|
Post by Deleted on Aug 23, 2018 8:33:16 GMT -5
Let's make no mistake here: the faults with both #105 and 106 are Jack Kirby's, not Stan Lee's. Cei-U! I summon the properly laid blame! Knowing you -- I feel really sad to read this and I understand why ... the Batroc story was so mishandled and reading your comments and the comments of The Captain ... and I just feel numb of Jack not using Batroc properly. Batroc is my favorite villain for Captain America -- and Jack just killed that story on #105. You are right on all counts !!!
|
|
The Captain
CCF Mod Squad
Posts: 4,916
Member is Online
|
Post by The Captain on Aug 24, 2018 13:16:15 GMT -5
Let's make no mistake here: the faults with both #105 and 106 are Jack Kirby's, not Stan Lee's. At this point, Kirby was responsible for pretty much everything on the series: plotting, pacing, etc. Stan's job was basically to add dialogue to the pages Jack handed in. Oh, he might have said "Let's use Batroc, Swordsman, and Living Laser in the next issue" (the latter two characters Kirby didn't co-create or design and thus probably wouldn't have used without prompting) but that's probably it. That's why the short period between the conclusion of the Exiles storyline and the first Steranko issue are so dire: Kirby was bored and phoning it in. Swapping Kirby ouit for Steranko was Lee doing his job as editor. Cei-U! I summon the properly laid blame! Another thing to consider is that this is around the same time when Joe Simon was in the process of suing Marvel over the rights to the Captain America character; he filed his first suit in federal court in 1966, then his suit in the state of New York in 1967. One of the lynchpins to Marvel's defense was Jack Kirby being the "co-creator" of the character, with Kirby making an agreement with Marvel that Captain America was created as a work-for-hire to Martin Goodman and Timely, essentially signing away any rights he might have had to the character in order to help his employer win their case against Simon. Kirby was also upset about not being given more credit for the work he did in both creating characters at Marvel and in the plotting of stories. Stan Lee was the faceman for the company and received the lion's share of the accolades for the growth of Marvel, even though it was Kirby who designed the iconic looks for many of Marvel's classic characters from the era. As such, it is not hard to imagine that in 1968, after going through all of that drama, he may have been less than enthusiastic about working on Cap due to the events of the previous two years.
|
|
The Captain
CCF Mod Squad
Posts: 4,916
Member is Online
|
Post by The Captain on Aug 31, 2018 18:56:06 GMT -5
Captain America #107"If The Past Be Not Dead--" Writer: Stan Lee Art: Jack Kirby (pencils) and Syd Shores (inks) Cover Date: November 1968 SynopsisCaptain America is locked in a battle against shadowy, faceless enemies shooting at him from all directions with a variety of energy-based weapons. He is knocked down, and when he comes to, he sees Bucky perched on a tombstone whose epitaph reads "Here lies Bucky Barnes! He died...while Captain America lived!" Bucky tells Cap it was all his fault, as he saved hundreds but couldn't save his own partner. At this moment, Steve Rogers wakes up screaming, asking why he has to suffer that one mistake over and over again. He gets out of bed, wondering if he's going mad, then picks up the phone to call Doctor Faustus, a psychiatrist who had been treating him for about a month since they first met on a panel show. The doctor tells Steve to come in immediately, as he fears Steve's condition is more serious than he initially thought. Hanging up, Faustus calls to Ferret, a man in his employ, a man who is currently posing as a bellboy in Steve Rogers' building and who has the job of delivering Faustus' prescriptions to Steve, prescriptions known as "nightmare pills". Faustus, who knows that Steve is Captain America, is determined to drive him insane before destroying him, so he hands Ferret stronger pills to give to Steve after the appointment. Walking the street to his appointment, Steve wonders if he would have been better off staying frozen in the ice, as he feels out of place in the 1960's, a relic of a distant past. He catches a glimpse of a woman who looks like his beloved Sharon Carter, but she passes right by him without even saying hello, so he chases her down the street. Grabbing hold of her, he is confronted by not Sharon but a completely different woman, and his actions draw the attention of a nearby police officer; looking at the approaching officer, Steve begins to