|
Post by tarkintino on May 7, 2021 15:59:03 GMT -5
I knew we were in trouble when I read (in the Star Wars wiki, before reading the comic) that this story was repurposed from leftover John Carter art. And sure enough, it does stick out like a sore thumb. Though John Carter was one of the many sources that Lucas read prior to making Star Wars, this definitely doesn’t feel like Star Wars, and definitely does feel like John Carter. ...and that's the problem; this issue in no way registered as "Star Wars"; its the equivalent of a backdoor pilot on an established TV series, where characters, mood and situations are utterly dissimilar from the real series, and as a result, it is first a glaring drop-from-nowhere on the reader (when first released), then it quickly became forgettable. The cover: Once again, Simonson illustrated an out of proportion Leia; she is far too undersized in the Stormtrooper's arms, looking like the size of a child (when Carrie Fisher standing next to performers in Stormtrooper costumes was never that small). That problem began by the films having fiery explosions in space. After that, anything goes where SW ship destruction is concerned.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,213
|
Post by Confessor on May 7, 2021 16:13:26 GMT -5
I took a look and yeah, the cover of The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #143 is indeed a lot better than SW #53. I wish I knew who the artist was, too! Bits of that cover look very Infantino-esque. Especially the cityscape in the background, the TIE Bomber in the sky and the rope ladder trailing from it. But the figures of Princess Leia and the two stormtroopers-- especially the stormtroopers -- absolutely do not look anything like Infantino's work. And anyway, Infantino had left Marvel for DC a good 6 months or more before this issue was published. I do wonder though if the cover of The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #143 was perhaps the unused cover for the John Carter: Warlord Of Mars issue that Infantino's interior art was repurposed from, but with the foreground figures (and the TIE Bomber, of course) redrawn by a British artist?
|
|
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on May 7, 2021 17:24:57 GMT -5
I took a look and yeah, the cover of The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #143 is indeed a lot better than SW #53. I wish I knew who the artist was, too! Bits of that cover look very Infantino-esque. Especially the cityscape in the background, the TIE Bomber in the sky and the rope ladder trailing from it. But the figures of Princess Leia and the two stormtroopers-- especially the stormtroopers -- absolutely do not look anything like Infantino's work. And anyway, Infantino had left Marvel for DC a good 6 months or more before this issue was published. It looks a lot like Simonson to me. A Simonson in a hurry, maybe, but Simonson nevertheless.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on May 7, 2021 18:17:09 GMT -5
Leia looks like a light Infantino layout.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 7, 2021 18:35:58 GMT -5
I knew we were in trouble when I read (in the Star Wars wiki, before reading the comic) that this story was repurposed from leftover John Carter art. And sure enough, it does stick out like a sore thumb. Though John Carter was one of the many sources that Lucas read prior to making Star Wars, this definitely doesn’t feel like Star Wars, and definitely does feel like John Carter. ...and that's the problem; this issue in no way registered as "Star Wars"; its the equivalent of a backdoor pilot on an established TV series, where characters, mood and situations are utterly dissimilar from the real series, and as a result, it is first a glaring drop-from-nowhere on the reader (when first released), then it quickly became forgettable. The cover: Once again, Simonson illustrated an out of proportion Leia; she is far too undersized in the Stormtrooper's arms, looking like the size of a child (when Carrie Fisher standing next to performers in Stormtrooper costumes was never that small). I was thinking of using the term "backdoor pilot" myself when discussing that issue. If we're both thinking it, there must be something to it.
