who destroyed the Death Star is named Luke Skywalker, he shows no recognition of the name at all, despite it being his son.
Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Strange. My family placed me in the order so I could maintain my innocence...be free of the Galactic Empire's many intrigues. Yet here I am, deep in an intrigue of my own...ready to betray the order." – Sister Domina Tagge reflects on the chain of events that have led her to form an alliance with Darth Vader.
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Aug 4, 2015 12:32:52 GMT -5
Great review as usual, Confessor. I remember that even at the time, I had found it interesting that Vader had had to look for Luke's name. His lack of surprise at hearing the name "Skywalker" can be no-prized away in different ways, I think, even if it's clear that the real reason was to avoid spoiling the big revelation in The Empire Strikes Back: a) We can't see Vader's face under his mask, but it's actually like this when he hears Luke's name: b) Skywalker is a name as common in that galaxy far, far away as Smith is in on Earth. c) Vader is intrigued by the coincidence and the connection to the Force, but since before then he had not even a shred of suspicion that his son might have been born at all, he's not all that taken aback. It would be the same if a complete stranger announced me that I had a long-lost son; my first reaction would be "Oh, really?" d) Vader actually is stunned for a moment. As I recall, the splash page is a close-up of his mask with a word balloon saying "Luke Skywalker", and Vader doesn't say anything on that page; this might be taken as a momentary moment of silence, induced by the shocking revelation. All of which makes me realize something... how the heck didn't Anakin and Padmé know they were expecting twins when she was, like, at least in her seventh month? Are Coruscant gynaecologists that inept?
|
|
|
Post by lindario on Aug 4, 2015 15:37:03 GMT -5
If we take Dark Horse comics into count, then the canon explains that Vader found out Luke's last name in the story "Vader's Quest" and that the only new information he got in "Dark Lord's Gambit" was the first name. Thus he had already gone throught the most shocking reveal.
In terms of the history of Star Wars, I think this is one the most interesting story arcs ever written. Because Luke (or the writer) hasn't yet met Yoda, the ethics and philosophy of the Jedi are unknown to him. This leads to Luke showing emotions of extreme aggression and using his powers to commit cold revenge as he's innocently unaware that they are actions forbidden by the jedi code. He does what he feels is rightful and heroic, though actually he releases his inner hatred. That (I think) makes the story more dark than anything that Star Wars fiction (even the "Dark Empire saga") has ever done with the character afterwards.
I doubt Luke has ever been closer to the dark side for reasons as humane and innocent as in this storyline, and that's why it is so brilliant to me.
|
|