panic, feeling his nightmares are happening in broad daylight. As he runs away, the woman and the police officer, who is wearing a Red Skull mask, reveal themselves to also be working for Faustus. Reaching his doctor's office, Steve tells him of his nightmares, only to seemingly have one come to life right there, as he is beset by Nazi soldiers who attack him. Faustus brings Steve out of his reverie and writes him a new prescription, one he says will be dropped off for Steve at his home later. After Steve leaves, the "Nazis" come out from behind a wall, showing themselves to be just more actors in Faustus' employ and looking to get paid for their work, made more dangerous by Steve's fighting prowess. At home, Steve is sparring against a S.H.I.E.L.D. Plastoid, and as he finishes, Ferret (in his bellboy outfit) brings Steve his new pills. Taking one, Steve lies down for bed, only to wake up see in the mirror that he has aged during his slumber; more shocking is Bucky (a disguised Ferret) is in his apartment, urging Steve to join him on an important mission. Steve suits up as Cap and the two take off, racing away on a motorcycle to try to catch a plane carrying a missile, and Cap vows he won't let Bucky die this time, but he seems to fail yet again before collapsing in front of Faustus, who is at the location that "Bucky" led Cap to. Faustus is in the process of paying his actors when, all of a sudden, they are sent flying as Cap gets up fighting. He reveals he was suspicious of Faustus' pills, so he used an old-age mask and gloves supplied by S.H.I.E.L.D. to draw Faustus out so as to learn his plans. Faustus, a physically imposing man much larger than Cap, says he will destroy Cap with his bare hands, but Cap knocks him out with a single punch, dedicating the victory to Bucky as he walks away. My ThoughtsAny one who listened to the podcast I did with Crimebuster last year will know that I am a big fan of Doctor Faustus. I like his use of psychological warfare against Cap rather than trying to use brute force (although he did here, to no avail) or gadgets (which we'll see a prime example of next issue), as it is interesting to have a villain be more mentally-savvy than the hero and try to outwit him. Also, the bad doctor has a solid plan here. Faustus uses his network of actors (especially Ferret, who has managed to get close to Steve by posing as a bellboy at his building) to gaslight Steve, along with the use of the specially-formulated pills that Faustus keeps feeding him. This is quality villainy here, as someone that Steve trusts is using his secrets to try to bring him down. Unfortunately, the issue isn't without its flaws. Stan makes the best of the introduction of Faustus but violates the "show, don't tell" rule here, having Steve start seeing Faustus off-panel for a month. I know that books in this era were by and large written as one-offs without ongoing plot lines, but surely a couple of panels in each of the two previous issues (particularly the #106 stinker) could have been used to establish that Steve is seeing a psychiatrist to deal with his survivor's guilt and ongoing feelings of being a man out of time. It's something that modern comics fans such as myself have come to expect, as it would work better to sell the ongoing relationship and give some insight into how Faustus has been manipulating Steve. As well, the last five pages completely fall apart. Why on earth would Steve wake up as an aged man if the pills that Faustus was giving him were to induce nightmares? Wouldn't Ferret question why Steve was elderly when he showed up as Bucky and maybe alert Faustus that something screwy was going on? Sure, maybe the pills would make Steve think he had aged overnight, but the physical manifestation of the insanity makes zero sense? I know that Stan had to make something out of Kirby's art, but there is no reason for taking it in the direction it did. On a positive note to wrap up the review, I did love Faustus' bravado at the end, looking down on Cap as being smaller than him and thinking his size gave him an advantage in a fight. It's such a villain thing to do, underestimating the hero due to a physical size difference, and Kirby rightly ended that notion with Cap cold-cocking Faustus with one punch, as any prolonged altercation would have strained credulity. Faustus may have the brain, but he doesn't have the muscle. My Grade: B If it were any other villain, I probably would have gone "C" because of how things go off the rails at the end, but my love (irrational as it may be) for Doctor Faustus gives it a little higher grade than it probably deserves.