|
|
|
Post by huladollar on May 7, 2021 19:28:02 GMT -5
The cover: Once again, Simonson illustrated an out of proportion Leia; she is far too undersized in the Stormtrooper's arms, looking like the size of a child (when Carrie Fisher standing next to performers in Stormtrooper costumes was never that small). Or... you might even say she looks like a regular-sized Leia in the arms of giant-sized Stormtroopers, and that Simonson knew what he was doing! Maybe Confessor could have mentioned something about giant-sized Stormtroopers in his review to have avoided this confusion. /s
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 8, 2021 5:52:19 GMT -5
The cover: Once again, Simonson illustrated an out of proportion Leia; she is far too undersized in the Stormtrooper's arms, looking like the size of a child (when Carrie Fisher standing next to performers in Stormtrooper costumes was never that small). Or... you might even say she looks like a regular-sized Leia in the arms of giant-sized Stormtroopers, and that Simonson knew what he was doing! Maybe Confessor could have mentioned something about giant-sized Stormtroopers in his review to have avoided this confusion. /s Good point. Since I forgot to mention those giant-sized stormtroopers myself before, I'll just say that it looked ridiculous, and no explanation was given as to how/why there were giant-sized stormtroopers, that I recall, which isn't cool. I realize it was due to the fact that this was repurposed John Carter art, and whatever beings those stormtroopers originally were (Tharks), were giant-sized, but it must have been confusing to many readers at the time.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 8, 2021 10:56:05 GMT -5
Star Wars #54Cover dated: December 1981 Issue title: Starfire Rising!Script: Chris Claremont Artwork: Carmine Infantino (pencils)/Walter Simonson (pencils)/Frank Giacoia (inks)/Tom Palmer (inks)/Al Milgrom (inks) Colours: Glynis Wein Letters: Ray Burzon Cover art: Walter Simonson Overall rating: 5 out of 10 Plot summary: In an Imperial warship above the planet Shiva IV, Princess Leia and Aron Peacebringer are brought before General Sk'ar. The general reveals to the captured pair that Aron's comrade Ygal Delois has turned traitor and joined forces with the Empire, with the promise that he will be installed as ruler of the planet. Ska'ar also reveals that the Empire's plan is to break the will of the Calian people and subjugate them by destroying the capital city of Illyriaqüm with an anti-matter bomb. As Sk'ar's ship blasts off towards the capital carrying the bomb, Aron and Leia escape their Imperial captors and pursue the general in a desperate attempt to thwart his plan. A fierce battle ensues, during which Luke Skywalker, Lando Calrissian and Chewbacca, along with the droids R2-D2 and C-3PO, make a sudden appearance, having finally located Leia after many weeks of searching. Leia defuses the bomb, while Chewbacca destroys Sk'ar's ship and kills the general by throwing a steel projectile at it as it blasts off. A ceremonial party is thrown in Illyriaqüm in celebration of Sk'ar's defeat, but during the festivities, R2-D2 detects that an Imperial Star Destroyer is approaching Shiva IV. Boarding the Millennium Falcon, the Rebels lead the Imperial ship away from the planet and towards the outer edges of a nearby black hole. Using the Force, Luke manages to successfully navigate a safe passage out of the black hole, as the Star Destroyer is seized by the huge gravitational pull of the singularity and is crushed, killing all those on board. Comments: "The Last Gift From Alderaan!" storyline concludes in this issue, which features a real hodge-podge of artistic talent in its pages. Like last issue, much of this comic is actually an unused story that artist Carmine Infantino had originally drawn for Marvel's cancelled John Carter: Warlord of Mars series, retooled by Chris Claremont and Walt Simonson as a Star Wars story. However, the Infantino and Simonson halves of this story don't quite hang together as well as they did last issue. For one thing, Simonson returns to his signature style of drawing once Infantino's section of the issue is done with, whereas in the last instalment, he and inker Tom Palmer did an excellent job of imitating Infantino's style on the pages that they drew, which in turn lent things a cohesion that's unfortunately absent here. Of course, it probably doesn't help that the majority of Simonson's pages in this issue are inked by Al Milgrom, whose work looks decidedly messy and rushed. Nonetheless, despite the somewhat jarring transition from Infantino's pages to Simonson's, the latter's artwork has its usual great storytelling flow and perfectly captures the fast pace of the Star Wars galaxy. For example, in these two panels depicting the Millennium Falcon deftly escaping a Star Destroyer and a black hole, Simonson gives a real sense of movement to the action. You can almost see the panels come to life in your imagination and hear the sound of the Falcon's engines, as it streaks past the windows of the Imperial ship... Another nicely drawn sequence is to be found in the celebration party scenes, following General Sk'ar's demise. In particular, the way in which Chewbacca barges his way through the crowd, throwing startled guests out of his path, in order to reach Lando Clarissian and bring to his attention the approaching Star Destroyer, is full of humour and a favourite moment of mine from this comic. Chris Claremont continues his powerful portrayal of Princess Leia as the duty-bound victim of the Alderaan holocaust. More than ever, we see Leia questioning the cost of her role in the Galactic Civil War. At one point, after she's forced to take an Imperial officer's life with a blade, we see her tearfully agonise about it, noting that death at close quarters like this is very different to the remote killing of ship to ship combat. Again, at the story's conclusion, we see Leia question whether the deaths of thousands of Imperials aboard a Star Destroyer is any real reason for celebration. While its certainly interesting to see Leia questioning her role in the Rebellion like this, I've always thought that Claremont over-eggs the pudding somewhat, with the princess coming across as a bit weak and whiny at times. Leia's interactions with Luke Skywalker are problematic and a bit uncomfortable too. I'm not sure if Claremont is writing Leia as having feelings for Luke or if she's just very glad to be reunited