|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 27, 2021 14:59:14 GMT -5
Star Wars #92Cover dated: February 1985 Issue title: The DreamScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Jan Duursema (pencils)/Tom Mandrake (inks) Colours: Glynis Wein Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Bill Sienkiewicz (paints) Overall rating: 7 out of 10 Plot summary: Luke Skywalker is being tormented by vivid, Force-induced dreams, in which he sees his father, Darth Vader, preparing to remove his helmet. Following one of these dreams, a starfighter lands near the Alliance base on Endor, carrying a lone pilot who introduces himself as Prince Denin, last survivor of the royal family of Naldar. Denin petitions the Alliance to send ships to his homeworld, where many of the remaining Imperial forces are regrouping. He also requests that Luke train him as a Jedi, but Skywalker refuses, fearing potentially disastrous repercussions for the galaxy if his abilities as a teacher prove lacking. Admiral Ackbar decides to send a reconnaissance force to the planet, made up of Luke, Han Solo, Princess Leia, Lando Calrissian, Chewbacca, R2-D2, C-3PO, and one of Luke's combat students named Barney. Before leaving Endor, Luke has another vivid dream, in which Yoda, Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker reveal that the figure of Vader that he saw in his earlier dreams was a portent of a dark power on the rise. After making an emergency landing on Naldar, the party search through the remains of a huge battleground and soon find themselves surrounded by Imperial stormtroopers. The troopers' armour-clad leader is Barney's old friend, Flint, who has turned to the Dark Side after studying as a pupil of Vader's. As Luke and Flint duel with lightsabers, Leia and the droids discover documentation revealing that Prince Denin actually died some years ago. When he is confronted about this, Denin admits the he is, in fact, Denin's twin sister, Vila, who took on her brother's identity after his death, in order to fulfil his wish to become a Jedi. As Luke's comrades take on the Imperial troops, he and Flint's duel comes to a finish. Barney confronts his old friend, reminding him that it was the Empire who caused his mother's death, not the Rebellion, which prompts Flint to question his path to the Dark Side. A nearby stormtrooper hears the exchange and prepares to assassinate Flint, but before this can happen, Vila picks up Luke's lightsaber and rushes forward, striking the Imperial down as he fires a laser bolt into her. Flint finally realises the trouble that he has wrought and sets off a detonation device, annihilating the Imperial troops. As Vila dies in Luke's arms, she finds comfort in the fact that, at the end, she wielded a lightsaber and acted as a Jedi would. As she passes away into the mist-shrouded, ethereal domain of the Force, Vila finds her brother and Yoda waiting for her. Comments: The story in Star Wars #92 is a sequel – or maybe "follow-up" is a better term – to "The Apprentice", which appeared in Star Wars Annual #3. Here we catch up with Flint, who joined up with Darth Vader and the Imperial forces at the end of that annual, and his friend, Barney, who threw in his lot with the Rebellion. Like Star Wars Annual #3, this is a double-sized issue and, given that it's not by the series' usual artistic team, I strongly suspect that this was originally intended to appear in a never-to-be-published fourth Star Wars annual. I have to say that this is a much better story than "The Apprentice", with Jo Duffy turning in a really fantastic script. The story opens with the gang all back together on Endor for the first time since issue #81, and it seems that Luke Skywalker has taken on a group of new recruits for combat training, including Kiro, Rik Duel, Dani, Chihdo and Barney. Duffy also gives us a fascinating glimpse into Luke's current mindset, examining his unresolved feelings towards his father, along with his fear and insecurity over taking on new Jedi apprentices. I noted in my review of issue #90 that I thought that it was perfectly understandable for Luke to be hesitant about taking on pupils, but what's interesting about this story (and "The Apprentice") is that he sees how not taking on those who have ability with the Force, such as Flint, can also have its dangers. The swirling, Force-created dreamscape that Luke visits in his sleep is also a pretty interesting concept and not without precedent in Marvel's Star Wars comic; we saw a very similar realm when Luke was laying ill with the Crimson Forever in issue #50. At one point, as Luke dreams, he is visited by the Force ghosts of Yoda, Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker (standing next to Darth Vader, no less) – with the latter drawn to look like actor Sebastian Shaw, since this issue was published long before George Lucas saw fit to replace him with the spirit form of Hayden Christensen in the revamped version of Return of the Jedi. ... This is significant because it is Anakin's only appearance in Marvel's original Star Wars series, since his face wasn't shown in the comic adaptation of Jedi. We also learn that many of the rogue Imperial forces that we've heard about in recent issues are regrouping on the planet Naldar. Flint is leading these forces and is now the second pretender to Vader's throne that we've seen in the series, what with Lumiya appearing in issue #88. I must say that the way in which Duffy is showing us the scramble for power in the vacuum left by the Emperor and Vader's demise feels very believable. Prince Denin's also a fairly interesting character, although he (she?) comes on like such an overly-entitled jackass when our heroes first meet him, that I'm surprised they wanted to help him at all. Ah well, I guess that's why they're heroes though, right? The secret about Denin actually being Vila, the dead prince's sister, is a nice touch too and the clues that Duffy plants in the lead up to the big reveal are subtle and clever. On a slightly negative note, there are two or three small, nitpicky things that bug me in this issue. Firstly, how does Denin know that Master Yoda taught Luke? That probably wouldn't have been common knowledge outside of Luke's immediate circle of friends, so how could Denin, from the far off world of Naldar, know about it? Secondly, Luke's lighsaber is incorrectly coloured blue/white in this issue, rather than green (although it is correct on the front cover); and thirdly, the interior layout of the Millennium Falcon is all wrong, with the ship's cockpit visible from the recreational area. We had the Falcon depicted like this in the adaptation of the first film, but back in those early issues of the series, the error was much more understandable, since Star Wars was still such a new thing. There really is no excuse for it at this point in the series. As for the artwork, the first thing that I want to mention is the wonderfully surreal front cover by Cynthia Martin and Bill Sienkiewicz, which is gorgeous and striking. Martin went on to become the regular artist for Star Wars (beginning with issue #94), but this cover is notable for being her very first contribution to the series. The interior artwork is handled by the husband and wife team of Jan Duursema and Tom Mandrake. Duursema' name may well be familiar to Star Wars comic fans because, in the 2000s, she became something of a fan favourite, writing Dark Horse Comic's Star Wars: Republic and Star Wars: Legacy titles, as well as illustrating the comic adaptation of Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones. This is her one and only contribution to Marvel's Star Wars series though, as well as her first time working on a Star Wars story. While the art isn't exactly to my tastes – being rather "chunky", with slightly wonky anatomy in places, and not as photo-realistic as Tom Palmer's work on the series – it is still pretty nice. There's a pleasing clarity and precision of line that I quite like. I also like the heavy shadow work that Mandrake employs in his inks, and the action sequences are excellent, particularly the lightsaber duel between Luke and Flint... Speaking to Abel G. Peña on starwars.com in 2002, Duursema recalled how she came to work on the issue: " Being such a big fan, I could not have passed up the opportunity to work on Star Wars when it was offered! I was working on another project at the time, but worked overtime to be able to draw the Star Wars issue as well." In the same interview, Duursema explained how she and Duffy arrived at the design for Flint's armour: " Flint's character was sort of an analogy for Luke... sort of a, 'What if Luke had gone to the dark side?' kind of story. Flint was a cool character to design. Jo Duffy and I both liked the samurai influences on Vader's costume, and wanted to hint at that, but we both really wanted to pull in something stylistically unique to Flint. So I researched Far Eastern armor, as well as medieval armor, and tried to come up with a blend for Flint's costume. Lucasfilm was really open to interpretation of design for this character." While I can certainly see the influence of medieval plate amour in Flint's design, the samurai influences are somewhat harder to identify – at least to my eyes. Your opinion may differ though... Overall, this is a very good issue, which delivers a compelling conclusion to the earlier, and frankly inferior, story, "The Apprentice", while also providing more fascinating glimpses into Luke's attitude towards taking on Jedi pupils. In addition, we get our strongest example so far of just what a problem the remnants of the Imperial forces can be to the newly born Alliance of Free Planets. The art is good, though not 100% to my tastes, and the dream-like realm of the Force that we visit at various points gives, what would otherwise have been a fairly pedestrian slice of space opera, a much more surrealistic edge. Continuity issues: - Luke Skywalker's lighsaber is incorrectly coloured blue/white, instead of green
- The interior layout of the Millennium Falcon is wrong, with the cockpit appearing to directly adjoining the recreational lounge area.
Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Do you think he never mentioned you to me... ? He told me that his greatest challenge was to come on the day that he faced you! He told me all that. And when my master died, and the Emperor with him, everyone knew who'd killed him -- his great enemy, you … Luke Skywalker!" – Flint gives Luke Skywalker his warped and decidedly inaccurate version of the events leading up to the death of Darth Vader and the Emperor. I’ll agree that this is a much better story than Star Wars Annual #3, and I’ll also agree that Denin/Vila comes across as an overentitled jackass, and very unlikeable, to boot. Personally, I wasn’t too crazy about Luke’s decision not to train and we see there, as you point out, that deciding not to train others has its dangers as well. “Denin” knowing that Yoda trained Luke was something that bothered me as well, Confessor. Another thing I had a problem with is Flint being so adept at using the Force and a light saber after what must have been hardly any training at all. Plus, he’s a Dark Lord now? They don’t make Dark Lords like they used to. It’s interesting, and makes sense, that Luke & Leia didn’t tell anybody that Vader is their father.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Jun 27, 2021 18:38:57 GMT -5
Another thing I had a problem with is Flint being so adept at using the Force and a light saber after what must have been hardly any training at all. Although Star Wars #92 was yet another uninspired Duffy story, I disagree with your issue about Flint's connection to / use of the Force, after all, Luke had no training with a Lightsaber or even tapping into the Force for specific reasons before his brief training session aboard the Millennium Falcon (in Star Wars), yet with short instruction, he's able to deflect laser bolts with a blast shield covering his head. In other words, there are others who could be just as connected to the Force as early Luke was. The Jan Duursema / Tom Mandrake art combination was atrocious. It is clear by this time in the monthly title's run, Marvel cared little about this IP, and just dumped whoever they could find on the title. Sales were consistently sliding toward an inevitable fate since the dawn of the decade, and this issue is one of many strong examples of why. Moreover, the cover left no doubt that Cynthia Martin--even with the brilliant Bill Sienkiewicz painting her penciled work--could not be turned into a competent artist. With only a handful of issues left in the monthly series, one can say with confidence that the worst is yet to come.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 28, 2021 10:16:24 GMT -5
Star Wars #93Cover dated: March 1985 Issue title: CatspawScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Sal Buscema (pencils)/Tom Palmer (inks) Colours: Petra Scotese Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Cynthia Martin Overall rating: 6½ out of 10 Plot summary: While on a diplomatic mission to the planet Saijo, Han Solo, Luke Skywalker and Princess Leia spot a battle damaged X-wing being pursued across the skies by three Y-wing fighters. Rushing to the Millennium Falcon, they take off and engage the Y-wings in combat, since Han has decided that three against one isn't fair odds, even though both types of ship are used by the Alliance. With the Y-wings destroyed, Han, Luke and Leia land the Falcon and pull the X-wing pilot from her wrecked craft. Back at the medical centre of the nearest Alliance base, the Cantrosian pilot, who is named Minka, tells Han, Luke and Leia that the Y-wings were Imperial ships and her base in the Cantros system has been under continuous assault from the Empire. The three assure Minka that this is impossible, partly because the Empire has now been defeated, but also because captured Imperial intelligence proves that there was no Imperial presence in the Cantros system. Nevertheless, they decide to investigate Minka's claim and head back to Cantros 7. Once there, Han, Luke and Leia meet with other Rebels who maintain that they are engaged in an ongoing fight with the Empire, prompting the trio, with Minka and her comrade Sami in tow, to travel to the Imperial base in the Falcon. After coming under attack and making an emergency landing, Luke, Han and Sami are apprehended by a group Cantrosians, while Leia and Minka evade capture. The three prisoners are taken back to a base, where they are surprised to learn that their captors are also part of the Rebellion. Suddenly, they see Durne – a member of the same group of Rebels that they had met earlier – instructing their captors to torture them. It quickly becomes apparent that Durne has been manipulating both groups of Rebels and playing each side off against the other. Leia and Minka appear to rescue their friends and, in the ensuing firefight, Luke saves the life of the Cantrosian leader who captured him, convincing the other Rebels at this location that he and his friends are not with the Imperials. The Cantrosians turn on Durne and take him prisoner, as Luke ponders who the scheming Rebel was working for and what has really been happening in the galaxy recently. Comments: Star Wars #93 is drawn by Sal Buscema, who is probably most famous for his work on Marvel's toy tie-in comic ROM and for a 10-year run on The Incredible Hulk. This is one of only two contributions that Buscema made to the Star Wars series (the other being issue #102), which is a real shame because his ability to tell a story with sequential art is marvellous, with some really interesting panel composition and clever "camera angels" on display here. Take this panel, for example... I love how we have our heroes' confiscated weapons in the foreground and we, the readers, are sort of peering around that rock at the scene unfolding beyond. It's only a little thing, but as a compositional choice it accentuates the tension of the scene and this could almost be Princess Leia and Minka's view of their friends, as they plan their rescue attempt. Regular inker Tom Palmer brings his usual high quality draftsmanship to the issue, although, like his work on issue #91, some of the pages here look much more polished than others. Cynthia Martin again handles the cover art – which is pretty unspectacular – and she will take over as the series' new regular artist from next month. Jo Duffy's plot and script is solid, as we've come to expect from her, and, actually, this issue works as something of a mystery story, with the reader trying to figure out what's going on and who the "Imperials" that the Cantrosians are fighting really are. In that respect, this is a real page turner. Speaking of the Cantrosians, they are the second feline-inspired race we've seen in the Star Wars comic recently, what with the Imperial adjutant Ssssk!, who appeared back in issue #84, and, just like Ssssk!, I'm afraid that they look a little too much like bipedal housecats for my tastes. Something that I find interesting about this issue is that we begin to see that Han Solo, Luke Skywalker and Leia are being lionised as legendary heroes of the Rebellion by the peoples of the newly liberated galaxy. At one point, Leia says that the further away from the galactic centre planets are, the more distorted the stories will become, with the result that the three of them will become living legends. This is perfectly in keeping with what we saw many years later in Star Wars: Episode VII – The Force Awakens, when Rey asks Han about the stories that she's heard concerning what happened during the Galactic Civil War, what with the Dark Side and the Jedi, and Han tells her it's true – all of it. On a related note, I like that Luke shows concern that he and his friend's "legend" doesn't become too big and diminish the sacrifices made by other Rebels. As he says, "everyone who's willing to risk his life for freedom is a hero, no matter who gets talked about." Knowing that it's impossible for the Rebels on Cantros 7 to the have been fighting the Empire, Luke clearly doesn't want them to feel as if they've been fighting for nothing – although, of course, they essentially have. This humility suits Luke well and is a testament to how clearly Duffy understands the essence of Skywalker's character. On the down side, the fact that the traitor Durne is so surprised to see Han and Luke at the so-called "Imperial base" makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Durne was there only a handful of pages earlier when our heroes clearly stated that they were leaving to travel to the base, so why would he not be expecting them to have been there? I mean, OK, maybe he didn't know that the other Cantrosians had captured Han and Luke, but he definitely shouldn't have been as surprised as he was to see them there. Still, I like the fact that it's revealed that Durne was working for someone else, which ties in nicely with the hints about a shadowy power working behind the scenes that Knife was making, back in issue #91. It also ties this otherwise stand-alone story into the larger Nagai invasion a little later on in the series. The Wookieepedia website tells me that it was actually later retconned to have been Knife that Durne was working for in Rich Handley and Joseph Bongiorno's article "The University of Sanbra Guide to Intelligent Life: The Marvel Series" from Star Wars Gamer magazine. Something that doesn't sit well with me is Han's decision to attack and destroy the three Rebel Y-wing fighters that we see chasing Minka's X-wing at the start of the story. Han says, "when I see three against one, I draw my own conclusions about who the good guys and bad guys are", but that makes no sense at all, especially when all four ships sport Rebel markings. Simply destroying the three Y-wings because they outnumber the X-wing doesn't seem like a very good idea at all. On top of that, Luke and Leia go along with the Corellian's flawed logic, resulting in them killing other Rebels, as is pointed out later. Anyway, overall this is an enjoyable issue, with a pretty gripping plot. It was something of a favourite of mine as a kid, but these days I can see that, despite its engaging script, it's actually quite flawed in some respects. Nonetheless, this is a decent enough issue, with some rather nice Buscema art. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Sami, everyone who's willing to risk his life for freedom is a hero, no matter who gets talked about." – Luke Skywalker states his belief that all those who serve in the Rebel Alliance are heroes. I agree with Confessor that it’s interesting that our heroes have been lionized. I think the art is decent, but I do think that the inks look unpolished, which is unusual for Tom Palmer. Oddly, the pencils don’t look like Sal Buscema to me, for some reason. I thought the story setup was very interesting (ad yes, a bit of mystery, as Confessor noted) but I felt that the conclusion was lame and cliched. The plot also seemed a bit similar to last issue, where our heroes go off to another planet to investigate Imperial shenanigans, though in this case, only alleged shenanigans. I liked how Han said to Leia "I was almost loose, you know" on p.19 as she was freeing him. Some nits here. Why would backwater planets be hardest hit by the Empire's tyranny?? That doesn't make sense, and sort of contradicts the implication in ANH that the Empire practically doesn't exist on Tatooine, which is a backwater world. Also, how could Han see the ships' designations from that distance?? I also agree with Confessor that Han’s decision to help the one X-Wing against the three Y-Wings simply because it’s outnumbered doesn’t make any sense. That’s not the same thing at all as helping somebody out who’s being beaten up in a fistfight with three to one odds. And yes, I wasn’t crazy about seeing yet another race of cat people here. Durn’s followers seemed awfully gullible to take his lies at face value, also.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,212
|
Post by Confessor on Jun 28, 2021 11:09:25 GMT -5
I think the art is decent, but I do think that the inks look unpolished, which is unusual for Tom Palmer. Oddly, the pencils don’t look like Sal Buscema to me, for some reason. I just realised that when I was replacing all the images in this review thread a while back (after Tinypic closed down), I accidently put the two pix in this review the wrong way around. D'oh! I'll fix that now.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 28, 2021 12:04:25 GMT -5