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Aug 31, 2018 21:11:59 GMT -5
I've always wondered just how much Hugo Strange was modeled after Doctor Faustus, not only in method of taking down their respective masked crusaders but even their basic look:
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Sept 1, 2018 6:43:12 GMT -5
Captain America #107 I consider this the greatest of all Captain America covers, utilizing nearly all of his dramatic hallmarks in an unforgettable way. Similarly, this earns my vote as Kirby's (and Giacoia) best cover of the Silver Age, surpassing numerous strong covers of Thor and the Fantastic Four (the usual candidates in the "best of Kirby" cover discussions). Grade: B+Not the average problems of a superhero, or monthly of that period, which explains why Cap was one of the quickly rising, "must-read" characters at Marvel by the end of the decade, with a human side just as sympathetic and deep as Spider-Man. Shores was Kirby's best inker, softening the Kirby tendencies to draw blocky, robotic forms, adding a softer side most of his inkers failed to apply (outside of Giacoia or Romita). Cap suffering from genuine PTSD--possibly nearing a total psychotic breakdown--was rare for comics of any kind in the 60s, and certainly not to be found (with any regularity) among the other members of the cape and tights set. Once again, Cap being a survivor with some rather serious issues elevated him above the gong-ho, patriotic stereotype he was accused of being by the clueless (or somewhat anti-American pride types) hardly familiar with stories and characterization like this. Cap was near-superhuman, but his mind and heart were never free from emotional agony. Nothing--not even er..."Captain America-ing" could offset the turmoil caused by his past. Although the story was a winner for the pure drama & visual strength of it all, at his point, Cap should never fall for anyone claiming to be Bucky (he was suspicious of Ferret, but still...), or such screaming levels of guilt (to a degree) since two months earlier, the events of The Avengers #56 (September, 1968) had Cap use Doctor Doom's time machine travel back in time to witness his final, deadly battle against Baron Zemo, which ended in Bucky's body being destroyed in the drone plane's explosion. At that moment, Cap was certain there was no way Bucky could have survived, so all future fake Buckys should have been something Cap could ignore outright, certainly erasing guilt over an event he had no ability to prevent in any way... ...but as we will see, that did not happen. Considering Cap's genuine negative reactions in this story, some fans have debated whether or not the time travel occurred before or after the events of this issue, but I've taken it as both stories matching their publication dates.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Sept 1, 2018 8:31:47 GMT -5
I've always wondered just how much Hugo Strange was modeled after Doctor Faustus, not only in method of taking down their respective masked crusaders but even their basic look: Well, considering Hugo Strange debuted in 1940 and Faustus in 1968. I'd say the latter had no influence on the former whatsoever.
Cei-U! I summon the temporal anomaly!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 1, 2018 9:20:39 GMT -5
I've always wondered just how much Hugo Strange was modeled after Doctor Faustus, not only in method of taking down their respective masked crusaders but even their basic look: Well, considering Hugo Strange debuted in 1940 and Faustus in 1968. I'd say the latter had no influence on the former whatsoever.
Cei-U! I summon the temporal anomaly!
True, but the Hugo Strange who created the Monster Men in 1940, though a great villain, bears almost no resemblance to the psychiatrist who battled Batman in the 70's, 80's and 90's.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Sept 1, 2018 10:11:23 GMT -5
Well, considering Hugo Strange debuted in 1940 and Faustus in 1968. I'd say the latter had no influence on the former whatsoever.
Cei-U! I summon the temporal anomaly!
True, but the Hugo Strange who created the Monster Men in 1940, though a great villain, bears almost no resemblance to the psychiatrist who battled Batman in the 70's, 80's and 90's. The '40s Strange was bald with thick glasses and a full beard, just like the '70s version. That's not "almost no resemblance," that's the exact same character. Or do yu mean something other than physical appearance?
Cei-U! I summon the bewilderment!
|
|
|
Post by thwhtguardian on Sept 1, 2018 10:27:35 GMT -5
True, but the Hugo Strange who created the Monster Men in 1940, though a great villain, bears almost no resemblance to the psychiatrist who battled Batman in the 70's, 80's and 90's. The '40s Strange was bald with thick glasses and a full beard, just like the '70s version. That's not "almost no resemblance," that's the exact same character. Or do yu mean something other than physical appearance?