with an old friend. To be honest, it could be interpreted either way, but it's clear that Aron Peacebringer suspects there is some romantic affection between the two of them. More explicit is the panel in which Luke wonders to himself whether he and the princess might one day be more than friends. Although this is a bit icky in hindsight, the revelation that Luke and Leia were brother and sister was still a closely guarded secret when this comic was written, so I guess we can't really blame Claremont. However, the fact that there's no mention of Leia's romance with Han Solo either, makes me wonder whether Claremont was properly taking the events of The Empire Strikes Back into account when he wrote this story. Another criticism of this issue is that the ending, after the bomb is diffused and Sk'ar is killed, feels a bit tacked on. Of course, we know that it was tacked on in order to conclude the story begun in Infantino's pages, but it really feels different to the first half of this issue. Especially as Aron isn't even involved in the final battle against the Star Destroyer and is instead relegated to narrating the events of this final sequence. Also, Aron fails to save Leia's life in the end, with it being left to the late arriving Luke to take care of that. It all feels as if Aron is unceremoniously dumped from the storyline, once Infantino's artwork featuring him is no longer being used. Claremont also over-estimates Chewbacca's strength somewhat in the sequence where the Wookiee throws a steel gun mount at Sk'ar's rapidly departing ship. Ships in the Star Wars galaxy take off fast – just look at the Falcon leaving Mos Eisley or Boba Fett's Slave 1 leaving Cloud City in the films. Chewie would need to be fantastically strong – and we're talking Superhero levels of strength here! – to hurl a steel object far enough, and with enough velocity and precision, to hit and destroy Sk'ar's ship. Overall, this instalment of the story is inferior to last month's. That's mostly due to the Simonson-drawn second half not really gelling too well with the story that Claremont crafted around Infantino's old pages. Still, this issue has a satisfying ending to it, which ties up the loose ends and nicely illustrates Leia's stoic heroism and innate courage. Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Hey! Be gentle with the material! Do you have any conception of what this outfit cost?!" – An irritated Lando Calrissian admonishes Luke Skywalker for manhandling him and his clothes. Oh boy, this was bad. I thought Leia’s characterization was waaay off. Aron says that "War had been an abstract concept" to Leia. WTF? For real? He also calls her the most gentle soul he has known. Really? Also, Leia feeling such great remorse for killing an Imperial officer – in self defense, no less – is completely inconsistent with the Leia we have known. Then later she feels such remorse for blasting her enemies in the arifight. Again, nothing like the Leia we know. And since when did Leia become such a hotshot pilot, anyway? Plus, they didn’t even show Leia and Aron defeating the guards who were guarding the bomb. “Just take our word for it, they took them out”. And how does Leia know how to disarm a bomb? OK, I can let that one slide. General S’kar has a personal force shield?! Huh? Why doesn’t every Imperial officer have one of those, then? And why’s he running away in fear with that thing, anyway. I also find it really far fetched how S’kar’s ship blew up like that just because Chewie threw a large piece of metal at it. That was kind of ridiculous, actually. That conversation between Luke and Leia at the end was just weird, really weird. On the plus side, the space pursuit scene with the Falcon and the Str Destroyer was very well done, as Confessor alluded to. I also like how Luke used the Force to navigate around the black hole (questionable science aside) while the Star Destroyer couldn’t manage that without the Force to guide them.
|
|
|
Post by tingramretro on May 9, 2021 6:01:19 GMT -5
I took a look and yeah, the cover of The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #143 is indeed a lot better than SW #53. I wish I knew who the artist was, too! Bits of that cover look very Infantino-esque. Especially the cityscape in the background, the TIE Bomber in the sky and the rope ladder trailing from it. But the figures of Princess Leia and the two stormtroopers-- especially the stormtroopers -- absolutely do not look anything like Infantino's work. And anyway, Infantino had left Marvel for DC a good 6 months or more before this issue was published. I do wonder though if the cover of The Empire Strikes Back Monthly #143 was perhaps the unused cover for the John Carter: Warlord Of Mars issue that Infantino's interior art was repurposed from, but with the foreground figures (and the TIE Bomber, of course) redrawn by a British artist? See, to me the Leia figure does look vaguely like Infantino's work, but possibly partly redrawn by someone else. No idea who, though. The most likely British candidate At the time would have been Paul Neary, and it's definitely not his style.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on May 9, 2021 10:50:10 GMT -5
Oh boy, this was bad. I thought Leia’s characterization was waaay off. Aron says that "War had been an abstract concept" to Leia. WTF? For real? He also calls her the most gentle soul he has known. Really? Also, Leia feeling such great remorse for killing an Imperial officer – in self defense, no less – is completely inconsistent with the Leia we have known. Then later she feels such remorse for blasting her enemies in the arifight. Again, nothing like the Leia we know. Agreed. Claremont made it clear he did not know Star Wars at all, and it makes me wonder if he watched the films. From the start of the original film, it is clear Leia is not only an enemy of the Empire, but did not have an issue killing its representatives. Suddenly, Claremont transformed her into the wilting, regretful damsel trope. At no point in the films, but as time went on in the dreaded "expanded universe," too many characters were grafted to the Han Solo trait just because, which watered down Solo's skills being unique and/or formidable in a fight when everyone off of the shelf also had a similar level of piloting skill. Yes--a personal force field would have come in handy to a military organization always getting into firefights with an active revolutionary group, but...naahhh. Just let one guy have it!
