|
Post by Deleted on Nov 12, 2017 14:02:43 GMT -5
That means that every woman has had to sleep with someone they didn't like to get a job in Hollywood. I don't think that's accurate. No no, I don't mean that - I mean that each of those 4 scenarios are amplified when there's a power relationship involved. Having a power relationship without the advances is entirely different
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Nov 12, 2017 14:28:18 GMT -5
That means that every woman has had to sleep with someone they didn't like to get a job in Hollywood. I don't think that's accurate. No no, I don't mean that - I mean that each of those 4 scenarios are amplified when there's a power relationship involved. Having a power relationship without the advances is entirely different K. But what annoys me is that now EVERYONE seems to be speaking out like they're heroes for doing so. They are not heroes , they didn't say anything before, they should keep their silence now.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 12, 2017 14:57:22 GMT -5
No no, I don't mean that - I mean that each of those 4 scenarios are amplified when there's a power relationship involved. Having a power relationship without the advances is entirely different K. But what annoys me is that now EVERYONE seems to be speaking out like they're heroes for doing so. They are not heroes , they didn't say anything before, they should keep their silence now. Really? They live in fear of reprisal on top of being victimized trying to cope with the shame and helplessness of it all, and when inspired by someone who finally has the courage to speak out for themselves letting them know they are not alone in this and muster the courage to speak out, you tell them they should have stayed quiet? That kind of attitude is why so many are afraid to speak out in the first place. It's victimizing them for being a victim. Yeah that's the kind of thing Jesus would have said to a victim, right? -M
|
|
|
Post by The Captain on Nov 12, 2017 16:34:00 GMT -5
No no, I don't mean that - I mean that each of those 4 scenarios are amplified when there's a power relationship involved. Having a power relationship without the advances is entirely different K. But what annoys me is that now EVERYONE seems to be speaking out like they're heroes for doing so. They are not heroes , they didn't say anything before, they should keep their silence now. And just why should they keep quiet? So we never find out that Kevin Spacey is a creep and they're going to have to rewrite the last season of House of Cards around him not being there, so the fans don't get the ending they want? Or so we never hear about what a scumbag Louis C.K. is, because he's a really funny comedian and we like his shows and specials and were looking forward to his new movie? How about George Takei or Dustin Hoffman, respected actors with millions of fans, whose reputations have now been tarnished by individuals coming forward years later, when it would have been easier for them to just take that crap to their graves so we can continue to read Takei's tweets or watch Rain Man without being reminded of how they treated another human being? I'm asking, because those are all things I've seen written elsewhere. There are people less pissed off about Kevin Spacey being a creep and more about the fact that a stupid f#$@ing TV show won't have a proper ending, or that Ellen Page opened her mouth about Bret Ratner and that might impact the next Wonder Woman movie because of Gal Gadot taking a stand like a real hero instead of going along for just another paycheck. As the father of two daughters, I want them to grow up in a world where they never have to fear speaking up if a man, or woman, does something to them that makes them uncomfortable, hurts them, or threatens their education or livelihood unless they give in to the advances. They need to feel empowered to tell people in authority so that it never happens to anyone else and so they don't live in shame thinking there is something wrong with them or that they are to blame. I love you, man, but you couldn't be more wrong on this if you tried.
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Nov 12, 2017 18:15:05 GMT -5
K. But what annoys me is that now EVERYONE seems to be speaking out like they're heroes for doing so. They are not heroes , they didn't say anything before, they should keep their silence now. And just why should they keep quiet? So we never find out that Kevin Spacey is a creep and they're going to have to rewrite the last season of House of Cards around him not being there, so the fans don't get the ending they want? Or so we never hear about what a scumbag Louis C.K. is, because he's a really funny comedian and we like his shows and specials and were looking forward to his new movie? How about George Takei or Dustin Hoffman, respected actors with millions of fans, whose reputations have now been tarnished by individuals coming forward years later, when it would have been easier for them to just take that crap to their graves so we can continue to read Takei's tweets or watch Rain Man without being reminded of how they treated another human being? I'm asking, because those are all things I've seen written elsewhere. There are people less pissed off about Kevin Spacey being a creep and more about the fact that a stupid f#$@ing TV show won't have a proper ending, or that Ellen Page opened her mouth about Bret Ratner and that might impact the next Wonder Woman movie because of Gal Gadot taking a stand like a real hero instead of going along for just another paycheck. As the father of two daughters, I want them to grow up in a world where they never have to fear speaking up if a man, or woman, does something to them that makes them uncomfortable, hurts them, or threatens their education or livelihood unless they give in to the advances. They need to feel empowered to tell people in authority so that it never happens to anyone else and so they don't live in shame thinking there is something wrong with them or that they are to blame. I love you, man, but you couldn't be more wrong on this if you tried. Cap, If they had spoken up before, many would have been spared harassment and possible forced rape. A quick story- My wife had her son in Chile and was forced to leave him with a baby sitter during the day at a young age. She came to find out some time later that he was being neglected/abused by the sitter. Some time after she found someone else to care for him a person that worked nearby the sitters place told her he was glad that the son was no longer in the care of the sitter because he would hear her son screaming every day when he was there. My wife was beside herself asking why the person didn't speak up at the time. So the " heroes" that are finally speaking up get no credit from me for saying something years after the fact.