Another thing I had a problem with is Flint being so adept at using the Force and a light saber after what must have been hardly any training at all. Although Star Wars #92 was yet another uninspired Duffy story, I disagree with your issue about Flint's connection to / use of the Force, after all, Luke had no training with a Lightsaber or even tapping into the Force for specific reasons before his brief training session aboard the Millennium Falcon (in Star Wars), yet with short instruction, he's able to deflect laser bolts with a blast shield covering his head. In other words, there are others who could be just as connected to the Force as early Luke was. The Jan Duursema / Tom Mandrake art combination was atrocious. It is clear by this time in the monthly title's run, Marvel cared little about this IP, and just dumped whoever they could find on the title. Sales were consistently sliding toward an inevitable fate since the dawn of the decade, and this issue is one of many strong examples of why. Moreover, the cover left no doubt that Cynthia Martin--even with the brilliant Bill Sienkiewicz painting her penciled work--could not be turned into a competent artist. With only a handful of issues left in the monthly series, one can say with confidence that the worst is yet to come. Well, Luke, in theory was supposed to be one of the most powerful Force users ever, as the offspring of Vder (he of the highest midichlorian count ever- granted Lucas had not conceived of this at the time of ANH) so I don't expect every Tom, Dick, and Harry to be able to do what Luke does.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 29, 2021 9:44:00 GMT -5
Star Wars #94Cover dated: April 1985 Issue title: Small WarsScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Tom Palmer (inks) Colours: Glynis Wein Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Cynthia Martin Overall rating: 4 out of 10 Plot summary: At the Alliance base on the forest moon of Endor, the native Ewoks have declared war on a visiting delegation of Lahsbees. The trouble between the two diminutive races is being caused by an alleged affair that one of the visitors is having with the Ewoks' Princess Kamida. This has prompted the Ewok warrior Tippet, who is Kamida's swain, to declare war on the Lahsbees in a fit of jealous rage. However, both sides are, in fact, being manipulated by Hirog, an aide to Admiral Ackbar, who has contrived the incident in an attempt to unbalance the Alliance and make it easier for his race, the Hiromi, to conquer the galaxy. As Hirog communicates with the Hiromi mothership from the undergrowth, the disgruntled Ewoks launch an attack on Luke Skywalker and the Lahsbees, hurling rocks and stones at them. As a particularly large boulder is launched from an Ewok catapult, Luke uses the Force to send it crashing into the bushes – where it knocks Hirog unconscious. As the fight dies down, Luke, Princess Leia, Han Solo, Chewbacca, R2-D2 and C-3PO all try to figure out a solution to the impending war, while Hirog regains consciousness and primes a bomb that will destroy the Ewok village and kill the Alliance leaders. Meanwhile, Lando Calrissian convinces both of the warring sides that this is an affair of the heart and, as such, should be settled by Tippet and the accused Lahsbee alone. As the pair square off against each other, Han gives the woefully unprepared Lahsbee his blaster, but due to his unfamiliarity with the weapon, the tiny creature begins firing it randomly in all directions, as Ewoks and Alliance members run for cover. A stray shot hits Hirog's bomb, but has the effect of starting an uncontrolled countdown to detonation, rather than destroying it. As the Lahsbee continues to fire Solo's blaster, he becomes overexcited and transforms into a huge, monstrous Huhk. The hulking creature advances towards the spear-wielding Ewoks, just as a panicked Hirog runs screaming from the undergrowth. Coming face to face with the ferocious creature, the Hiromi spy flees back into the foliage, as the beast hurls a large boulder after him, hitting the bomb and destroying it. Back on board the Hiromi mothership, Hirog's superiors hear his panicked screams and decide to suspend their plans for invasion and leave the galaxy, abandoning their spy on Endor. With the Ewoks and Lahsbees having made their peace, Luke, Han, Leia, and the others watch amused, as Hirog is pursued through the trees by the ferocious Huhk. Comments: Although I think that Star Wars #94 is a pretty fun read, it also marks the beginning of the end of the original Marvel series, as far as I'm concerned. What I mean by that is, for me, this is the point where the quality of the comic's artwork and writing begins to seriously tail off. Having said that, I do really like the basic idea of an Ewok/Lahsbee war (even if it does turn out that both sides have been manipulated). The clash represents an entertaining and interesting meeting of the Marvel characters and George Lucas's creations. It also serves to ground the action on Endor, which is a nice change of pace from the inter-planetary adventures that we normally see in Star Wars. As an aside, I do kind of wonder if this issue was timed to shine a light on the Ewoks, just as their own comic – which was based on the Ewoks cartoon series and published through Marvel's STAR Comics imprint – was about to debut. The fact that we have an Ewok on the front cover, with not a Lahsbee in sight – making this issue look for all the world like an Ewoks comic – tends to lend credence to that theory, in my eyes. Regardless of Marvel's marketing strategy though, writer Jo Duffy is clearly having a lot of fun here with the notion of these two diminutive, furry races going head-to-head. The set up at the beginning of the issue, in which our heroes gravely talk about an upcoming war between two of the Alliance's greatest allies – as if there is about to be some major galactic conflict – is a good way to hook the reader, before revealing that, actually, the central cast are not really taking the impending war seriously at all. It's also nice to see the Ewoks playing a larger role in the comic, since they've mostly been relegated to the background since the events of Return of the Jedi. We even get a brief appearance from Wicket, who was the first Ewok that Princess Leia met. This issue is somewhat important (or maybe "infamous" is a better word) within the context of the series for two reasons. Firstly, it gives us our first look at Hirog and his race, the Hiromi (who Duffy named after the Japanese singer Hiromi Go, incidentally). Trouble is, I think Hirog, who is initially introduced as an aide to Admiral Ackbar, is probably my least favourite character of the entire Marvel run. The way that he's drawn makes him look like an utter joke! Without exaggeration, he and his insectoid race are probably the worst designed and most poorly conceived alien concept that I've ever seen published in a mainstream comic book... On top of Hirog's appallingly bad design, he's an annoyingly jokey, bumbling character, who's clearly supposed to provide some big laughs, but unfortunately comes across as annoying, rather than funny. Truth be told, Hirog's entire race are equally annoying, with their plan of using the Ewok/Lahsbee war as a way to divide the galaxy being utterly ridiculous – even for a plot devised by a comic book villain! Based on the reaction of the Alliance leaders, it seems far more likely to me that the other races in the galaxy would simply ignore the feud (although the idea of killing the Alliance leaders with a bomb, to further destabilise things politically, isn't without merit). Hirog is just so bad at being a spy and so prone to being on the receiving end of slapstick accidents, that it stretches credibility to believe that he could ever have successfully infiltrated the Alliance, let alone carried out his mission. In addition, the fact that the Hiromi abandon their plans for galactic conquest because of a misunderstanding, seems so hackneyed and unbelievable that it sort of reminds me of one of those old 1950s Marvel sci-fi tales. For better or worse though, the incompetent, bumbling Hiromi will go on to play a much larger role in the series. The second reason why this issue is significant (or infamous), is because it sees the debut of Cynthia Martin as the comic's new regular artist. I have to say right up front that I'm really not a fan of Martin's art. While I do see something sort of "classical" and almost art nouveau about her artwork at times, it's much more akin to '80s, Saturday morning kid's cartoons. Her grasp of anatomy, or posture and articulation, seems to be a little wonky too, and you'd have never gotten panels as slapdash or cartoony as these below during Ron Frenz's run... Come back Carmine Infantino...all is forgiven! This cartoony style of art is – and was, back when I was a 12-year-old fan of the series – a really jarring change of pace from the exquisite, movie-authentic work that the likes of Walt Simonson, Ron Frenz and Tom Palmer brought to the book in its heyday. Palmer is still on board for this issue, but he would be gone by next month to work on The Avengers with John Buscema. Palmer does his best to rein in the worst excesses of Martin's style, but he seems to be rather "dialling it in" in places, leaving many pages looking rather sloppy. All in all, I'd have to say that, although this issue is basically a fun read, it's a little too "played for laughs" for my tastes. I've always liked Duffy's use of humour in the series, but here it starts to tip over into making the Star Wars comic seem like a comedy. The introduction of the intensely annoying Hirog doesn't help things and neither does Martin's cartoony artwork. Still, this issue is important for introducing the Hiromi race to the series, regardless of whether you think that's a good thing or not. Ultimately, Star Wars #94 is a tongue-in-cheek, jokey story, which, while being pretty flawed in some respects, is nonetheless quite readable. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Lahsbees, dangerous? Come off it, pal! You're never gonna convince me you were ever scared of one of 'em. This whole thing is a joke, right?" – Han Solo incredulously asks Chewbacca about the Lahsbees' fighting ability. Well, this was a cute story, in a way, though overall it was just a bit too silly. Han and Lando did have some good, humorous dialogue, though. I didn’t like the art that much, and since it looks like Cynthia Martin is going to become the regular penciller, that doesn’t bode well. I am seeing that Confessor’s comment about the quality of the writing and art starting to drop off at this point will almost certainly be a statement I agree with.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jun 30, 2021 10:51:17 GMT -5
