|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 29, 2014 8:33:40 GMT -5
The Spectre #9March-April 1969 (January 16, 1969) $.12 Cover Art: Nick Cardy Untitled 11 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Mike Freidrich (Writer), Jerry Grandenetti (Penciller), Frank Giacoia (Inker), no lettering or coloring credits. FC: The Spectre SC: The Voice SynopsisWhile helping Jim Corrigan round up a band of criminals, The Spectre ― distracted and upset by the judgment of the Voice in the previous issue ― loses control of himself and takes the life of a crook. When another cop protests, Spectre lashes out angrily, injuring the officer. Corrigan chastises his ectoplasmic counterpart for his rash actions and refuses to let him enter his body. The Ghostly Guardian attempts to force his way in, causing Jim to collapse. Summoned before The Voice once more, The Spectre is chained to the “Journal of Judgment” and condemned to investigate those named in its pages. Behind the ScenesEditorial control of The Spectre passes from Julius Schwartz to Dick Giordano with this issue, resulting in the series' abrupt change in plotline and format. The Good GuysThis is the first time in Earth-Two continuity that The Spectre deliberately takes a human life. For this act of “irresponsibility,” his mission on Earth is ended and he is chained to the Journal of Judgement with the promise that “if you handle the tasks assigned within this book ― you shall be allowed to resume your normal previous standing.” The Voice removes many of The Spectre's powers in this story but his placid role in this and the next issue make it difficult to determine the exact nature of those changes. When The Spectre tries to force his way into Jim Corrigan's body, the detective is rendered unconscious, but whether he has simply passed out temporarily or has become comatose is not clear. Either way, this is the final appearance of Corrigan in The Spectre.“Abraca-Doom” 9 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Denny O'Neil (Writer), Bernie Wrightson (Artist), no lettering or coloring credits. FC: The Spectre Intro: Nicholas Scratch, also called Beelzebub Intro: Frederick Foost, also uses the alias Count Lagos (dies in this story) The first case investigated by The Spectre is that of Frederick Foost, an incompetent stage magician. Foost is offered real magical powers and immortality by “Nicholas Scratch” in exchange for his soul. Signing the contract despite Spectre's warnings, Foost is given the “Abraca-Doom,” a mystic talisman that will endow him with magic, providing it never gets within six feet of the “Abraca-Death,” a second talisman given by Scratch to another sorcerer. Foost uses the Abraca-Doom to make himself absolute ruler of the small European nation of Marlovia. Disguising himself as “Count Lagos,” the former prestidigitator proves a wise and beneficent ruler. When Marlovia is attacked by a neighboring country, Foost again uses his powers benignly, stopping the invaders without taking their lives. He meets with the other nation's prime minister, the wielder of the Abraca-Death. Both men forfeit their souls and are consigned to Hell. The Bad GuysIt is not clear if Nicholas Scratch is in fact Earth-Two's Satan. If so, this is his first appearance in Earth-Two continuity. “Shadow Show” 5 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Mark Hanerfeld (Writer), Jack Sparling (Artist), no lettering or coloring credits. FC: The Spectre A thief named Hickey avoids the police by sticking to the shadows he has come to think of as his friends. Reaching the supposed safety of his room, Hickey finds The Spectre waiting to capture him. Points to PonderThis story is something of a non-sequitor, as it has nothing at all to do with the premise established in the book's earlier stories.
|
|
|
Post by Ish Kabbible on Oct 29, 2014 10:45:09 GMT -5
I very much enjoyed the Dick Giordano version of the Spectre along with the other books he was editing at this time. You now did not know what to expect when reading the Spectre and the stories were more compelling than the previous tales of an omnipotent "hero". Too bad it didn't last longer
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 29, 2014 11:37:38 GMT -5
We must have read different Spectre comics, Ish, because the Giordano-edited issues (all two of them) stink. I agree, though, that his other titles rocked.
Cei-U! I summon the divergent views!