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 9, 2021 10:59:49 GMT -5
Star Wars #55Cover dated: January 1982 Issue title: Plif!Script: David Michelinie Artwork: Walter Simonson (pencils)/Tom Palmer (inks) Colours: Don Warfield Letters: Joe Rosen Cover art: Walter Simonson Overall rating: 10 out of 10 Plot summary: Princess Leia leads a Rebel survey team, which includes Chewbacca and the droid C-3PO, to the forest planet of Arbra, in the hope that it will provide a suitable location for a new Rebel base. The scout team soon discover that the planet is overrun with small, furry, rodent-like creatures known as Hoojibs. Unbeknown to the Rebels, the Hoojibs feed on energy and, as the team make camp for the night, the creatures surreptitiously drain all of the energy from their weapons and gear. The next morning, a spokesman for the creatures named Plif informs the princess that the Hoojibs usually feed on geothermal crystals in a nearby cave, but they have recently been forced to flee their home by a large, flying creature known as the Slivilith. Leia agrees to help the Hoojibs rid themselves of the monster, in order that they can return to their home and the Rebels can use the energy crystals to recharge their blasters and communications equipment. Following an attack by the Slivilith on the Rebel's encampment, Plif leads Leia and the rest of her team to the mouth of the grotto where the winged creature resides. The Hoojibs gather in front of the cave and begin to make a shrill, high-pitched noise in order to draw the beast out. Once it appears, Leia and the Rebels attack the Slivilith with improvised spears and the few working blasters that they have. The creature swoops after Leia, as she leads it back inside the cave, where Chewbacca is waiting. The Wookiee grabs hold of the flying beast's tentacles and swings it down into a pit containing the energy crystals, which shatter with the impact and pierce the Slivilith's body, killing it. With the creature destroyed and the Hoojibs' home returned to them, Leia elects to continue the search for a new Rebel base elsewhere, rather than displace the small creatures. As the scout team turns to leave, Plif invites the Rebel Alliance to set up a new permanent base on Arbra, where they can live in harmony with the Hoojibs. Meanwhile, Lando Calrissian has been troubled about the state of affairs at Cloud City, ever since the tibanna gas mine was overrun by the Empire and he abdicated as its administrator. Taking the Millennium Falcon, Lando returns to the Bespin system and lands on Cloud City, where he explores the deserted gas mine, unaware that he is being watched. Comments: The new regular creative team of David Michelinie and Walt Simonson return for this issue, which is a pretty important one, at least within the context of the ongoing Marvel Star Wars continuity. It sets up the Rebel Alliance's new permanent base on the planet Arbra and it also introduces Plif, who will remain a part of the central cast until the end of the run in issue #107, and his race, the Hoojibs, who will be a major Rebel ally for the remainder of the series. Personally, I like the Hoojibs a lot, although I suspect that there are many Star Wars fans who would find them annoying and overly-cutesy. But I've always felt that, at its heart, Star Wars is a classical fairy tale dressed up in space-fantasy trappings, which makes the Hoojibs the cute, magical, talking bunny rabbit that the heroes meet at the side of the road or something. To me, they seem like a very Star Wars-y idea: a seemingly primitive race that ends up helping the Rebellion in its fight against the Empire. Sound familiar? There are definite parallels between the Hoojibs and the Ewoks from Return of the Jedi: both races play a similar role within the overall Star Wars story, both races are small, cute, furry creatures, and both races live on a forest world. However, Star Wars #55 was published a good 18 months before either the Ewoks or Endor were introduced to the movie-going public, once again demonstrating (just like in the Tarkin story arc) what a good feel Michelinie had for Star Wars and how in tune with George Lucas's intentions for the saga he could be. While we're talking about him being on the same wavelength as Lucas, Michelinie also shows the Rebels using landspeeder-esque bikes. That is, floating motorcycles that hover a foot or two above the ground in much the same way as Luke's old landspeeder did on Tatooine. This is an almost identical concept to the one that we would later see in Return of the Jedi, with the Imperial speeder bikes, and in the expanded universe literature as swoops. Michelinie got there first though, as the gorgeously drawn and coloured splash page that I've chosen below as my favourite panel shows. The fact that the rodent-like Hoojibs are not only sentient, but telepathic too, is a really nice idea that makes them much more memorable than a lot of the other alien races we've seen in the series. Interestingly, the Hoojibs can actually make simple, high pitched noises with their mouths – represented here by the sound effects "Sree!" and "Yi!" – but they communicate with each other and outsiders telepathically. They're also energy eaters and don't need to consume food in order to metabolise their energy, but instead ingest it directly. Michelinie starts introducing us to recurring Rebel characters in this issue too, such as Gemmer, who we'll see again in the not-too-distant future. He also shows us that there are female members of the Rebellion, other than Leia. This fleshing out of the Rebellion beyond the members of the central cast gives the entire organisation a much more three-dimensional feel and serves to draw the reader into the daily lives of those that work alongside Leia and Luke Skywalker, and that, in turn, draws you further into this fictional setting. Simonson's artwork here is as gorgeous as ever. He really is a good fit for the Star Wars comic, excelling at both the fast-paced, dynamic action sequences and the more character-driven moments, while making sure that everything looks suitably Star Wars-y. This issue has some tightly packed panels, with plenty of detail and a real cinematic quality to the artwork. I also love his design for the Slivilith. You get a real sense of the beast's mass and its surprisingly graceful movements, as it glides menacingly down towards the Rebels... Tom Palmer's inking is superb in this issue as well, with his usual slick style and some nice use of Zip-a-Tone. In particular, I like how Palmer uses the Zip-a-Tone for the shadowy tree shapes in the woodland backgrounds. When this effect is combined with the Benday dots that colourist Don Warfield chooses you get a really effective evocation of the dense, enclosing woodland terrain on the surface of Arbra, as seen in these two panels... Regarding the epilogue of this issue, in which Lando Calrissian goes back to Cloud City, I'm not sure why he's so surprised that the place is deserted. After all, it was he that instructed the population of the gas mine to leave before more Imperial troops arrived in The Empire Strikes Back. What did he expect would happen?! Overall, this is another fantastic Michelinie/Simonson issue of Star Wars and I really like the message that we get at the story's conclusion. Leia and the Rebels saved the Hoojibs from the Slivilith, in part because they needed the geothermal power crystals in the cave to re-energise their communications equipment, but they also realise that taking the Hoojibs' home from them would make them almost as bad as the Empire. The Hoojibs are impressed enough by the princess's integrity that they invite the Rebels to share their home, with the two races living and working together for mutual benefit. That's a nice message of respect and tolerance to put forth, and it's well delivered too. It doesn't feel hokey or overly sentimental. It's a generous and pragmatic solution, and one that warms the cockles of your heart. One tiny criticism of Star Wars #55 is that I find the front cover to be a bit jumbled and not terribly clear. But all in all, this is such a well rounded, done-in-one, stand-alone story – which simultaneously manages to be tremendously important to the rest of the series – that I'm gonna give it full marks anyway. As an aside, just like the earlier "Droid World!" story from issue #47, "Plif!" was adapted by Buena Vista Records (Rainbow Communications Ltd. in the UK) into a book-and-record set in 1983, where it was retitled Star Wars: The Further Adventures – Planet of the Hoojibs... I had this set as a kid and really enjoyed it. There are a few minor differences to the story when compared to the original comic, such as the Hoojibs actually speaking instead of communicating via telepathy and the scenes featuring Luke and Lando having been removed to streamline the plot. You can listen to Star Wars: The Further Adventures – Planet of the Hoojibs on YouTube below... Continuity issues: None Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "Very well, fellows, let's show that grotto-grabbing villain what it means to incur a Hoojib's wrath!" – Plif rallies the Hoojibs against the Slivilith. I agree with Confessor that this was a good issue. I, too, noted the similarities between this and Return of the Jedi. I think I like the Hoojibs more than the Ewoks, though. I also agree with Confessor that this issue teaches a nice lesson about tolerance and respect, and the Princess’s high morals wound up being to their benefit, also, as the Hoobies are impressed and let the rebels stay. Pretty cool! It does seem, though, like our heroes have ditched their search for Han. I do kinda like, though, that Lando decided to go back to Bespin to see what happened, though it might be a bit foolhardy since the Empire could have left a garrison there. By the way, on p.5 is sort of looks like Luke can understand Artoo, though I think it’s been shown he needs a translator to do that. I suspect that he just is assuming the gist of what Artoo is saying from his tone. I like how Michelinie gives the "anonymous" rebel names. It adds depth to the Star Wars Universe. However, Confessor says that they will become regulars, so I guess they won’t be “anonymous” for long.
