T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents at Tower Comics (reviews by shaxper)
Jun 22, 2017 16:34:33 GMT -5
Confessor likes this
Post by shaxper on Jun 22, 2017 16:34:33 GMT -5
UNDERSEA Agent #6 (March 1967)
(note: this scene never occurs within the issue. Too bad, as that sure looks like Renata Del Mar!)
The final issue of UNDERSEA Agent comes in at only 40 pages (last issue was 50 pages, and the regular length before that was 68), with fan letters far more interested in discussing Merman and T.H.U.N.D.E.R. than Davy Jones' adventures under the sea. As much as the letters page indicates that they are thinking up new directions for this title, you can see the writing on the wall. Even if Tower hadn't begun collapsing at exactly this point, UNDERSEA Agent was doomed.
Concordantly, while we get more Ray Bailey work on this issue, the writing shows very little respect for the actual premise of this series, two of the three stories having very little to do with the sea, one story giving Davy super powers in order to make him more relevant (and, apparently, missing the memo that he already HAS super powers for this very reason) and another leaving him out entirely.
In short, this is a lousy send off for what was at times the best thing Tower had going for it, but at least we get a little more Ray Bailey on the title.
"Doomsday In The Depths"
Script: Gardner Fox
Pencils: Gil Kane
Inks: Gil Kane
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
This one feels lifted from a Star Trek episode (though I couldn't tell you which) in that Davy ends up stuck in a lost civilization where he finds new love and is sorely tempted to start again and forget about his old life, but he is inadvertently thrust back and forced to live with a new sense of loss. It could have been moving, except that the romance is rushed and not earned, and this whole thing feels derivative of something (I just can't put my finger on what).
Plus there's Kane's artwork. Now, I'm generally an admirer of Kane's work, but what the hell happened here:
The entire story looks like this, with awkward, cross-eyed faces and disastrous inking. The script also calls for some images of far out technology, and Kane underwhelms on those, never providing as much detail as he should (perhaps because he didn't want to give himself more to ink?):
At times, the colorist tries to help out, utilizing contrast in place of fine detail, but it really really doesn't work:
We also have this moment at the beginning where Professor Weston conducts an experiment on Davy to give him greater resilience and strength that will allow him to endure the pressures at the bottom of the ocean. We get an awkward fight between Skooby and Davy to determine which one of them undergoes the procedure (this pointless fight never ends up going anywhere but took up a whole lot of space anyway), and then this power promptly gets forgotten, just as much as Fox clearly forgot Davy already has a super power at this point (magnetism).
And, by the way, if the experiment was a success, why can't Weston now perform the procedure on ALL agents of UNDERSEA?
"The Sea Stalag"
Script: ?
Pencils: Ray Bailey
Inks: Ray Bailey
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
It's The Great Escape, but only worse and in a fortress beneath the sea (and still governed by a Nazi jailer for some reason).
At least they remembered that Davy has magnetic powers this time (but not the new ones he just got in the last story).
There's truly nothing else to this one.
"Lobster Island"
Script: ?
Pencils: Ray Bailey
Inks: Ray Bailey
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
A thoroughly generic superhero story in which a scientist, spurned by the world and deformed by a lab accident, retreats to a remote island to plan his revenge upon the world, this time with mutated lobsters.
If Merman's first ever solo story was intended to somehow sell us on the character, it doesn't happen. He's thoroughly generic in fighting the lobsters and offering a bad wisecrack at the end. Really nothing to this story either.
And there it is, the end of UNDERSEA Agent. Davy Jones will get one more story in T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents #13 (perhaps the story missing from this 40 page issue), but that will be it for the original run. A crying shame, really.
(note: this scene never occurs within the issue. Too bad, as that sure looks like Renata Del Mar!)
The final issue of UNDERSEA Agent comes in at only 40 pages (last issue was 50 pages, and the regular length before that was 68), with fan letters far more interested in discussing Merman and T.H.U.N.D.E.R. than Davy Jones' adventures under the sea. As much as the letters page indicates that they are thinking up new directions for this title, you can see the writing on the wall. Even if Tower hadn't begun collapsing at exactly this point, UNDERSEA Agent was doomed.
Concordantly, while we get more Ray Bailey work on this issue, the writing shows very little respect for the actual premise of this series, two of the three stories having very little to do with the sea, one story giving Davy super powers in order to make him more relevant (and, apparently, missing the memo that he already HAS super powers for this very reason) and another leaving him out entirely.
In short, this is a lousy send off for what was at times the best thing Tower had going for it, but at least we get a little more Ray Bailey on the title.
"Doomsday In The Depths"
Script: Gardner Fox
Pencils: Gil Kane
Inks: Gil Kane
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
This one feels lifted from a Star Trek episode (though I couldn't tell you which) in that Davy ends up stuck in a lost civilization where he finds new love and is sorely tempted to start again and forget about his old life, but he is inadvertently thrust back and forced to live with a new sense of loss. It could have been moving, except that the romance is rushed and not earned, and this whole thing feels derivative of something (I just can't put my finger on what).
Plus there's Kane's artwork. Now, I'm generally an admirer of Kane's work, but what the hell happened here:
The entire story looks like this, with awkward, cross-eyed faces and disastrous inking. The script also calls for some images of far out technology, and Kane underwhelms on those, never providing as much detail as he should (perhaps because he didn't want to give himself more to ink?):
At times, the colorist tries to help out, utilizing contrast in place of fine detail, but it really really doesn't work:
We also have this moment at the beginning where Professor Weston conducts an experiment on Davy to give him greater resilience and strength that will allow him to endure the pressures at the bottom of the ocean. We get an awkward fight between Skooby and Davy to determine which one of them undergoes the procedure (this pointless fight never ends up going anywhere but took up a whole lot of space anyway), and then this power promptly gets forgotten, just as much as Fox clearly forgot Davy already has a super power at this point (magnetism).
And, by the way, if the experiment was a success, why can't Weston now perform the procedure on ALL agents of UNDERSEA?
"The Sea Stalag"
Script: ?
Pencils: Ray Bailey
Inks: Ray Bailey
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
It's The Great Escape, but only worse and in a fortress beneath the sea (and still governed by a Nazi jailer for some reason).
At least they remembered that Davy has magnetic powers this time (but not the new ones he just got in the last story).
There's truly nothing else to this one.
"Lobster Island"
Script: ?
Pencils: Ray Bailey
Inks: Ray Bailey
Colors: ?
Letters: ?
grade: C-
A thoroughly generic superhero story in which a scientist, spurned by the world and deformed by a lab accident, retreats to a remote island to plan his revenge upon the world, this time with mutated lobsters.
If Merman's first ever solo story was intended to somehow sell us on the character, it doesn't happen. He's thoroughly generic in fighting the lobsters and offering a bad wisecrack at the end. Really nothing to this story either.
And there it is, the end of UNDERSEA Agent. Davy Jones will get one more story in T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents #13 (perhaps the story missing from this 40 page issue), but that will be it for the original run. A crying shame, really.