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 30, 2014 8:38:04 GMT -5
The Spectre #10May-June 1969 (March 18, 1969) $.12 Cover Art: Nick Cardy “Footsteps of Disaster!” 7 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Mike Friedrich (Script), Jerry Grandenetti (Penciller), George Roussos (Inker), no lettering or coloring credits “Hit and Run!” 5 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Steve Skeates (Script), Jose Delbo (Art), no lettering or coloring credits “How Much Can a Guy Take?” 5 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Jack Miller (Script), Jack Sparling (Art), no lettering or coloring credits “Will the Real Killer Please Rise?” 8 pages Dick Giordano (Editor), Jack Miller (Script), Jack Sparling (Penciller), George Roussos (Inker), no lettering or coloring credits. FC (all stories): The Spectre SynopsesContinuing his investigation of those listed in the Journal of Judgment, The Spectre encounters a career criminal haunted by memories of an abusive father, a car thief who sacrifices his life rather than run over an innocent child, a shoeshine man nearly driven to crime by the taunts of a sadistic customer, and a murderous ventriloquist. Behind the ScenesThis is the last issue of The Spectre.Points to PonderThough for most of the issue The Spectre acts merely as observer and narrator, he claims the life of a would-be killer at the end of the third story. Paradoxically, it was his slaying of a true murderer that condemned him to investigate the listings in the Journal of Judgment in the first place!
|
|
|
Post by Rob Allen on Oct 30, 2014 11:19:54 GMT -5
No writing credits are available for this issue. The GCD has some, mostly garnered from contemporary issues of The Comic Reader. "Footsteps of Disaster" is by Mike Friedrich. "Hit and Run" is by Steve Skeates. "How Much Can a Guy Take?" and "Will the Real Killer Please Rise?" are by Jack Miller. www.comics.org/issue/22706/
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 30, 2014 14:18:38 GMT -5
Ah, they've updated them since the last time I looked. Thanks, Rob! I've updated the entry accordingly.
Cei-U! I summon the new data!
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 31, 2014 7:42:52 GMT -5
The Brave & the Bold #84June-July 1969 (April 22, 1969) $.12 Cover Art: Neal Adams, signed “The Angel, the Rock and the Cowl” 24 pages Murray Boltinoff (Editor), Bob Haney (Writer), Neal Adams (Artist), Joe Kubert (Inker, Sgt.Rock and Easy Company faces only), no lettering or coloring credits FC: Batman (also uses the aliases Pierre Leduc and Jack Pimpernel) SA: Winston Churchill Intro: Sgt. Frank Rock (see Cosmology note below) Intro: Cpl. Horace “Bulldozer” Canfield, Wildman (true name unknown) and other unidentified infantrymen of Easy Company (see Cosmology note below) Intro: Colonel Von Stauffen (first name unknown) Intro: Digby Palmer (dies in this story) SynopsisIn the city of London on the night of June 5, 1944 — the night before D-Day — Bruce Wayne encounters his former teacher, Digby Palmer, now an Allied intelligence agent. A V-2 rocket explodes near them, fatally wounding Palmer. With his dying breath, he tells Bruce “there is something odd about the wine at Chateaurouge.” Volunteering to complete Palmer's mission, Wayne boards a military transport plane bound for France. En route, he meets Sgt. Frank Rock and the “combat-happy joes” of Easy Company, to whom he introduces himself as “Jack Pimpernel.” Parachuting into the village of Chateaurouge, Wayne and Easy part ways. Posing as a Vichy wine merchant, Wayne visits the Chateaurouge winery, now being used as a Nazi command post by one Colonel Von Stauffen. Bruce sniffs out Von Stauffen's plan to smuggle nerve gas to the beaches of Normandy in Chateaurouge bottles. Sneaking away, Wayne contacts Sgt. Rock, whose mission is to destroy the bridge leading out of the village at dawn. Realizing he may have unintentionally led the Nazis to Easy's bivouac, Wayne becomes Batman and diverts their attention. Sneaking into the winery, Batman discovers the gas being removed in a hay wagon. Changing back to Jack Pimpernel, Wayne makes for the bridge. Though Rock tries to prevent it, Wayne detonates the charges prematurely, destroying the bridge, the hay wagon and the gas. The Allied invasion begins as planned. Twenty-five years later, Bruce Wayne is called to the Gotham City Museum where a famous statue of the archangel Gabriel ― the same statue Wayne's parachute had once caught on in Chateaurouge ― has resided since the war. Someone from the French village has come to claim it, someone with a German accent. Bruce, aware the statue is a fake, urges the curator not to turn it over. Von Stauffen