Cei-U! I summon the bewilderment!
I meant more in the sense of characterization and threat type; the Golden Age Hugo Strange was more of your generic mad scientist but when he returned in the 70's he had a much greater psychological bend to him, so much so that to imagine him hanging out in a dilapidated castle and creating mutant monster men just no longer fit. At any rate, I never meant to truly imply that one was really cribbing off the other as like any similarities between characters from Marvel and DC through out the years it's definitely more just a sign of the zeitgeist of the times than out right borrowing...but it's fun to think about the similarities.
|
|
|
Post by Cei-U! on Sept 1, 2018 10:34:07 GMT -5
The '40s Strange was bald with thick glasses and a full beard, just like the '70s version. That's not "almost no resemblance," that's the exact same character. Or do yu mean something other than physical appearance?
Cei-U! I summon the bewilderment!
I meant more in the sense of characterization and threat type; the Golden Age Hugo Strange was more of your generic mad scientist but when he returned in the 70's he had a much greater psychological bend to him, so much so that to imagine him hanging out in a dilapidated castle and creating mutant monster men just no longer fit. At any rate, I never meant to truly imply that one was really cribbing off the other as like any similarities between characters from Marvel and DC through out the years it's definitely more just a sign of the zeitgeist of the times than out right borrowing...but it's fun to think about the similarities. Ah, okay. I misunderstood your earlier post. Thanks for clarifying.
Cei-U! I summon the mutual understanding!
|
|
The Captain
CCF Mod Squad
Posts: 4,916
Member is Online
|
Post by The Captain on Sept 9, 2018 14:00:27 GMT -5
Captain America #108 "The Snares of the Trapster" Writer: Stan Lee Art: Jack Kirby (pencils) and Syd Shores (inks) Cover Date: December 1968 SynopsisCaptain America is in his workout room, which has been specially designed by Tony Stark, running through his paces when the door opens and a man with a gun steps through. Distracted, Cap nearly gets hit by a missile, but the mystery man shoots it before it can harm Cap; the man reveals himself to be another of Fury's men, and he has come to Cap with a job. Cap barks at him, telling him to let S.H.I.E.L.D. agents earn their pay once in a while, and the man replies that he has never seen Cap like this before, to which Cap responds that he's sick of always being on call, which keeps him from having a real life. The agent tells Cap he's going to do him a favor, as the job is to find Agent 13, who S.H.I.E.L.D. has lost track of while on a mission, and Nick Fury figured Cap would want to be the one to bring her back. Handing Cap a homing device, the agent tells him it will beep as long as Sharon is alive, and it will beep louder the closer Cap gets to its mate, which Sharon is carrying. Sharon is indeed alive, but she has been captured and literally stuck to a board as a man interrogates her about Project Fireball. She tells him that she's never talk and her captor, revealed to be The Trapster, says that not even S.H.I.E.L.D. can stop him, so she should just tell him what she knows now. Following the signal across New York's rooftops, Cap comes to an abandoned ruin of a building as the homing device starts beeping wildly. Heading inside, he is almost hit by two jets of paste, letting him know who his foe is immediately. He dives down the stairs without touching them, in case they are coated with paste, only to become stuck as he grabbed a bar situated across the bottom of the steps. The Trapster approaches him, but Cap kicks him away before breaking the bar out of the wall to use as a weapon, although The Trapster escapes by pulling down the wall to create some separation before running off. Cap heads off to find Sharon, only to have the bar suddenly drop from his hand just as he falls through a trap door. Finding himself stuck to a large turntable, Cap is spun around mercilessly as Sharon is forced to watch on a video monitor. The Trapster figures she will crack if he tortures the man she loves, but all of the sudden, the control panel breaks, so he takes off to find Cap, who finds him first by bursting through a door. They fight, and just as Cap gains the upper hand, he is trapped by a tube that falls from above and begins filling with paste. Cap vows to fight on, so The Trapster taunts him by telling Cap that he is being paid to sabotage Project Fireball by the Red Skull. Seemingly on the verge of victory, The Trapster is shocked when the adhesive in the tube cracks and falls apart, releasing Cap, who proceeds to soundly beat his foe. Racing off to find Sharon, he finds that the individual stuck to the board is actually a LMD of Sharon, as the real Sharon has been hiding in the shadows. She explains that she had infiltrated The Trapster's lair as part of "the plan", using some chemicals provided by Tony Stark to dilute and weaken his paste. "The plan" was designed to draw out the name of The Trapster's employer, which wouldn't have been possible unless Cap was the one to do it. Cap notices that The Trapster has slipped away, but before he can chase him Sharon pulls him close in an embrace and tells him that he can always capture him tomorrow. My ThoughtsWe have the appearance of another non-traditional Cap villain show up in the form of The Trapster, although Stan does play off the fact that these two have met previously in Avengers #6, as Cap is easily able to identify who has captured Sharon by his choice of weaponry. This iteration of The Trapster is more akin to how Arcade would be written in later years, a master of traps and the like, rather than just a guy with a glue gun who is treated like a joke. It's also nice to see that he wasn't completely regarded as useless within continuity either, as The Red Skull hired him to do a job, but that job couldn't have been all that important, as this issue is the only mention of Project Fireball in Marvel's history. I find it odd how easily the S.H.I.E.L.D. agent slips into Steve's apartment and then his workout room. I get that he works for the world's preeminent spy organization, but I would have to imagine that Steve had a little bit better security on his living space to ensure that people didn't just happen to slip in and out whenever they wanted to. Also, I want to know how Tony Stark designed the workout space to have missiles flying around even though Steve lives in an apartment building around other people; seems a little careless and a lot dangerous, if you ask me. That said, I did enjoy Cap losing his temper with the guy, as his point about having S.H.I.E.L.D. use its own people to do their work seemed realistic; he's not on their payroll, and even though it is Agent 13 involved, it seems shoddy that Fury would immediately turn to Steve to bring her back. However, as we later learn, it was all just another one of Fury's Rube Goldberg plans to save the day. S.H.I.E.L.D. sends a Sharon Carter LMD to get captured so that Steve will think his main squeeze is in danger, but it's only because they feel the only way The Trapster will reveal who has hired him is if Steve gets captured and The Trapster gives up the information willingly. Oh, and we'll have the real Sharon easily infiltrate The Trapster's hideout, even being able to mess with his chemicals, so that Cap is never in any danger himself, and in the end, they find out who hired The Trapster (who gets away, probably while Cap is stunned to find out his girlfriend is in on Fury's stupid plan) but it's all for naught because we never hear about Project Fireball again in all of Marvel's history. My Grade: D
The complete disinterest Kirby had in the title is in full display here, as there is nothing inspiring or engaging about this story. In the end, the plot makes no sense and is ultimately forgotten despite the name-drop of the Red Skull as being interested in the outcome of the events, and Nick Fury is once again revealed to be a sadistic creep who apparently enjoys putting Cap in mortal danger for no good reason.
|
|
|
Post by tarkintino on Sept 12, 2018 14:03:52 GMT -5
As usual, Shores wrangled in Kirby again, and it makes for a fantastic visual treat. I loved this moment--Cap starting to resent being the superhero more than the man who is the essence of that hero. To varying degrees, this will be explored during the short Steranko run, and the Lee/Romita periods seen in #114 (where he feels he's more Cap than Steve) and #139 where Cap initially becomes a police officer as an undercover assignment, but considers going in that direction as Steve Rogers. At this point in Marvel history, I thought Paste Pot Pete / The Trapster's main weapon was too close to Zemo and his Adhesive X. While Paste Pot Pete pedated Zemo's introduction by a year, Zemo being one of Cap's deadliest foes (the man who killed Bucky) elevated him--and his arsenal--above the likes of the Trapster. That's typical Marvel visual bombast of the 60s, where they often stretched the limits of ordinarily mundane locations or objects, all to keep up with the kind of gadget overload seen on many a TV show and movie of the period. "Marvel Science" was perfectly acceptable where weapons or vehicles were concerned, but in a standard apartment...no. The Stark-outfitted room was not thought out as well as say, some Bond or Man from U.N.C.L.E. set ups. Fortunately for the Captain America title, it would outlive Kirby's time and go on to enjoy greater creative heights that took Cap out of "just" being that "Living Legend of World War II" with PTSD, and slowly building him up as a complex man (though still long-suffering) continuing to feel like an alien in the late 20th century. Grade: C-. My grade is slightly higher thanks to the nod to Cap wanting to be/do more than be a hero on call.