|
|
|
Post by The Captain on Nov 12, 2017 19:01:05 GMT -5
And just why should they keep quiet? So we never find out that Kevin Spacey is a creep and they're going to have to rewrite the last season of House of Cards around him not being there, so the fans don't get the ending they want? Or so we never hear about what a scumbag Louis C.K. is, because he's a really funny comedian and we like his shows and specials and were looking forward to his new movie? How about George Takei or Dustin Hoffman, respected actors with millions of fans, whose reputations have now been tarnished by individuals coming forward years later, when it would have been easier for them to just take that crap to their graves so we can continue to read Takei's tweets or watch Rain Man without being reminded of how they treated another human being? I'm asking, because those are all things I've seen written elsewhere. There are people less pissed off about Kevin Spacey being a creep and more about the fact that a stupid f#$@ing TV show won't have a proper ending, or that Ellen Page opened her mouth about Bret Ratner and that might impact the next Wonder Woman movie because of Gal Gadot taking a stand like a real hero instead of going along for just another paycheck. As the father of two daughters, I want them to grow up in a world where they never have to fear speaking up if a man, or woman, does something to them that makes them uncomfortable, hurts them, or threatens their education or livelihood unless they give in to the advances. They need to feel empowered to tell people in authority so that it never happens to anyone else and so they don't live in shame thinking there is something wrong with them or that they are to blame. I love you, man, but you couldn't be more wrong on this if you tried. Cap, If they had spoken up before, many would have been spared harassment and possible forced rape. A quick story- My wife had her son in Chile and was forced to leave him with a baby sitter during the day at a young age. She came to find out some time later that he was being neglected/abused by the sitter. Some time after she found someone else to care for him a person that worked nearby the sitters place told her he was glad that the son was no longer in the care of the sitter because he would hear her son screaming every day when he was there. My wife was beside herself asking why the person didn't speak up at the time. So the " heroes" that are finally speaking up get no credit from me for saying something years after the fact. But since they didn't say anything, because they were ashamed or traumatized or felt that the powerful men who forced them to do things or witness things or experience things might retaliate, and others later went through the same thing because those feelings kept the original victims from coming forward, they should just keep their mouths shut and act like it never happened? Nope. Just more victim blaming and shaming, making it their fault somehow, instead of placing the blame where it actually belongs. How about Harvey Weinstein doesn't use his position of power to do whatever he wants for decades? How about Louis C.K. doesn't whip his junk out and whack it in front of women he isn't in a relationship with? How about Kevin Spacey doesn't try to rape a 14 year-old boy? How about these and other men stop acting like they are entitled to have and take and do whatever they want because they have money or positions of power or the admiration of fans or because they've been treated their entire lives like they are special? And lastly, how about we stand by the victims and tell them that they were taken advantage of because we did nothing to empower them to come forward, that we really didn't care that this was going on because we just figured that's how Hollywood was and everyone was OK with it, that they are the ones who need to be counseled and protected, that they are the ones that need our sympathy, and that we are not going to stand idly by and allow future generations to be subjected to these types of actions by men who should know better but for some reason just don't care?
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 12, 2017 21:00:45 GMT -5
And just why should they keep quiet? So we never find out that Kevin Spacey is a creep and they're going to have to rewrite the last season of House of Cards around him not being there, so the fans don't get the ending they want? Or so we never hear about what a scumbag Louis C.K. is, because he's a really funny comedian and we like his shows and specials and were looking forward to his new movie? How about George Takei or Dustin Hoffman, respected actors with millions of fans, whose reputations have now been tarnished by individuals coming forward years later, when it would have been easier for them to just take that crap to their graves so we can continue to read Takei's tweets or watch Rain Man without being reminded of how they treated another human being? I'm asking, because those are all things I've seen written elsewhere. There are people less pissed off about Kevin Spacey being a creep and more about the fact that a stupid f#$@ing TV show won't have a proper ending, or that Ellen Page opened her mouth about Bret Ratner and that might impact the next Wonder Woman movie because of Gal Gadot taking a stand like a real hero instead of going along for just another paycheck. As the father of two daughters, I want them to grow up in a world where they never have to fear speaking up if a man, or woman, does something to them that makes them uncomfortable, hurts them, or threatens their education or livelihood unless they give in to the advances. They need to feel empowered to tell people in authority so that it never happens to anyone else and so they don't live in shame thinking there is something wrong with them or that they are to blame. I love you, man, but you couldn't be more wrong on this if you tried. Cap, If they had spoken up before, many would have been spared harassment and possible forced rape. A quick story- My wife had her son in Chile and was forced to leave him with a baby sitter during the day at a young age. She came to find out some time later that he was being neglected/abused by the sitter. Some time after she found someone else to care for him a person that worked nearby the sitters place told her he was glad that the son was no longer in the care of the sitter because he would hear her son screaming every day when he was there. My wife was beside herself asking why the person didn't speak up at the time. So the " heroes" that are finally speaking up get no credit from me for saying something years after the fact. I'm not really sure what that has to do with ... anything here at all.