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 10, 2021 12:54:13 GMT -5
Star Wars #56Cover dated: February 1982 Issue title: Coffin in the CloudsScript: David Michelinie (plot, script)/Walter Simonson (plot)/Louise Jones (plot) Artwork: Walter Simonson (pencils)/Tom Palmer (inks) Colours: Glynis Wein Letters: Joe Rosen Cover art: Walter Simonson Overall rating: 7½ out of 10 Plot summary: Having returned to Cloud City, high above the planet Bespin, Lando Calrissian discovers that the floating mining outpost has apparently been abandoned. As he ponders the reason for this, he is attacked by his former aide, Lobot, who is malfunctioning and believes Lando to be a threat to the city. Fleeing from Lobot's attack, Lando spots a platoon of Imperial troops, led by Captain Treece, the new governor of Cloud City, arriving in a shuttle to disarm a series of bombs that have been left behind by disgruntled Ugnaught workers. However, in attempting to defuse one of the bombs, the Imperials accidentally set it off, which leaves Treece as the only surviving Imperial on Cloud City. Lando and Treece make a temporary truce, as the Imperial explains that the Ugnaughts planted the bombs because they wanted the tibanna gas mining operation to return to the surface of Bespin, where they could proudly work as miners instead of being treated like menials in Cloud City. Calrissian and Treece manage to capture and fix the rampaging Lobot, returning him to his normal self. Lando then commands Lobot to disarm the remaining bombs, but as soon as he does, the treacherous Treece kicks Lando through a safety railing, sending him plunging down towards the surface of Bespin. Meanwhile, back at the new Rebel base on Arbra, Luke Skywalker is becoming concerned about Lando, since he hasn't checked in with the Alliance since he left for Bespin. Luke decides to take Lieutenant Shira Brie with him on a mission to Cloud City to investigate Lando's communications silence. Comments: The two-part Return to Bespin story arc begins in this issue, which, although it's a really enjoyable read, is unfortunately flawed with some fairly glaring continuity problems. For one thing, as I mentioned in my review of last issue, why is the fact that Cloud City is deserted so surprising to Lando? After all, it was he, in The Empire Strikes Back, who instructed the population of the city to evacuate before more Imperial troops arrived. I guess that we must assume that most of the people living and working there ignored him because in this story we learn that the population evacuated to the surface of the planet when they learned that the Ugnaughts had planted bombs in the city. Which leads us to another continuity issue: Bespin is a gaseous planet and therefore has no solid surface. The fact that the planet was a gas giant had already been established in Donald F. Glut's novelization of The Empire Strikes Back and in issue #43 of the Star Wars comic, both of which were published in 1980, so there really is no excuse for this mistake. While we're on the subject of Bespin, it's stated here that tibanna gas, which is the substance that Cloud City mines, is an anti-gravity gas and it is this gas that evidently keeps the city afloat above the planet. I assume that David Michelinie got this information from the Art of The Empire Strikes Back book, which was published in late 1980, but later expanded universe sources have established that tibanna gas is, in fact, used in heating and also as a coolant for hyperdrives. On the plus side, Walt Simonson and Tom Palmer's artwork is as gorgeous as ever, with some nicely inventive panel layouts from the former. Simonson also helps out with the plotting for the first time in this issue. This is something that he would continue to do for the remainder of his time on Marvel's Star Wars series. Speaking in Amazing Heroes #13 from 1982, Michelinie explained why he decided to include Simonson in the writing process: "I like working with the artists – the penciller specifically, both artists if possible. The main advantage to that – especially in Walt's case – is that he has a lot more enthusiasm, puts a lot more into it, has a lot more fun doing it, than if I just handed him a plot and said, 'Do this.' As a result his art's a lot more fun and I can have a lot more fun writing it and I can put more energy into it." Michelinie's scripting is really good and, in particular, he's creating a character for Lando that fits in perfectly with what we will see of him in Return of the Jedi. Michelinie writes him as a brave and cunning warrior, who uses his gambler's instincts to play the odds, which, as far as the comic is concerned, prevents him from simply becoming a Han Solo clone. I must say that it's really quite impressive that Michelinie was able to read Lando's character so well from his somewhat brief appearance in The Empire Strikes Back and then build on that in the comic. It's also great to be taken back to Cloud City and to see Lobot again, although I'm not convinced that he should really have the ability to telekinetically manipulate electronic machinary like he does here. Still, I remember getting a real kick out of seeing ol' baldy again as a kid. Also, having Lando freeze a group of Imperial stormtroopers in the city's carbon freezing facility is especially gratifying, given what happened to Han in that very room in Empire. In addition, the talking bomb left by the Ugnaughts and the vaguely Samurai-esque Imperial bomb disposal troops are both nice touches on Michelinie and Simonson's part. Captain Treece is a fairly forgettable, cookie-cutter Imperial officer, but he makes for a reasonable enough antagonist for Lando. The brief interlude in this issue showing us how the Rebel Alliance is settling into its new base on Arbra is really nicely done. We get to see Rebel airspeeders being given a camouflage paint job for the arboreal world, which nicely demonstrates how the Rebellion adapts to different locales. This is another example of what I talked about in my review of last issue, about how Michelinie writes a living, breathing Rebel Alliance that feels very three-dimensional and draws the reader into the daily lives of those that work alongside Luke and Leia. Speaking of Luke and Leia's fellow Rebels, undoubtedly the most important aspect of this issue is the first appearance of Shira Brie (initially spelled as "Brei" here), an auburn-headed female Rebel pilot that accompanies Luke on his mission to Bespin. Shira will become a major recurring character during Michelinie's run and would also re-appear in the post- Return of the Jedi issues and in some of the later expanded universe novels of the early 21st century. Her debut in this issue is fairly unspectacular, but already there are hints of Princess Leia's jealousy over Shira's burgeoning relationship with Luke. Overall, this is another enjoyable issue of the Michelinie/Simonson run. It's just unfortunate that it's somewhat marred by a couple of continuity problems. Continuity issues: - Bespin is a gaseous world with no solid surface, yet it's stated in this issue that the Ugnaughts and the population of Cloud City are currently residing on the planet's surface.