|
|
The Captain
CCF Mod Squad
Posts: 4,916
Member is Online
|
Post by The Captain on Sept 22, 2018 7:17:01 GMT -5
Captain America #109 At this time, I'm skipping a review of this issue, but I wanted to create a placeholder for it. This is a retelling of Captain America's origin (yet again), framed within the context of a conversation between Cap and Nick Fury. If time permits down the road, I may get back to this, but I would prefer to focus on new stories, especially since we are about to enter the brief but excellent Jim Steranko run on the book. Review for issue #110 should be posted within the next day or two.
|
|
|
Post by Prince Hal on Sept 22, 2018 11:29:52 GMT -5
I've always wondered just how much Hugo Strange was modeled after Doctor Faustus, not only in method of taking down their respective masked crusaders but even their basic look: I thought of Dr. Faustus... when I read B and B 200 and saw this guy (Brimstone):
|
|
The Captain
CCF Mod Squad
Posts: 4,916
Member is Online
|
Post by The Captain on Sept 23, 2018 18:06:04 GMT -5
Captain America #110 "No Longer Alone" Writer: Stan Lee Art: Jim Steranko (pencils) and Joe Sinnott (inks) Cover Date: February 1969 SynopsisOn a darkened street, a trenchcoat-wearing Steve Rogers lights a cigarette in a dark alley, and as he stands there, he hears a pounding from behind a nearby wall. All of a sudden, two enormous green hands burst through the bricks, revealing the Hulk, who is immediately set upon by some soldiers. They order Steve away for his safety, and he leaves, only to return in his costumed guise of Captain America. The solders cease their attack with conventional guns, instead using a cannon firing pure ionic energy that blasts the Hulk away. Cap tells the soldiers to fall back while he tends to the jade giant, while in the distance, he hears Rick Jones calling out to him, warning him to stay away. Distracted, Cap doesn't notice the Hulk rise, at which point the behemoth grabs him by the wrists as Jones yells to the Hulk to remember that Cap is a friend and not an enemy. Cap breaks loose with a flip-kick, and as the Hulk is stunned, Rick approaches the Hulk, only to be tossed aside in rage. Before delivering a death blow to the youth, Hulk leaps away, leaving Cap to pick up the battered boy, being drawn back to how his own carelessness years before led to Bucky's needless death. Cap takes Rick back to his apartment to rest, and as the boy sleeps, Cap looks out over the city, lost in his memories, until he hears footsteps behind him. Turning, he finds Rick wearing Bucky's costume, and he tells Rick no one must ever wear it, as he won't watch another partner die. Rick tells him that he isn't buying it and that everyone loses someone as some point, but as he turns to leave, Cap reconsiders and says he'll give Rick a shot. Just then, the Avengers Alarm goes off, so the two suit up and head into the sewers, led by the audio-lectronic map coordinates they are being sent, to enter a fight against the forces of Hydra. They engage the Hydra soldiers, but Cap is overcome with doubt partway through the battle, wondering why he let Rick come along. Telling Rick to run away into the tunnels, Cap knocks out the Hydra agent Rick is fighting with a throw of his shield, allowing the boy to escape, but Cap's concern only serves to get him captured after being hit by a stun blast. Coming to, he finds himself facing Madame Hydra, leader of the Hydra forces, whose plan it is to contaminate the city's water supply. Facing off against a Hydra agent in a Power Vest, which enhances the wearer's strength, Cap tricks his foe into breaking through the nearest wall to facilitate his escape. Elsewhere in the tunnels, Rick knows that Cap was worried about him in a way that Cap would not have worried about Bucky, so he doubles back to prove his worth to Cap, only to distract Cap (who had beaten the Power Vest soldier and was wearing it himself to get close to Madame Hydra). His ruse foiled, Cap is beset by Hydra agents, while others turn their weapons on Rick, who is quickly captured by Madame Hydra. She pushes him toward to the rushing torrent of the city's water supply, but Cap manages to grab the youth before