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Nov 12, 2017 21:13:21 GMT -5
My wife's son was in torment when it could have been stopped by someone else at the time. Maybe you're right that nothing could have stopped Weinstein , as he was too powerful but something stopped him now. Too many people knew what was happening and did nothing. I am not blaming the victims but I am saying some of the people speaking out now while they are "safe" get no credit from me.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Nov 12, 2017 21:44:57 GMT -5
My wife's son was in torment when it could have been stopped by someone else at the time. Maybe you're right that nothing could have stopped Weinstein , as he was too powerful but something stopped him now. Too many people knew what was happening and did nothing. I am not blaming the victims but I am saying some of the people speaking out now while they are "safe" get no credit from me. I don't think they're looking for credit, or to be heroes... it seems like they're just seeking relief. I never got the feeling that the #metoo people thought of themselves as, or were seeking to be seen as, heroes but rather just people looking to finally be able to share the pain they felt they had to hide and there's nothing wrong with that.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Nov 13, 2017 14:06:23 GMT -5
No no, I don't mean that - I mean that each of those 4 scenarios are amplified when there's a power relationship involved. Having a power relationship without the advances is entirely different K. But what annoys me is that now EVERYONE seems to be speaking out like they're heroes for doing so. They are not heroes , they didn't say anything before, they should keep their silence now. Put on the brakes, pal. What's a hell of a lot more annoying to a lot of us is that so much of this bullying, molestation, and assault was and has been going on for so damn long. Just this morning spoke to a woman who'd been victimized by her own brother over 50 years ago who had never admitted it to anyone until she was in counseling a few years ago. She talked about the shame and guilt it engendered in her and how she kept pushing it back, burying it. It still haunts her. This is a far more common occurrence than you might like to think. Simply because something happened x-number of days, weeks, months or even decades ago doesn't mean that its effects somehow dissipate. Fear, guilt and pain do not have sell-by dates, and neither does heroism.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Nov 13, 2017 14:12:53 GMT -5
My wife's son was in torment when it could have been stopped by someone else at the time. Maybe you're right that nothing could have stopped Weinstein , as he was too powerful but something stopped him now. Too many people knew what was happening and did nothing. I am not blaming the victims but I am saying some of the people speaking out now while they are "safe" get no credit from me.Yeah, you frikking are. How do you feel about African-Americans who never said a word about all the lynchings that took place throughout the South for nearly a century? Maybe they should just "keep their silence now." Tell me, should Cherry and Blanton, the lowlife cowards who blew up four little girls at the 16ht Street Baptist Church not have not been prosecuted because they weren't able to put him on trial until nearly 40 years later? Maybe the prosecutors who were finally able to bring the case to a fair trial should have just kept their silence, right?
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Nov 13, 2017 14:18:37 GMT -5
My wife's son was in torment when it could have been stopped by someone else at the time. Maybe you're right that nothing could have stopped Weinstein , as he was too powerful but something stopped him now. Too many people knew what was happening and did nothing. I am not blaming the victims but I am saying some of the people speaking out now while they are "safe" get no credit from me. But nobody did speak out for that litttle boy, or for any of the other victims in question. So why should the victims remain silent just because there might have been others who could've/ should've come to their aid decades ago? Maybe there weren't others. Obviously your wife's little boy couldn't speak for himself then. Would you be pissed at him now if he had said something to you years later when he finally had the wherewithall to do so?
|
|
|
Post by Icctrombone on Nov 13, 2017 20:27:04 GMT -5
I don't disagree with the points you make, Prince Hal, but just because some of these accusers say it happened, doesn't make it so. Maybe i'm not explaining my point correctly. In the world of Hollywood, there are many people that are trying to take advantage of situations. Some of these people that claim they are victims are not. Some of them are opportunists.
|
|
|
Post by The Captain on Nov 13, 2017 20:45:24 GMT -5
I don't disagree with the points you make, Prince Hal , but just because some of these accusers say it happened, doesn't make it so. Maybe i'm not explaining my point correctly. In the world of Hollywood, there are many people that are trying to take advantage of situations. Some of these people that claim they are victims are not. Some of them are opportunists. Do you honestly believe these women have anything to gain from coming forward, other than public ridicule, shaming, and having their motives questioned? It's being turned around that somehow they're the attacker, that they're the ones persecuting these poor innocent men, and that they're the ones who are somehow going to benefit from bringing these things to the public. I really, really hope you stop posting in this thread, because each subsequent thing you write is more horrific than the last.
|
|
Roquefort Raider
CCF Mod Squad
Modus omnibus in rebus
Posts: 17,415
Member is Online
|
Post by Roquefort Raider on Nov 13, 2017 21:01:34 GMT -5
I regret that in all of this, the one TV personality who was caught on tape bragging about his assaulting women seems to be strangely above the fray. The press seems more interested in hounding bloody George Takei.
|
|