- Tibanna gas is described here as an anti-gravity gas, but in accepted Star Wars canon it is used as a heating fuel or a coolant for hyperdrive engines and has no anti-gravity properties.
Favourite panel: Favourite quote: "That's one for you, Han." – Lando Calrissian chalks up three carbon frozen stormtroopers as revenge for the Empire's freezing of Han Solo. First the good: The art is excellent. I like Palmer’s inks over Simonson’s pencils more than Simonson’s inking in the previous issue. I also like that Lando gets a solo story, and I think his dialogue is pretty good here. I think that the overall plot is decent. There’s also a good cliffhanger, though I strongly suspect that Luke and Shira will show up in the nick of time. But…lots of problems here, and Confessor already mentioned a lot of them. For instance, Bespin being a gas planet (thus having no surface for the people to get evacuated to) and Tibanna not being an anti-gravity gas. I also have problems with the depiction of Lobot. He’s described as a cyborg, given superhuman strength, and also referred to as “the Lobot” as if Lobot is another term for robot or cyborg, rather than his name. I didn’t get the impression that any of these things is correct from my many viewings of the movie, and a look at wookieepedia seems to confirm my suspicions that these are incorrect characterizations. Lobot is indeed a proper name. He has cybernetic implants in his head, but I don’t think that they should give him super strength. This is another instance of the people at Marvel making this too much like a superhero comic instead of a Star Wars comic. (This is neither here nor there, but I think those godawful Disney sequels also make the Jedi and Sith more like comic book superheroes and supervillains, ignoring the more mystical aspects of the Force that Lucas had focused on.) Also, Lobot never talked in the movie. I have no idea if he was supposed to be mute or not, but he talked a lot in this comic, and it was a bit jarring. I find it interesting here that Luke seems to be ditching Leia for Shira. There’s no way Michelinie could have known that Luke & Leia were twins at this point, so it’s interesting to see him give Luke another potential love interest (and Leia jealous). Perhaps he saw the writing on the wall with Leia & Han’s “I love you – I know” exchange in The Empire Strikes Back? Or perhaps he just wanted to add some spice.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,213
|
Post by Confessor on May 11, 2021 5:59:06 GMT -5
Yeah, for me, the Simonson-drawn parts of the issue don't really jell too well with the John Carter parts. Still, I kinda like the ending, I must say. I, too, noted the similarities between this and Return of the Jedi. I think I like the Hoojibs more than the Ewoks, though. I kinda like them both. The Hoojibs are a really nice addition to the comic though. It does seem, though, like our heroes have ditched their search for Han. I never really saw it as being like that. I think it's just a case of more important Rebel business coming up that supersedes the need to find and rescue one Rebel hero. The Alliance has been without a main base since they left Hoth and subsequently abandoned Golrath, so finding a new permanent base has to take precedence. The search for Han will resume before too long. By the way, on p.5 is sort of looks like Luke can understand Artoo, though I think it’s been shown he needs a translator to do that. I suspect that he just is assuming the gist of what Artoo is saying from his tone. Maybe, or it could be that R2 is just bleeping a general greeting and Luke was already aware that the droid had finished his pre-flight check on the Falcon. I can't say that I've ever read that panel as Luke being able to understand R2. First the good: The art is excellent. I like Palmer’s inks over Simonson’s pencils more than Simonson’s inking in the previous issue. I also like that Lando gets a solo story, and I think his dialogue is pretty good here. I think that the overall plot is decent. There’s also a good cliffhanger, though I strongly suspect that Luke and Shira will show up in the nick of time. Yeah, this is a really fun issue. I remember my friends and I got a real kick out of seeing Lando go back to a deserted Cloud City back in the day. But…lots of problems here, and Confessor already mentioned a lot of them. For instance, Bespin being a gas planet (thus having no surface for the people to get evacuated to) and Tibanna not being an anti-gravity gas. Yeah, this was a glaring continuity error; Bespin being a gaseous planet had already been established by this point in the ESB novelization and the ESB comic adaptation. This is an uncharacteristically sloppy gaff from Michelinie. However, the gaff about tibanna gas being an anti-grav gas isn't really his fault: this factoid had been