he falls to his death. Cap tells Rick that while they were successful in their mission of thwarting Hydra's plan, Rick would have to follow orders without question in the future or Cap would no longer let the boy be his partner. As they leave the scene Rick vows that while he may never be the partner Bucky was, he would never stop trying. My ThoughtsFrom the outset, the reader can tell this is a new era for Captain America, as Jim Steranko used different layouts than the traditional splash page and the usual four- or six-panel pages that were the hallmark of Kirby's run, such as multiple small panels, smaller inset panels, or even art that wasn't in a traditional panel set-up. This is the top of the first page: And this is a portion of a later page, where the use of small panels allows a short moment (Cap and Bucky entering the sewers) to be conveyed as dynamic, rather than how it would likely have been done under Kirby's hand, which would have been one larger panel showing one or the other jumping down, leading to them both being in the sewer in the next panel. Steranko also played with the shape and form of the panels in a way that Kirby did not. In previous issues, nearly all of the panels were squares or rectangles with black borders, while here, Steranko did borderless panels (and just wait until next issue, where things get really out of the box, so to speak) or tried new things, like the following, where the second panel on the page has a border that follows the shape of Madame Hydra's boot from the first panel. Going back to the initial point above, another thing that is definitely different are the human shapes. Gone are the angular features of Kirby characters, and in are curves and natural-looking bodies. As well, Madame Hydra may be the first truly "sexy" woman depicted in a Cap book. She has a womanly figure and her face is more normally-shaped than the round-faced Sharon Carter that Kirby drew. Sharon Carter as drawn by Jack Kirby Madame Hydra as drawn by Jim Steranko As for the story, a couple of big things jumped out to me: 1. I'm not a huge Silver Age Hulk fan, but it seemed strange to me that Cap, even though he was in peak physical condition, was able to break free of the Hulk's grip and kick him aside so easily. 2. Poisoning the city's water supply is Hydra's plan? To what end, other than wanton death and destruction? For a psychotic maniac villain, this may be an OK plan, but I kind of expect more from Hydra. Lastly, while this book is a major leap forward in terms of style for Captain America, it also includes a moment I loathe to my core, and that is the introduction of Rick Jones to the Cap mythology. As many long-time members of CCF know, my hatred of Rick Jones is only matched by two other characters, those being Wolverine and Deadpool, but my dislike of them is due to overexposure, while I actively dislike the "character" of Rick Jones. He's a mouthy, petulant little punk who is nothing but a useless luck-sack who succeeds in spite of himself, not because of any actual skills or abilities he has. In this issue alone, Jones: 1. Nearly gets killed by the Hulk, only surviving when the Hulk loses interest, and this triggers Cap's survivors guilt related to Bucky. 2. Wakes up in Steve's apartment and decides it's a good idea to put on the costume of Steve's dead partner, then tells Steve to "get over it" when told to take it off. 3. Ignores orders multiple times, resulting in Cap getting captured and/or beaten not once but twice. 4. Almost dies a second time, this instance at Madame Hydra's hands, if not for a last-second rescue by Cap, which allows Madame Hydra and the other Hydra agents to get away. I keep telling myself that Cap is as annoyed by Rick Jones as I am, and he lets him come on missions in the hope that Jones will wind up buying the farm, figuring it won't actually affect him because while he liked and cared about Bucky, he will be doing the world a favor by getting rid of Jones. Sadly, I know this isn't the case, but it does help me get through the story a little easier. My Grade: A-Good story, great art, nice start to the post-Kirby era, but the presence of Rick Jones keeps me from giving it a full "A".
|
|