appears. Before he can shoot Wayne, he is disarmed by none other than Sgt. Rock, who had trailed the fugitive Nazi from Europe. The statue, made of plaster-covered gold looted from Chateaurouge by Von Stauffen, will be returned to France. CosmologyAlthough Robert Kanigher ― the editor of DC's war titles during the Silver Age and the co-creator of Sgt. Rock ― always insisted his war characters' exploits did not occur in any of the company's super-hero universes, that does not preclude Rock and his men from having Earth-Two doppelgängers. This is therefore the first appearance of the Earth-Two Sgt. Rock and Easy Company. EDIT: A good ten years after writing the above paragraph, I can no longer recall where I read that quote from Kanigher, nor have I run across another such reference. It may be wisest, therefore, to take that particular factoid with the proverbial grain of salt. KM 11/4/14 ContinuityAlthough it is not identified as such, the story in this issue is part of the Earth-Two canon. Its events are referenced in the “Batman and Sgt. Rock” story in The Brave and the Bold #162, a comic explicitly set on Earth-Two. This is the first of four stories of the Earth-Two Batman set during World War II to appear in The Brave and the Bold. The stories are not published in chronological order. The timeline for these issues is: ● May 23-30, 1942 – Brave & Bold #146 ● June 5-7, 1944 – Brave & Bold #84 ● September 19-21, 1944 – Brave & Bold #167 ● Autumn 1944 – Brave & Bold #162 See the index entries for the individual issues for more information. The Good GuysBecause “Batman” stories were published continuously throughout the 1930s, '40s, '50s and '60s, there is no point at which it can be authoritatively said that the character segues from his Golden Age incarnation to his Silver Age persona. It is therefore impossible to pinpoint the exact title and issue number of the Earth-Two version's last appearance. Fashion WatchBatman's costume is depicted with detailing consistent with the 1970s version of the character rather than with the detailing it had in 1944. Only the omission of the yellow oval around his chest emblem differentiates this Batman visually from his Earth-One doppelgänger.
|
|
|
Post by Reptisaurus! on Oct 31, 2014 17:20:28 GMT -5
Although it was explicitely not intended as an Earth Two story at the time of publication, right?
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Oct 31, 2014 17:37:58 GMT -5
Right. And the next four or five Batman/Rock B&Bs are definitely set on Earth-One (or, I suppose, Earth-B). They won't explicity use the E2 bats until #146, after Boltinoff has left the editor's chair.
Cei-U! I summon the confusion!
|
|
|
Post by foxley on Oct 31, 2014 17:54:49 GMT -5
Right. And the next four or five Batman/Rock B&Bs are definitely set on Earth-One (or, I suppose, Earth-B). They won't explicity use the E2 bats until #146, after Boltinoff has left the editor's chair. Cei-U! I summon the confusion! Although Rock remembering Wayne's WWII service doesn't exactly make sense for stories set on Earth-One. But #124 starring Batman, Sgt. Rock, Jim Aparo, Bob Haney and Murray Boltinoff will always be my favourite B&B issue of all time.
|
|
|
Post by Reptisaurus! on Oct 31, 2014 19:41:09 GMT -5
Right. And the next four or five Batman/Rock B&Bs are definitely set on Earth-One (or, I suppose, Earth-B). They won't explicity use the E2 bats until #146, after Boltinoff has left the editor's chair. Cei-U! I summon the confusion! Although Rock remembering Wayne's WWII service doesn't exactly make sense for stories set on Earth-One. But #124 starring Batman, Sgt. Rock, Jim Aparo, Bob Haney and Murray Boltinoff will always be my favourite B&B issue of all time. Although they tried like hell to explain it away in the letter collumns - I think Neal Adams even said he was drawing his Batman a little older for that issue.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Nov 1, 2014 8:16:30 GMT -5
Justice League of America #72June 1969 (April 24, 1969) $.12 Cover Art: Joe Kubert, signed “13 Days to Doom!” 23 pages Julius Schwartz (Editor), Denny O'Neil (Writer), Dick Dillin (Penciller), Sid Greene (Inker), no lettering or coloring credits FC: The Atom, Batman, The Flash, Green Arrow, Green Lantern, Hawkman, Superman, teamed as the Justice League of America GS: Hawkgirl [of Earth-One], The Red Tornado A special meeting of the Justice League is disrupted by The Red Tornado, come to Earth-One on an urgent mission for the Justice Society. Before he can explain himself, however, the JLA rush off to answer an emergency signal from their Hawkman. The subsequent details of the case that preoccupies the League for the next thirteen days are irrelevant to the goal of this guide, except to note that it is Red Tornado's actions that save the day. Shamed by the uncharacteristic indifference and contempt with which they have treated the Tornado, a chagrined JLA now listen attentively as the android begins to speak of his mission. CosmologyAccording to this story, Earth-One and Earth-Two are “separated by a dark-zone barrier.” Points to PonderThe idea that the Justice League would completely ignore The Red Tornado for thirteen days, or that the Tornado would fail to mention his mission or its urgency during that period, strains credulity to its breaking point.