published in the Art of The Empire Strikes Back book back in 1980 (which is where I assume Michelinie got it). I also have problems with the depiction of Lobot. He’s described as a cyborg, given superhuman strength, and also referred to as “the Lobot” as if Lobot is another term for robot or cyborg, rather than his name. I didn’t get the impression that any of these things is correct from my many viewings of the movie, and a look at wookieepedia seems to confirm my suspicions that these are incorrect characterizations. Lobot is indeed a proper name. He has cybernetic implants in his head, but I don’t think that they should give him super strength. This is another instance of the people at Marvel making this too much like a superhero comic instead of a Star Wars comic. (This is neither here nor there, but I think those godawful Disney sequels also make the Jedi and Sith more like comic book superheroes and supervillains, ignoring the more mystical aspects of the Force that Lucas had focused on.) Also, Lobot never talked in the movie. I have no idea if he was supposed to be mute or not, but he talked a lot in this comic, and it was a bit jarring. Yeah...good points. Lobot talking never really bothered me (after all, he was not on screen for very long in ESB, so there was no reason to believe that he is or was actually mute). As for the increased strength, I guess that's because he's a cyborg. I'm not sure whether it had been established at this point that his cybernetic enhancements were confined to his brain, or whether that was the only outwardly visible evidence of his enhancement? I guess Michelinie was maybe thinking he had mechanically enhanced limbs, a la Captain Valance or Darth Vader, hence the "super-strength". I find it interesting here that Luke seems to be ditching Leia for Shira. There’s no way Michelinie could have known that Luke & Leia were twins at this point, so it’s interesting to see him give Luke another potential love interest (and Leia jealous). Perhaps he saw the writing on the wall with Leia & Han’s “I love you – I know” exchange in The Empire Strikes Back? Or perhaps he just wanted to add some spice. I think that, on the surface of things, its just Michelinie taking his lead from ESB. That film had established a clear romance between Leia and Han -- as opposed to the "love triangle" of the first SW movie. So, that development left Luke out in the cold, romantically speaking. However, Han was out of the picture, which meant that the romance angle in the comic was dead...or at least on hold for the time being. Since Michelinie was now free to inject some romantic drama into Luke's life, and given that the franchise's main romantic male lead was on ice (forgive the pun), supplying the young Jedi with a love interest and having Leia have a slightly jealous reaction to her, was just a neat way to increase the dramatic tension in the comic.
|
|
Confessor
CCF Mod Squad
Not Bucky O'Hare!
Posts: 10,213
|
Post by Confessor on May 11, 2021 6:10:28 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by dbutler69 on May 11, 2021 10:16:45 GMT -5
I find it interesting here that Luke seems to be ditching Leia for Shira. There’s no way Michelinie could have known that Luke & Leia were twins at this point, so it’s interesting to see him give Luke another potential love interest (and Leia jealous). Perhaps he saw the writing on the wall with Leia & Han’s “I love you – I know” exchange in The Empire Strikes Back? Or perhaps he just wanted to add some spice. I think that, on the surface of things, its just Michelinie taking his lead from ESB. That film had established a clear romance between Leia and Han -- as opposed to the "love triangle" of the first SW movie. So, that development left Luke out in the cold, romantically speaking. However, Han was out of the picture, which meant that the romance angle in the comic was dead...or at least on hold for the time being. Since Michelinie was now free to inject some romantic drama into Luke's life, and given that the franchise's main romantic male lead was on ice (forgive the pun), supplying the young Jedi with a love interest and having Leia have a slightly jealous reaction to her, was just a neat way to increase the dramatic tension in the comic. All true. Now, then, I believe the reason they froze Han in the first place was because there was no guarantee that Harrison Ford would sign up for a third film (though the other principals had already signed on) so this was a sort of plan B in case he decided not to re-up. I also recall reading that Harrison Ford wanted Han Solo killed off in Return of the Jedi. If either of these things had come to pass, I imagine that the romance between Luke & Leia would be back on. I suspect that it was known at the time that this comic was written, though, that Harrison Ford would be back.
|
|