Star Wars #95Cover dated: May 1985 Issue title: No ZeltronsScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Steve Leialoha (inks) Colours: Glynis Oliver Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Kent Williams Overall rating: 7 out of 10 Plot summary: On the planet Kinooine, the Dark Lady of the Sith, Lumiya, learns from a captured former Rebel that he and his party were sent to the planet by her nemesis, Luke Skywalker. Realising that she now has the means to lure her enemy to her, the Sith Lord prepares a trap for the young Jedi. Back at the Alliance base on Endor, Princess Leia reluctantly accepts a group of four male Zeltrons – a race that Leia is not at all fond of – as her escorts and personal attendants, in order to facilitate closer diplomatic ties with their homeworld. As Luke, Kiro and Dani depart to investigate the disappearance of the scouting party on Kinooine, Leia, Han Solo and the Zeltrons leave for a summit on the planet Kabray. Once there, it soon becomes apparent that they have walked into an ambush, and the group is quickly captured by the slaver, Knife, and other members of his species. The Alliance delegation are thrown into a prison cell, but with much help from Leia's Zeltron attachés, they soon manage to escape and overpower their captors. Meanwhile, on the barren world of Kinooine, Luke begins to set up camp, while Kiro and Dani scout the nearby terrain. Some time later, a wounded Kiro stumbles back to the camp, pleading with Luke to save his lover Dani from a mysterious assailant. Grimly, Skywalker heads off in the direction of his friend's encounter and soon comes face to face with Lumiya. Igniting his lightsaber, as Lumiya simultaneously activates her lightwhip, the pair silently engage in a vicious duel. Although Luke puts up a valiant fight, Lumiya eventually manages to gain the upper hand, disarming the young Jedi and knocking him to the ground unconscious. Comments: Star Wars #95 features the first instalment of the Dark Lady story arc, which will continue through to issue #97. The story is certainly a gripping one, with the return of Lumiya, the Dark Lady of the Sith, who looks fairly different to how she did during her first appearance in issue #88. We get a striking splash page showcasing Lumiya's new look, which I'd have to say is a big improvement over her earlier design... Interestingly, Kent Williams's front cover painting, which is a rather nice piece of artwork, by the way, has Lumiya clothed in the armour that she wore during her earlier appearance. Regardless, the Lady of the Sith comes across as a much more sinister and much more threatening adversary here than she did in issue #88. I also really like her lightwhip weapon, which is part-real whip and part lightsaber, with the weapon's metal and leather tails encased in a crackling sheath of energy. Along with the reappearance of Lumiya, writer Jo Duffy also introduces us to the Nagai warrior, Den Siva, although he is not named in this issue. Several other Nagais appear here too, along with Knife, who we met back in Star Wars#91, but their species are referred to as "Knives" by the Alliance members, after the first one of their type that Han Solo encountered. The Nagai race were actually named after the legendary Japanese manga artist, Go Nagai, creator of the popular Cutey Honey series, whom Duffy was a big fan of. Talking to starwars.com in 2002, artist Cynthia Martin recalled that she came up with their visual design by looking at Japanese comics: " Jo Duffy suggested that I look at anime for inspiration for the Nagai. This was back when anime was scarcely known in the mainstream; Jo was really ahead of her time. She showed me a Japanese comic about a tragic vampire that had a strong influence on my concept drawings." To my eyes, however, the Nagai look more like Elves – particularly Dark Elves – from fantasy literature, with their slender, slightly androgynous appearance and pointed ears, rather than exuding a manga influence. But maybe that's just me. Martin's artwork in this issue is still not really to my tastes, but Steve Leialoha's tight inking works wonders at tempering the worst excesses of her cartoony style. Nonetheless, the quality of the art in this issue is a little uneven, with some of it working better than other parts. Martin's quite good at conveying the high tension of Luke Skywalker and Lumiya's duel though, with this page in particular being heavy on operatic drama... Plus, I also really like the inventive way that Martin uses jagged, rough-looking panel borders in the scenes set on Kinooine. This serves to highlight the planet's rugged, inhospitable terrain, while also lending these scenes a nightmare-like quality. Leialoha, who had previously done such a fantastic job inking some of the Star Wars movie adaptation and Star Wars Annual #1, provides some sharp detailing, particularly in the backgrounds. However, while he minimises the cartoon-ish elements present in Martin's work, he also brings a hard-edged quality to her art, which seems to accentuate its ugliness and leaves it looking rather harsh. Ultimately though, the end result is probably some of Martin's best looking artwork on the series, although that's hardly saying very much. It's probably just a coincidence, but the title, "No Zeltrons", is actually something that Princess Leia exclaimed in Star Wars #88, which was also the issue that featured Lumiya's debut. It's actually kind of a throwaway title for, what is, quite a dark story. The group of Zeltron males that are assigned to Leia look rather like a red-skinned boyband, dressed up in camp '80s fashions... Fortunately, the Zeltrons provide some real laughs, which serves to lighten the otherwise heavy script somewhat. It's also nice to see that, after initially establishing them as little more than comic relief, Duffy has the Zeltrons play an important part in Leia and Han's escape from their Nagai captors. That's a nice way to show up Leia's irrational dislike of their race for the narrow-minded attitude that it is. In fact, this is really the point at which Leia's dislike of Zeltrons, which could have previously been dismissed as a simple dislike for Dani, tips over into blatant racism. I mean, just what is it that Leia has against this race?! Duffy's characterisation of the princess as being bigoted towards a particular race seems really at odds with what we've previously seen in the series and in the Star Wars films. Something else that niggles me slightly is how Kiro and Dani seem to be a couple now. Where the hell did that come from? I mean, don't get me wrong, it's a nice piece of character development for Dani, but it just seems to have come out of nowhere. Where was the set up for this development? The only evidence of any vague romantic connection between the two that we've seen was in issue #87, when a frightened Dani cuddled up to Kiro for comfort and called him "darling". However, Dani's still all over Luke later on in that same issue, so it's not apparent that she's developed any special feelings for the Iskalonian. Like I say, I don't mind the Kiro/Dani relationship at all, but I would've liked to have seen a little bit more set up for it. On the political side of things, Duffy gives us some interesting hints at the developing, post-Empire situation, with some worlds feeling that the former Rebellion is too "rough and ready" and too much of a military organisation to administer peace throughout the galaxy. That sounds like a very plausible thing for certain systems to think, as far as I'm concerned, but fortunately Han and Leia demonstrate to the delegates on Kabray that that it is precisely its military experience that makes the Alliance the ideal organisation to secure peace. It's also nice to revisit the Kabray system, which is home to Kabray Station, where issue #77 was set. All in all, this is a much more gripping tale than we got last issue. Duffy and Martin both do a good job of building the tension in the story, as Luke heads to Kinooine and unknowingly into Lumiya's trap. The writer ratchets up the drama further with a second plot to capture Han and Leia on Kabray. The duel between Luke and Lumiya is really well handled and the final page, with Luke seemingly defeated by the Dark Lady, gives us the best cliffhanger we've seen in the series for a while. Martin's cartoon-like art is still bothersome and Leia's inexplicable racism towards the Zeltrons doesn't sit at all well with me, but nonetheless, this is definitely one of the better issues from the latter part of the series. Had this comic been drawn by the old art team of Ron Frenz and Tom Palmer, it would have no doubt scored higher than 7 out of 10. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Y'know, when I first met you, I thought you were unique. An' I gotta say, the thought of a whole race of your kind is really depressing." – Han Solo sarcastically taunts the Nagai warrior Knife, who has the Corellian at blasterpoint. I agree that the art is a little bit better this issue, but not great. I groaned when I was that this issue would be chock full of Zeltrons, but they weren’t as bad as I thought, and were even useful. Some more good humor with Han falling for the Zeltrons’ flattery until he finds out they thought he was Lando. This was a decent enough story, better than the last two issues, though I have no idea why an alliance scouting party would have been investigating an allegedly lifeless planet. Haven’t they better things to do at this point? Lumiya's weapon looks like something a rhythmic gymnast would use. I’m glad Confessor would explain what that weapon was, because I really didn’t get it at all. I also agree with Confessor that the Dani and Kiro relationship came from out of nowhere. I also find it really weird, since he’s a water breather. How is that going to work out?
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jul 1, 2021 9:40:40 GMT -5
Star Wars #96Cover dated: June 1985 Issue title: Duel with a Dark Lady!Script: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Colours: Glynis Oliver Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Bob Wiacek (inks) Overall rating: 4½ out of 10 Plot summary: On the desolate planet of Kinooine, Luke Skywalker faces off against Lumiya, the Dark Lady of the Sith. Igniting his lightsaber, the young Jedi advances towards his enemy, as she activates her lightwhip. The pair silently engage in a ferocious duel, until Lumiya gains the upper hand, disarming Skywalker and knocking him unconscious. The Dark Lady then takes the Jedi prisoner, confiscating his lightsaber and keeping him alive on orders from her Nagai superiors. Later, while conferring with her Nagai accomplice Den Siva about the imminent arrival of a Nagai invasion fleet, the Nagai warrior requests that Dani – whom Lumiya had previously captured – be handed over to him for study. Elsewhere on Kinooine, the water-breathing Iskalonian, Kiro, who had earlier been grievously wounded by the Dark Lady, cobbles together some make-shift breathing equipment and manages to break into her hideout. After rescuing Luke, Kiro helps the Jedi fashion a short-bladed lightsaber from the Iskalonian's stinger weapon and some surplus power packs. Once they locate Lumiya on a nearby outcrop, Luke uses the Force to snatch his lightsaber away from her, as he engages the Dark Lady in combat with his two weapons. After a long fought duel, Luke eventually bests his adversary, slashing away her mask to reveal the face of his old comrade and romantic partner, Shira Brie. As she lies beaten, Skywalker attempts to explain to Shira that what Darth Vader taught her was a lie, but before he can convince her, the Nagai invasion fleet appears overhead. Comments: The "Dark Lady" story arc continues here with a much more detailed version of Luke Skywalker and Lumiya's duel than we saw last issue. In this extended version of the fight we get some very similar looking panels as last time, interspersed with new scenes of combat. While I admit that this duel is pretty spectacular and even more operatic than last issue – what with its drawn out, wordless, Sergio Leone style drama – it does also rather smack of "padding" or "filler". I mean, why do we actually need to see this duel again? Last issue ended with Luke unconscious and at Lumiya's mercy, so why the need to backtrack to the start of the duel again? It's almost as if this arc is really only about two issues worth of story being stretched out over three. It's not until we reach the eighth page of this comic that we actually get anything new, in terms of the narrative. That complaint aside though, Lumiya continues to be a threatening presence and a worthy opponent for Luke. The shocking twist where she is revealed to be Luke's old flame and comrade, Shira Brie, is an excellent one. Shira, who was an Imperial spy, was thought dead by Luke and the Rebels, and was last seen by readers barely alive and floating in a bacta tank in Star Wars #63. I can still remember what a complete shock it was to learn that Lumiya was, in fact, Shira, when the contents of this issue appeared in Return of the Jedi Weekly in the UK. I'm not sure how effective or easy to guess this shocking revelation might be to a modern adult reader, but 12-year-old me definitely didn't see it coming. While I'm on the subject of Lumiya, I'm not sure exactly why Luke has such a problem with the Dark Lady's lightwhip weapon. I mean, shouldn't his lightsaber blade just cut through the leather and metal parts of its tail? I'm not entirely convinced that he really needed two weapons to defeat her either. In addition, the young Jedi being able to fashion a working lightsaber from a blaster and some old power packs seems a little like something out of MacGyver or The A-Team (check out those totally rad '80s TV references, kids!). But I guess Luke has built a lightsaber by himself before (in a deleted scene from Return of the Jedi), so it's not too far fetched, I suppose. There's also some good character development for Kiro here, as we see him trying to follow Luke's example of how to be a noble warrior. The Iskalonian's conduct is rewarded when Luke finally agrees to train him in the ways of the Force, upon seeing just how responsible and well-balanced he can be. Something else that's cool is that we get to see just how badass and deadly Kiro is, as he enters Lumiya's base. On the down side, this issue suffers because of its artwork again. If you've been following my reviews recently, you'll know that I'm really not a fan of Cynthia Martin's pencils and there's certainly nothing in this issue to change that opinion. Bob Wiacek, who was a veteran of Marvel's Star Wars comic from its early years, provides some serviceable inking, but his work is noticeably less overbearing than Steve Leialoha's was last issue. As a result, the inherently cartoony nature of Martin's art is much more noticeable and I don't consider that a good thing. However, there are a few moments in this comic when Martin really does turn in some nice work. We see the return of her inventive, jagged panel boarders, which I made mention of in my last review, although she unfortunately abandons them after Luke and Lumiya's initial duel. Also, the shot of the Nagai invasion fleet arriving out of hyperspace above Kinooine on the final page is stunning (see my favourite panel below). Overall, this is a pretty intense and grim issue. However, writer Jo Duffy still manages to slip in a little humour where she can. The Nagai warrior Den Siva is an intriguing character and he will become even more interesting next issue, as will his relationship with Dani. Incidentally, this issue is actually the first time that the Nagai race are named, which is significant. Ultimately, although this issue is dark and tense, the unnecessary repeat of Lumiya and Luke's duel, along with the narrow narrative focus on Luke, Lumiya and Kiro, serves to make this the least satisfying instalment of the "Dark Lady" storyline. The fact that Martin's artwork still hurts my eyes, with the exception of a scant few panels, doesn't help things either. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "I was very stealthy … and I killed a few of them … not all, as I wanted to … but I didn't want to attract attention … and … and I knew you would not like it, if I killed needlessly." – Kiro recounts to Luke Skywalker how he managed to enter Lumiya's hideout. All in all, a decent enough story, considering the mediocrity of the last several issues. I still don’t like the art (though it’s gotten a little bit better) and Zumiya’s weapon still doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. It’s a whip with both physical and energy components? Well, okay, I guess, but I don’t see why the combination of energy and physical weapons would be able to defeat Luke because he’s only been trained to combat one or the other, not both at the same time. That doesn’t make any sense to me. Still, I’ll admit that Zumiya is a good foe for Luke. I was glad to see Luke agree to train Kiro, who does seem worthy, but I still think it’s a bit weird that his first apprentice will be a water breather. Not very practical. Oh, and it was kinda neat how Luke made a spare lightsaber out of spare parts.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jul 3, 2021 10:17:57 GMT -5
Star Wars #97Cover dated: July 1985 Issue title: EscapeScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Art Nichols (inks) Colours: Petra Scotese Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Art Nichols (inks) Overall rating: 5 out of 10 Plot summary: A Nagai invasion fleet, intent on conquering the galaxy, has arrived at the remote world of Kinooine. Landing on the planet, the starships disgorge Nagai warriors and renegade Imperial troops onto the surrounding landscape, as they get to work setting up base. Watching from a nearby trench, Luke Skywalker and Kiro take their prisoner, Lumiya, the Dark Lady of the Sith, back to their ship and tie her to its landing support, before leaving to rescue their friend Dani, who has been taken prisoner by the Nagai warrior Den Siva. Elsewhere, Dani is undergoing excruciating torture at Den's hands, as her Zeltron physiology is probed by analysis beams, which do not inflict psychical wounds, but which do generate tremendous pain. Though the process leaves her weakened and emotionally scarred, Den begins to become fascinated by his captive's inner strength and beauty. Meanwhile, back at the Alliance base on Endor, a gathering including Han Solo, Princess Leia, Lando Calrissian, Chewbacca, and the droids R2-D2 and C-3PO, listen to Admiral Ackbar and Mon Mothma, as they relay the news that the Nagai have declared war on the galaxy. Realising that Luke, Kiro and Dani are in danger, Han volunteers to travel to Kinooine and rescue his friends, but is forbidden from doing so by Ackbar. The Admiral explains that the Alliance has more important concerns regarding the invasion than rescuing Skywalker, which is ultimately a personal matter. This angers Solo to the point where he storms out of the briefing, vowing to leave the Alliance. Back on Kinooine, Kiro manages to rescue Dani from her cell, while Luke steals important data about the Nagai from the computers in the complex. After escaping onto a high, rocky pathway, Kiro and Dani come face to face with Den, who threatens them with a knife. Kiro leaps at the Nagai warrior, engaging him in a vicious fight, but as the pair wrestle, they topple into a river below. While Dani watches anxiously from above, she is joined by Luke, just in time to see blood beginning to spread upon the water's surface. Unsure of whether Kiro has survived the fight or not, Luke and the distraught Zeltron return to their ship, where they find Lumiya gone, having been rescued by Knife, who has evidently survived his clash with Kiro. Comments: As well as being the culmination of the "Dark Lady" story arc, Star Wars #97 has particular significance for me because it was the last story of the series that I read as a kid. I decided to stop buying Return of the Jedi Weekly in July 1985, with issue #107 being my last... I stopped buying the British comic, after years of being an avid reader, because I felt that the stories were deteriorating; I really disliked Cynthia Martin's artwork; I hated the Power Pack backup strip, and the magazine was becoming full of reprints of older Star Wars stories (stories that I already had in my collection), with barely 4 pages of new content per issue. So, the publication really wasn't providing great value for money to someone who was on just £1.50's worth of pocket money per week. In some ways, it's a shame that I chose this particular issue to stop buying the comic because a new Al Williamson drawn story began the very next week, and he has always been my favourite Star Wars artist. Ah well... Anyway, I didn't get to read the remaining ten issues of Star Wars until the mid-1990's, when I completed a collection of the original U.S. issues. But I digress... This is really the point in the series where the Nagai invasion begins in earnest. Having an alien race coming from outside of the known Star Wars galaxy to conquer the newly formed Alliance of Free Planets is a pretty cool idea of Jo Duffy's, I think. It's also a concept that subsequent expanded universe writers have used for themselves, and I'm specifically thinking of Kathy Tyers' The Truce at Bakura here, with its invading Ssi-Ruuk race. Clearly Duffy's intention with the Nagai was to create a credible threat to the Alliance, which is something that had been sorely missing from the book since the fall of the Empire. Of course, the Nagai aren't anywhere near as big of a threat as the Empire was, but nonetheless, the invasion does inject a renewed sense of urgency and story impetus into proceedings. In this issue, the Nagai warrior Den Siva is revealed to be a real nasty piece of work. He's cruel, callous and cold. In other words, he's a great villain! The way that he cruelly tortures Dani, in order to satisfy his scientific curiosity – regarding her as little more than an insect in a Petri dish – is very sinister. Especially as it's made clear that his probing with the analysis beams will leave the Zeltron psychologically scarred. We also see the beginning of Den's obsessive, quasi-romantic fascination with Dani, which will have ramifications later on in the series. It's a fascinating development for the Nagai warrior, which sheds light on the wider nature of his race. At one point, Den finds a beautiful flower outside his base and Duffy takes the opportunity to make an analogy between the plant's ability to survive on a harsh planet like Kinooine and Dani's own inner strength and outward beauty. As a Nagai, Den has been raised to respect strength, logical efficiency and elegance, rather than fragility, but in the flower – and, by extension, Dani herself – he sees that not everything that is fragile is necessarily weak. Duffy also gives us an excellent cliffhanger at the close of this issue, by showing Lumiya and Den still at large, while Kiro is seemingly dead. Lumiya has really come into her own in this arc, after that rather lacklustre debut in issue #88. Unfortunately, the promise of the character will go largely unfulfilled in the Marvel Comics run. She will only make two further appearances in the series (in issues #100 and #107), and it would be down to later expanded universe authors to use the character to her fullest potential. Something that I think is great in this issue, is that we see Luke Skywalker using the Jedi mind trick. It's a Jedi skill that, outside of the movie adaptation issues, is seldom utilised in the comic. I'm guessing the reason for that is because it makes it too easy for Luke to get out of tight situations. Anyway, it's nice to see the young Jedi using that power here. Duffy also has Luke using the same distraction trick that Obi-Wan Kenobi used when he was deactivating the tractor beam on board the Death Star, by using the Force to create a low, rumbling noise, as a diversion... Other things of note in the script are how Pilf hints at a connection between Han Solo and Knife, which is something that will be explored a little later on in the series. We also glimpse the ramifications of Han, Luke, Princess Leia etc not being allowed to sit on the Alliance of Free Planets' ruling council, following their having missed the inaugural council meeting, back in issue #90. Personally, I have a hard time understanding Admiral Ackbar and Mon Mothma's reluctance regarding Han going off to rescue Luke. That seems more than a little short-sighted, since Luke is not only the last remaining Jedi Knight in the Alliance, but also one of its most important figureheads and greatest warriors. On the artistic front, I really, really do not like the combination of Cynthia Martin's pencils and Art Nichols' inking. The combination produces some horribly angular art, while simultaneously accentuating the worst of Martin's cartoon-ish qualities. In particular, the Imperial stormtroopers look, in their own way, just as angular, stylised and dissimilar to their cinematic counterparts as they did during Carmine Infantino's tenure on the book. However, I find this curious variation of stormtrooper armour on the opening page pretty interesting... What is this supposed to be? A Vader-trooper?! Anyway, Martin and Nichols' art really turned me off as a kid and it continues to turn me off as an adult. Four issues into her term as the series' regular artist and Martin's style is still proving to be a very jarring change from the polished, cinema-authentic work of earlier artists, such as Ron Frenz, Walt Simonson and Tom Palmer. The front cover of this issue is every bit as ugly as the interior art too, unfortunately. However, I do think that Martin's design for the various Nagai spaceships look suitably alien and un- Star Wars-y – which is exactly how they should look, given that they have come from outside of the galaxy. There's also some nice background detailing on occasion in this comic, but overall, the art still is really unsatisfactory to me. Star Wars #97 ends promising us an episode entitled "Far, Far Away" but, in fact, we will get a fill-in story next issue. The promised episode, which directly follows on from this issue, won't appear until Star Wars #101 – even though it's set before issue #99. Confused? To quote Yoda, "you will be." All in all, the "Dark Lady" story arc is an important one. It provides us with the only real clash between Luke and Lumiya that we will see in the series and it also kicks off the Nagai invasion proper. Unfortunately, for me, this is the story arc in which the regular cast of Han, Luke, Leia etc, begin to feel like they're being squeezed out of the picture and pushed a little bit from centre stage by all the new Nagai characters and the return of Lumiya. Unfortunately, this impression of the main cast becoming somewhat sidelined in their own book will only intensify as the series progresses and the likes of the Hiromi, the Tofs and various Zeltrons flood the comic. Nevertheless, this concluding part of the "Dark Lady" storyline is, just like earlier instalments, a gripping read, with plenty of action and intrigue. It's just a pity that the art lets things down and does such a disservice to the story. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "You can trust me, Luke. Trust me to stick a knife in your back if you ever turn it on me." – Lumiya rages defiantly at Luke Skywalker, as he ties her up in order to prevent her escaping. I agree that it was dumb of Akbar & Mothma not to let Han go after Luke. Doesn’t really make sense. I liked seeing Luke use the Jedi mind trick on those Nagai (though Lumiya was able to snap them out of it by saying “snap out of it, you fools!” – kinda surprising) and I especially enjoyed seeing him use the same Force distraction trick that Ben used in ANH. While the art continues to be weak, I still think that Cynthia Martin’s first issue was the worst, and everything since than has at least been better than that low standard. I guess I missed the fact that the Nagai came from another galaxy. Didn’t Timothy Zahn also have a threat from another galaxy? All in all, another pretty good story with poor art. A bit darker than we’ve seen in a while, with no real humor to speak of.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Jul 3, 2021 12:08:30 GMT -5
Star Wars #94 - #97 - Continuing the absolute nadir of Marvel's adaptation. To readers, it all seemed like it was published to fulfill a contract / bleed whatever was left in the IP, which, by 1985--had been watered down from a legendary film series to a franchise aimed strictly at children, with the two TV movies The Ewok Adventure (1984) & Ewoks: The Battle for Endor (1985) along with the animated The Ewoks and Droids Adventure Hour (1985-86) becoming the face of that franchise. Its no wonder the Marvel title had so many cutesy, toy-like species in its last few years, since the main property had fully embraced that kind of nonsense in ROTJ. Then, there's Cynthia Martin: There's endless observations that could be made about her awful pencils, but her oversized version of a Lightsaber was jaw-droppingly terrible. As seen below, its a hilt with a distinctive look... ...not a nightstick, which is the length Martin gave the device.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jul 5, 2021 8:01:08 GMT -5
Star Wars #98Cover dated: August 1985 Issue title: Supply and DemandScript: Archie Goodwin Artwork: Al Williamson Colours: Glynis Oliver Letters: Ed King Cover art: Bill Sienkiewicz Overall rating: 7½ out of 10 Plot summary: While visiting the starship yards of Fondor, Han Solo sees Lando Calrissian and Nien Numb arrive in the Millennium Falcon, bringing word from the Alliance that he is to be sent on a mission to the ore mining world of Vandelhelm, to stabilise the dropping supply rate of metals to the shipyard. With Nien Numb serving as a temporary co-pilot, Han takes the Falcon to a former Imperial prison planet, where he picks up two children – a young boy and his older sister – who are known as "The Venerated Ones". He then transports the pair to Vandelhelm, in order that they can sort out the problem with the Metalsmith's Guild and its supply of ores and alloys to the Alliance. Unknown to Solo, the head of production on Vandelhelm, Guildmaster Orrk, has allied himself with Admiral Mordur and his small band of renegade Imperials. Mordur plans to kill the "Venerated Ones" as a way of maintaining his and Orrk's complete control over the planet's ore production. After a failed attempt at destroying the Falcon as it drops out of hyperspace, the Guildmaster meets with Solo, explaining that his passengers are the last remaining descendants of the families who initially founded the mining operation and that the superstitious metalsmiths of Vandelhelm believe that they can't produce high quality alloys without them. The Guildmaster also explains that the facility has been storing stockpiled metal on drone barges orbiting the planet. With the "Venerated Ones" returned to Vandelhelm, Han assumes that his mission is over. However, upon returning to the Falcon, he finds Nien Numb being held at gunpoint by Imperial stormtroopers, as Orrk arrives outside the ship, having taken the "Venerated Ones" hostage. As the Guildmaster reveals his arrangement with the Empire, the young boy bites Orrk's leg, causing a distraction and allowing Han to gun down the Imperials. Leaping towards the Guildmaster, Han wrestles with him until Orrk is thrown from a high docking platform to his death. Han then flies to the drone barges and docks on the command ship, where he finds that Mordur has set the container ships on a collision course with a nearby sun. Donning a spacesuit, Han guns down Mordur's stormtroopers and engages the Admiral in battle on the ship's flight deck, where the Imperial is ultimately sucked into the vacuum of space. An Alliance frigate arrives soon afterwards and draws the command ship into its docking bay, by means of a tractor beam, while the drone barge's course is changed and the ships are saved. Comments: Star Wars #98 sees the return of writer Archie Goodwin and artist Al Williamson to the series. The pair had previously worked together on the comic adaptations of The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi, as well as "The Crimson Forever" story in issue #50. They had also, between 1981 and 1984, been the creative team on the Star Wars syndicated newspaper strip. Ultimately, "Supply and Demand" would turn out to be the duo's final Star Wars story, which makes it somewhat significant. If you've been following my reviews, you'll know that Williamson is just about my favourite artist to have worked on this series and, right off of the bat, as soon as you flip open the cover of this comic, the artwork is stunning. The story opens with a couple of panels showing Han Solo dashing through a corridor within the shipyards of Fondor, as startled onlookers are shoved aside, but when you turn the page, you're treated to this gorgeous double-page splash... Williamson's art in this issue is, as always, pure eye candy. It combines incredible, sumptuous detail and photo-realism, with effortless panel-to-panel storytelling chops. His lush inking and bold use of shadow, when combined with his tendency to utilise interesting and inventive "camera angles" or staging, delivers some truly eye-popping artwork. The action sequences are fluid and full of movement, while the quieter character driven moments are handled with equal skill. Yep, Wiliamson once again proves that he is quite simply a comic book master. I have to say that the art here is so good that it really throws the shortcomings of the series' regular artist, Cynthia Martin, into sharp relief. I know that it's unfair of me to compare somebody like Martin to an all-time great like Williamson, but it's hard not too when this issue comes on the heels of four issues featuring artwork that I've been very critical about. For example, I've been bemoaning Martin's angular and highly stylised take on the Imperial stormtroopers of late, and seeing Williamson's exquisite, movie-authentic renditions here, it's hard not to think, "yeah, now that's how you draw 'em"... If I were to make one criticism of Williamson's work in this issue, it would be that the older, female "Venerated One" looks a little too grown up. It's clear from Han's dialogue that these two are children, but the older sister looks to be in her mid-to-late 20's, rather than in her early teens, as she should be. This is strange because Williamson actually used his own teenage daughter and young son, Valerie and Victor, as his models for these characters. Anyway, that little nitpick aside, Williamson once again shows us just how good the art in a Star Wars comic can be. Actually, it's a shame that this issue doesn't sport a Williamson drawn cover. Bill Sienkiewicz's painted image is quite nice, but it's a little too murky for my tastes. When "Supply and Demand" was reprinted as "The Vandelhelm Mission" by Dark Horse Comics in 1995 – with recoloured art by James Sinclair and some minor dialogue alterations – Williamson was asked to knock up a new cover for the story and delivered this minor masterpiece... Unfortunately, Goodwin's story doesn't come close to matching the grandeur of the artwork. The basic plot about delayed ore shipments to the Alliance is sound enough, I suppose, but it's also overly complex and not terribly interesting...or at all rewarding. Goodwin's characterisation of Han and Lando Calrissian is spot on and he certainly captures their "voices", but the plot feels kinda lightweight and I'm not entirely convinced it really makes a whole lot of sense. There's also a clumsy attempt on Goodwin's part to set Han up as being irritated by the two children he's escorting, before eventually learning to love them, but it never really comes off. In addition, neither Guildmaster Orrk or Admiral Mordur seem very threatening or particularly memorable. On a more positive note, I suppose it's interesting to see the unique pairing of Han and Nien Numb, even if the latter isn't utilised all that well in the story. It's also nice to see Goodwin bringing the Shipyards of Fondor – a location he created for the Star Wars newspaper strip in 1981 – into the Marvel Comics' continuity. It's difficult to know when this story is supposed to take place. I suspect that it's meant to be set soon after Return of the Jedi, but personally, I've always placed it directly after issue #91, "Wookiee World", because it's mentioned here that Chewbacca is away on leave on Kashyyyk. So, I guess that Han and Lando must've left the Wookiee on his homeworld to keep an eye on things after they'd thwarted the Nagai warrior Knife's slaving operation on the planet. This also explains why Lando is using the Millennium Falcon, rather than his own ship, the Cobra, since Knife stole it at the end of issue #91. Summing up, this fill-in issue is bit of a mixed bag. The artwork is utterly gorgeous, but Goodwin's plot is lacklustre and overly complicated, without ever giving the reader much to care about. Nevertheless, the story does feel quite Star Wars-y to me, in a way that recent issues maybe haven't. Ultimately, despite its workaday plot, it's hard not to view this issue as a last glimpse of the magic that could be found in Marvel's original Star Wars comics. Continuity issues: The Wookiee homeworld of Kashyyyk is misspelled here as Kazhyyyk. Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Listen to the man! He has to do a little temporary duty … assume a bit of responsibility … and he turns all surely." – Lando Calrissian teases Han Solo over his irritability and over-protectiveness of the Millennium Falcon. Agreed all around. More gorgeous Al Williamson artwork and a disappointingly mediocre script by Archie Goodwin. I also agree that the plot doesn't make a ton of sense (and also that Goodwin does a good job of capturing Han's voice). I wonder what was up with this issue. I'm used to excellence from Archie Goodwin, and I wonder if this was a fill-in issue, since it's the only Goodwin/Williamson issue in this run. Oh, and I also agree that a Williamson cover would have been scads better than the Bill Sienkiewicz cover. Not that the Bill Sienkiewicz was bad, by any means, but I would loved to have seen a Williamson cover. The more Williamson Star Wars art, the better!