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Nov 2, 2014 8:31:17 GMT -5
Justice League of America #73August 1969 (June 12, 1969) $.15 Cover Art: Joe Kubert, signed “Star Light, Star Bright ― Death Star I See Tonight!” 23 pages Julius Schwartz (Editor), Denny O'Neil (Writer), Dick Dillin (Penciller), Sid Greene (Inker), no lettering or coloring credits FC: The Atom, Batman, Green Lantern, Hawkman, Superman, teamed as the Justice League of America GS: Black Canary, Doctor Fate, Dr. Mid-Nite, Green Lantern, The Red Tornado, Starman, Wonder Woman, teamed with Superman as the Justice Society of America SC: Larry Lance Reintro: Superman (Clark Kent nee Kal-L) Intro: Aquarius Intro: The Council of Living Stars, all but Aquarius in flashback only SynopsisIn a “time beyond time,” a “space beyond space,” the Council of Living Stars — a species of intelligent energy beings with vast mystical abilities — sits in judgement on one of their own. Found guilty, the rogue named Aquarius is stripped of his powers and left to drift, barely alive, through the universe. On Earth-One, The Red Tornado relates the events of two weeks ago to the Justice League: While working at his observatory, Ted Knight sights the ghostly mist that was once Aquarius entering Earth-Two's atmosphere. Setting out to investigate as Starman, he is astonished when the mist siphons energy from his cosmic rod and assumes humanoid form. Deprived of his rod, Starman hurtles back to earth, crashing through the observatory's skylight just as Black Canary and her husband, Larry Lance, arrive. The Canary immediately sends out a JSA emergency signal. En route, several Society members encounter strange but temporary phenomena. These prove to be the work of Aquarius. After untold millennia in exile, the Living Star is now quite insane and, with the cosmic rod feeding him a constant stream of stellar energy, has enough power to carry out his plan to annihilate Earth-Two. None of the Justice Society members prove mighty enough to prevent the alien from casting a catastrophically powerful spell that sends Earth-Two and its inhabitants into a “spirit dimension.” Only the JSA itself, shielded by Doctor Fate's magic, remains behind. Fate reveals to the others that it is only their own memories of Earth-Two that keep the planet from being destroyed. But there is hope. In the instant before the blast, Fate sent Red Tornado to Earth-One to fetch the JLA. If he returns with them before the temporarily exhausted Aquarius regains his power, Earth-Two may yet be saved. The Justice League is horrified to learn their delay in hearing the Tornado's plea may have caused the death of a planet. CosmologyIt is not clear from this story if the Living Stars are native to the Earth-Two universe or exist outside of it. Black Canary and Larry Lance casually drop in on Starman — even bringing him a burger — in this story, the implication being that they live in the same city. Although this contradicts the “Starman and Black Canary” stories in The Brave and the Bold #61 and 62, which depict the Lances living in Park City and Ted Knight in Federal City, the two cities may be close together geographically or even share a “twin city” relationship like Minneapolis and St. Paul. Meeting MinutesA window display of Dr. Mid-Nite action figures similar in size to the original G. I. Joe toy is seen in this issue. Could this mean the Justice Society funds its operations with licensing fees? The Good GuysBecause “Superman” stories were published continuously throughout the 1930s, '40s, '50s and '60s, there is no point at which it can be authoritatively said that the character segues from his Golden Age incarnation to his Silver Age persona. It is therefore impossible to pinpoint the exact title and issue number of the Earth-Two version's last appearance. Fashion WatchThe Earth-Two Green Lantern is depicted on the cover of this and the following issue wearing the dark violet-blue cape last seen in Green Lantern #61 but wears the light purple version he wore in the previous JLA/JSA crossover in the interior pages. The cape's lining is colored a darker shade of green than usual in many panels of these two issues. The Earth-Two Green Lantern wears the horizontally-striped boots last seen in Justice League of America #22. There are no discernible visual differences between the two Supermen as depicted in this issue. Earth-Two's Wonder Woman wears Roman sandles instead of her red-and-white boots in this story, possibly because her Earth-One counterpart wore no costume during this period, eliminating the need to differentiate between the two visually.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Nov 3, 2014 8:44:30 GMT -5