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Jul 5, 2021 8:42:02 GMT -5
Well, a new rabbit character from the upcoming Star Wars Visions. Kawaiiiiiiiiii!!!
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Jul 5, 2021 11:18:42 GMT -5
Star Wars #98--Taking another look at this issue, it was a vast improvement over the plots published over the then-past couple of years, but it felt out of place with the direction the series was descending to at that point. Although with the truckload of photo resources LFL supplied Marvel--especially from TESB period-forward, there was no excuse for Williamson to use the inaccurate Kenner die-cast Millennium Falcon as a source, as revealed in the photo's highlights-- --with the oversized, misshapen gun turret and the completely screen-inaccurate landing gear taken directly from the toy. The cover--another memorable one from Bill Sienkiewicz--curiously shares a non-Star Wars inspirational lineage from many a "spacemen shooting it out" cover painted by the great George Wilson for various Gold Key Comics, such as Star Trek #15--
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jul 7, 2021 15:38:52 GMT -5
Star Wars #99Cover dated: September 1985 Issue title: Touch of the GoddessScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Ron Frenz (layouts)/Sam de la Rosa (finished art & inks) Colours: Glynis Oliver Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Ron Frenz (pencils)/Sam de la Rosa (inks) Overall rating: 4½ out of 10 Plot summary: On Endor, Luke Skywalker and Lando Calrissian discuss the Nagai invasion, as well as the recent death of Kiro and how distraught the Iskalonian's passing has left Dani. The pair also note that Leia's four Zeltron attendants are jealous of the recently arrived Mandalorian Supercommando, Fenn Shysa, who the princess initially encountered some time back, during the search for Han Solo. Elsewhere, Solo himself is on a mission to the planet Godo with his old childhood friend Bey and Admiral Ackbar. The planet is beset by a strange virus that is slowly wiping out the population, necessitating the three offworlders to be vaccinated against the disease before they can set foot on the planet. The Godoan representative, Fumiyo, guides the trio to the House of the Goddess, a temple containing an statue to the Godoan's deity. While there, Han notices that the temple is actually a techno-organic construct and, with the help of R2-D2 and C-3PO, deduces that it makes the planet habitable for the Godoans, but it isn't working properly, due to two missing miniature statues. Realising that these lost statues are the Dancing Goddess and Minstrel icons that Lando used to own, Han and Chewbacca race back to Endor and enlist Calrissian and Skywalker's help in locating them. Splitting up, Luke and Han travel to a prison in the Keyorin system to locate Lemo and Sanda. After bargaining with the pair, they journey to Arcan IV and acquire the Minstrel from the remnants of their gang. Meanwhile, Lando and Chewbacca travel to the planet Stenos, to retrieve the Dancing Goddess from Lando's old nemesis Drebble. After narrowly surviving an ambush, the pair meet with Drebble, who was given the Dancing Goddess as a reward from the Rebellion, in a case of mistaken identity. Luckily, Drebble is happy to hand over the statue in order to save the Godoans, rationalising that if he were to insist on keeping it, he would no longer deserve it. Once back on Godo, Han and Lando put the two statues in their rightful place, as a huge flash of light emanates from the temple, cleansing the planet's atmosphere and eradicating the virus. As thankful Godoans rush to the House of the Goddess, Luke, Han, Lando and Chewbacca leave the planet on their way to deliver arms to the front line of the Nagai invasion. However, once in space, Lando quickly falls ill and the group realise that he had forgotten to get his vaccination before setting foot on Godo. Contacting Fumiyo to request access to the temple once more, the Godoan reveals that his people have decided to permanently seal the House of the Goddess to offworlders. Furious at this, Han threatens to bring the might of the Alliance down on the planet, ending the Godoan civilisation and destroying the temple, if they refuse to help Lando. The Godoans relent and Lando is brought to the temple, where he is healed, as Solo remains vague about whether or not he would've carried out his threat. Comments: OK, this is where things start to get messy, chronologically speaking. This issue, which is set after the events of issue #101, shows the new character Bey already working alongside our heroes, while Fenn Shysa, who Leia encountered back in Star Wars #68 and #69, is now stationed at the Alliance base on Endor. Both characters would get their formal introduction (or re-introduction in Fenn's case) in issue #101, as a helpful editorial box in this issue explains. However, we do learn pretty much all we need to know about these characters from Luke Skywalker and Lando Calrissian's dialogue. We're told that Fenn has come to the Alliance's base in search of aid because the invading Nagai have attacked the Mandalore system and set up bases there. Fenn brought the towering half-Corellian Bey – who is apparently a legendary warrior and an old childhood friend of Han Solo's – with him. Speaking to the Belgian Star Wars fan club magazine TeeKay-421 in 2011, Duffy revealed that Bey was modelled physically on the Japanese martial artists Sonny Chiba, who is probably best known to Western audiences for playing Hattori Hanzo in Quentin Tarantino's Kill Bill. Apparently, the actor had also once played a character in a Japanese film whose name had 'bey' in it, and that's how Duffy came up with the new character's name. With his towering size, and voluminous, flowing white locks, as well as the casually worn animal furs and cybernetic eye-patch, Bey is certainly a memorable looking character... During the same 2011 interview with TeeKay-421, Duffy said that "Touch of the Goddess" was one of her favourite stories that she wrote for the series. Personally, I'm not sure I would rate it as highly as all that, but it's definitely a good old fashioned, galaxy-spanning romp. It's also a nice change of pace from the ongoing Nagai invasion and, in fact, there's not a Nagai to be seen anywhere in this issue. It's always good when Drebble makes an appearance in the Star Wars comic and it's especially gratifying to see that his personality has changed, as a result of having been decorated as a Rebel hero – never mind that he was being lauded for deeds done by Lando, while using Drebble's name. Seeing Drebble attempting to do the honourable thing, as if trying to live up to his new found status as a hero, is a satisfying crescendo to his appearances in the series (and this would be his last). So too is his desire to now call Lando, his one-time arch enemy, his friend. This excellent climax to Drebble's character arc is one of the reasons why I regard him as one of the best and most memorable original characters in the series. I also enjoy the climax of this story, in which it's left ambiguous as to whether or not Han would've wiped out the Godoans and destroyed the House of the Goddess, had they refused to help Lando. Personally, I choose to believe that Han was bluffing, but I really like that it's open to interpretation. On a related note, this issue features one of the most intriguing covers of the entire run, with Han's attention-getting declaration of, "If Lando dies, I'll destroy your planet!". You'd be hard pushed to resist that if you saw it on the news stand back in mid-1985. On the downside, in the opening pages of this issue, we are informed that Dani is hurting over the death of her beloved Kiro and that no one can reach her in her depression. The trouble is, as I mentioned in my review of Star Wars #95, Dani and Kiro's love affair wasn't properly set up: readers were simply informed that they were now a couple in issue #95. This is still proving to be a problem, because it's kind of hard for a reader to care about how Dani is feeling, when we've not really been invested in her romance with Kiro. If we had seen them fall for each other, seen their love grow and then seen them both blissfully happy in their romance, it would make Dani's mourning for the Iskalonian so much more poignant. As it is, I think it's hard for readers to care. As an aside, I should also note that the panel in the middle of page 2 is the last appearance in the series of Rik Duel and Chihdo. This issue sees the brief return of Ron Frenz on pencil layouts and, after recent Cynthia Martin drawn issues, which I've been mighty critical of, it's great to have him back – even if it is only for one issue. As ever, Frenz's work makes the comic look suitably Star Wars-y, and there's a particularly lovely splash page of Luke sitting in a tree, reminiscing about his recently deceased friend, Kiro (see my favourite panel below). Frenz is inked here by Sam de la Rosa, who also does the finished pencilling. Interestingly, Frenz gives Fumiyo and the other Godoans a distinctly Japanese manga-inspired look, which must be something that was done at Duffy's request, given her love of all things manga... The Godoans are also a bit reminiscent of the Andorians from Star Trek, I think. Anyway, "Touch of the Goddess" is a reasonably satisfying story and an entertaining slice of space opera. The artwork is solid, if unspectacular, and the script serves to tie up of the various story strands associated with the intermittent Dancing Goddess/Minstrel plot line. This comic isn't really much to write home about, but it is a solidly executed and fairly entertaining read nonetheless. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "I finally got to blast someone. Sometimes the basics work best, you know." – Han Solo cheerfully jokes to Luke Skywalker about his having just killed an assassin that had been trailing them. Zumiyo says he doesn’t rule, so he wasn’t responsible for Lando not being allowed in the temple, yet he's the one that finally gives Lando permission to enter the temple. That doesn't make any sense. I thought it was incredibly stupid that they wouldn't let Lando into the temple, anyway. I disliked the ending. I don't mean about whether or not Han was bluffing (which I thought was a nice touch) but the rest of it. Yes, the art was a big improvement over the Cynthia Martin stuff. The story was so-so overall.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on Jul 8, 2021 9:17:31 GMT -5
Star Wars #100Cover dated: October 1985 Issue title: First StrikeScript: Mary Jo Duffy Artwork: Cynthia Martin (pencils)/Art Nichols (inks)/Sam de la Rosa (inks) Colours: Petra Scotese Letters: Rick Parker Cover art: Tom Palmer Overall rating: 3½ out of 10 Plot summary: On the forest moon of Endor, the Alliance of Free Planets' high command detects a fleet of Nagai starships headed towards their base. After dispatching a squadron of Alliance and Mandalorian fighter craft to meet the invaders, Admiral Ackbar orders the immediate evacuation of the Endor base, in order to prevent the Ewoks from getting caught up in the conflict. However, Luke Skywalker and Han Solo are unable to accompany the other Alliance pilots on the mission because they both recently failed a piloting exam, due to their unorthodox flying skills. As the Alliance craft leave the base, Han and Luke venture into the forest with Tippet the Ewok and discover a group of Nagai, led by Han's adversary Knife, along with a number of armour-clad Maccabree warriors. They overhear that the enemy troops are preparing to attack the base, while the Alliance's best pilots are all away fighting in space. The pair also learn that there is a traitor within their ranks who has been leaking strategic information about combat formations to the Nagai, which will give the invaders the upper hand and allow them to massacre the Alliance pilots. As the Nagai and Maccabree depart for the Alliance base, Luke races ahead of them to warn his friends. Walking back on foot, Han comes across his old friend Bey, who reveals that it is he who is leaking information to the Nagai, since he is half-Nagai himself. At that moment, Knife appears on the scene and attempts to shoot Solo, but Bey steps in and blasts the Nagai in his side. Cradling the wounded Knife in his arms, Bey explains to Solo that the Nagai warrior is actually his half-brother. Elsewhere, Luke reaches the base and informs Ackbar and Mon Mothma of the impending ground attack. He also explains that the Nagai fleet already know all of the Alliance's flight manoeuvres. Ackbar contacts the Alliance ships, who are getting badly beaten by a squadron of enemy craft led by Lumiya, the Dark Lady of the Sith, and tells them to abandon their pre-planed combat formations. Lando Calrissian takes the initiative in the Cobra and leads the other pilots in a successful counter-attack, using one of Han's unorthodox piloting techniques to win the day. Back on Endor, the Maccabree warriors arrive at the Alliance base and attack, but Luke uses the Force to deduce that the creatures within their armoured bodies are located within the torso section. By focusing his attacks on that part of their anatomy, he is able to beat them. Realising that the tide of the battle has turned, the Maccabrees jettison their robotic arm and leg appendages and rocket away into the sky in cylindrical escape pods. With the rest of the Alliance now successfully evacuated, Luke suggests that he, Han, Princess Leia and her four Zeltron escorts leave Endor as soon as possible, before the Nagai can regroup. Comments: So, here we are at the 100th issue of Star Wars. Who at Marvel or Lucasfilm could've foreseen back in early 1977, when it started, that the series would still be going strong 100 issues later? Of course, much of the comic's staying power is down to how popular the Star Wars films became and the resultant fan interest in anything related to the franchise. But, that said, the comic certainly did a fantastic job of maintaining interest in Star Wars between those cinematic instalments of the saga, as well as greatly expanding the scope of that galaxy far, far away and fleshing out concepts that were only hinted at in the movies. This double-sized anniversary issue, which sports a very attractive painted cover by Tom Palmer, deals with the invading Nagai's first direct assault on the Alliance of Free Planet's base. However, while that event should be an exciting escalation of the ongoing invasion, this comic really isn't very gripping. It's hard to say why, exactly, but the story seems slow and rather dull to me. The narrative is also kind of disjointed in places, like there are pages missing or something. Even when writer Jo Duffy gives us the return of the arch-villain Lumiya, it's a decidedly anticlimactic return. The Dark Lady of the Sith appears fleetingly while leading the Nagai in the space battle against the Alliance, but really, her role in this battle is thoroughly underwhelming and it could've just as easily been another Nagai warrior leading the attack, for all the difference it would've made. Talking of the Nagai, the secret landing party of Maccabrees and Nagai warriors that attack the Alliance base don't really seem all that threatening. I do think that the Maccabrees are an interesting creation and they are kind of creepy too, but their silly name (which sounds much too close to the Jewish Maccabees of Biblical lore) and their "fat Iron Man" design, undercut and diminish any menace that Duffy might have hoped to imbue them with. However, I do like the idea that the Nagai invasion has been years in the planning. Han Solo's childhood friend Bey explains in this issue that his mother was an advanced scout for the alien invaders and that the entire race were waiting to see who won the Galactic Civil War before attempting to conquer the victors. That level of patient premeditation makes them seem a whole lot more sinister to me. On the downside, Han's whole confrontation with Bey and the shocking revelation that he is half-Nagai and an informant for the enemy, just kinda falls flat. I think that is mostly due to Bey having only appeared last issue – that's too short a time for readers to be all that shocked by his betrayal. I mean, it's not as if he was a long-standing and beloved member of the supporting cast or anything. Something else I really don't like is the plot element about Luke Skywalker and Han not being allowed to fly against the Nagai attack force because of a computer error associated with their piloting exams. That's just ridiculous! It's completely unbelievable that the Alliance would ground its two best pilots, just when they were facing a direct attack on their base from an enemy force. It also doesn't align with what we've previously seen in the Star Wars films: Luke was allowed to fly an X-wing during the first Death Star battle based on little more than a recommendation from his friend Biggs! Now, after years of flight practice and countless successful missions, he's suddenly grounded due to failing an exam?! Of course, I realise that having Han and Luke grounded is just a plot contrivance to ensure that they are on Endor to discover and thwart the secret Nagai ground assault. But nonetheless, it's still a really poor storytelling decision on Duffy's part, I think. It makes the Alliance top brass look like a bunch of idiots. Something that I want to make note of is that this issue represents the first and only time that the Corellian bloodstripe is mentioned in the Marvel series. For those who don't know, the bloodstripe is an award given for outstanding gallantry by the Corellian military, which is worn as red or yellow piping down the sides of a person's trousers... This piping was first referenced as a military award in Brian Daley's 1979 novel, Han Solo at Star's End, but it wasn't actually named as the bloodstripe until Daley's Han Solo and the Lost Legacy in 1980. Duffy shows us Bey getting the bloodstripe in a flashback sequence, when he and Han were both young men. As for the artwork in this issue, I really do hate to be so continually negative about Cynthia Martin's work on the series, but it almost seems like her art is deteriorating with every issue she draws. As I've said before, I do kind of like the vaguely art nouveau influences present in her work, and she was way ahead of the pack in bringing Japanese manga influences into a mainstream American comic book too, but her art is just so cartoony that it doesn't say "Star Wars" to me. Her panel composition is also rather confusing at times and it's not always entirely clear what is happening. Also, there are some, frankly, terrible depictions of X-wing fighters and the Millennium Falcon in this issue. Just look at this panel showing the Alliance hangar... Overall, I've gotta say that this is a very disappointing issue. I would've expected a much more exciting story and a lot more bang for your buck in a 100th issue special like this. I would've also expected much better artwork. Ultimately, it's hard not to see this issue as yet more evidence of Duffy steadily going off of the boil on the series. Unfortunately, that steady deterioration will continue up to the end of the run and Martin's increasingly scrappy and cartoony artwork only adds to the sense of this being a series that is well past its glory days. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Sanity has nothing to do with it! I was a smuggler. That's how we all fly. And Luke's supposed to be crazy, too. He's got the Force." – An exasperated Han Solo tries to explain the intricacies of his and Luke Skywalker's flying technique to the Alliance command. Overall, big picture-wise, I thought the plot was decent. The Nagai’s plan sort of makes sense. However, the idea that Han and Luke aren’t “allowed” to fly because of the results of some test (and further, that Akbar & co. can’t let them fly because of some computer glitch) is stupid, moronic, and ridiculous. I know it’s just a plot device to keep Han & Luke on the planet so that they could discover, and foil, the Nagai plot, but I think Duffy could have come up with a better way of accomplishing this. The stupidity and outrageousness of this plot device spoiled my enjoyment of the story. Fenn showing up out of nowhere and romancing Leia seems a bit forced. To be honest, I’d forgotten who he was until I saw him in his Boba Fett (OK, Mandalorian) armor. Luke taking on three remotes at once was kinda cool (though the second light saber appears from out of nowhere), and the Force telling him how to defeat those robots (or Macabrees, whatever they are) was also kinda cool. Luke’s light saber being uncolored is annoying, though. It seems implied that Luke and Han understand the Ewok language. When did this happen? Also, if Bey’s father was a Corellian, and his mother a Nagai, why is he a giant?? Neither of those races are giants. Also, Confessor is right that we haven’t known Bey long enough to care about his revelation about his parentage and secret mission. The Nagai fleet, led by Lumiya, turned tail and ran the second it became apparent that the Alliance had figured out that they had their plans, and started fighting randomly. That doesn’t say much for the Nagai fleet. The art, again, is not particularly appealing to me, but I’ll still say it’s better (less cartoonish) than Martin’s first couple of issues on this series. I have to agree with Confessor that Martin’s panel composition makes things confusing at times, and the picture he shows of her X-Wings does look like lazy artwork.
|
|