Justice League of America #74September 1969 (July 24, 1969) $.15 Cover Art: Neal Adams “Where Death Fears to Tread” 23 pages Julius Schwartz (Editor), Denny O'Neil (Writer); Dick Dillin (Penciller), Sid Greene (Inker); no lettering or coloring credits FC: The Atom, Batman, The Flash, Green Arrow, Green Lantern, Hawkman, Superman, teamed as the Justice League of America GS: Black Canary, Doctor Fate, Dr. Mid-Nite, Green Lantern, The Red Tornado, Starman, Superman, Wonder Woman, teamed as the Justice Society of America SC: Larry Lance (dies in this story) Villain: Aquarius (dies in this story) SynopsisAs the Justice League and The Red Tornado enter the Earth-Two dimension, they find that the Justice Society and Larry Lance have survived their two week imprisonment thanks to Doctor Fate's magic. Aquarius panics at the appearance of more superhumans where, to the best of his knowledge, there should be none. He flees ― but not before using his own magical powers to mesmerize the weakened JSA and compel them to attack the Leaguers. Though the two Supermen seem evenly matched, the rest of the JLA have little trouble overcoming their hypnotized friends. Green Lantern of Earth-One uses his ring to locate and retrieve Aquarius. The lunatic alien defends himself by creating a huge sphere of radiation and hurling it at the heroes. Larry Lance, seeing his wife lying helpless in the sphere's path, overcomes Aquarius' enthrallment and throws himself between the sphere and the Canary. The sphere explodes, canceling the Living Star's hypnotic spell, restoring Earth-Two to its rightful position… and killing Larry. The two teams have little time for grief as Aquarius appears to jeer at the heroes, then attempts to flee to Earth-One. The two Green Lanterns trick the monstrous energy being into following them into a “negative energy universe,” where he is destroyed. (The Lanterns' rings protect them from the same fate.) Unable to bear life on Earth-Two without her husband, the Black Canary resigns from the JSA and accompanies the JLA back to Earth-One. CosmologyThe universe of negative energy seen in this issue may be the anti-matter universe of Qward but this cannot be confirmed. Meeting MinutesAt the conclusion of this issue, Black Canary decides to emigrate to Earth-One and join the Justice League. For that reason (and others that will arise in Justice League of America #219-20), this index will treat her from this point on as an Earth-One character and will no longer track her appearances. The Good GuysAlthough Starman is shown in flashback to last issue and his cosmic rod is still in the possession of Aquarius, he makes no actual appearance. It is not clear in this story if the Green Lanterns recover the cosmic rod after Aquarius' destruction or if Starman must either create a new one or own a spare. At any rate, he has it in hand in his next appearance in Justice League of America #83. Fashion WatchThe Earth-Two Green Lantern's boots have three yellow stripes instead of the usual two throughout this issue, excluding the cover. Points to PonderIt is extremely unlikely (not to mention illegal) that Larry Lance would be buried unembalmed on the grounds of Ted Knight's observatory as seen in this story. Presumably, the body was exhumed and given a proper funeral and burial after these events (though how the JSA explained Dinah Lance's disappearance is anybody's guess).
|
|
|
Post by zaku on Nov 3, 2014 10:37:06 GMT -5
CosmologyAlthough Robert Kanigher ― the editor of DC's war titles during the Silver Age and the co-creator of Sgt. Rock ― always insisted his war characters' exploits did not occur in any of the company's super-hero universes, that does not preclude Rock and his men from having Earth-Two doppelgängers. This is therefore the first appearance of the Earth-Two Sgt. Rock and Easy Company. Which version of Alfred did the stories use? Though the two Supermen seem evenly matched... In his later apperances, won't Superman of Earth 2 be considered weaker than his Earth-1 counterpart? Congratulations for you incredible work!
|
|